Lazy people
Author
Discussion

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
I've opened my email this morning to find a rant from a friend from evening classes some years ago. He gave me this link:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2189973/Kw...

He's just returned home from work after an all but 14 hours shift despite being contracted for nine. He gets no overtime. There is no parking at his company so has to get a bus in to work. There is an early bus he gets when working closer to 9 hours. It is full of people going to work, cleanears, shift workers, that sort of thing.

To cut some of the rant from his email, his questions amounted to:

How many jobs do you think those in the 'class of 2010' have held down over the years?

How many of them have had to queue for buses at 5.15 in the morning after a long night's work (coming out of a club and taxis refusing to run you home 'cause you've got vomit down your designer dress doesn't count).

How many have actually seen a worker?

We both believe that there should be restrictions on who can become an MP. Enforcement will have to be stricter than the one banning those who are mad.

Over a post class pub pint we came up with this 3-point plan:

Firstly, they should have had to have held down a job for ten years. And a real one. One where decisions matter, where a mistake could cost you your income. (Editor of politically biased magazines not couned. My addition.)

Or, alternatively, they could have run their own business for 10 years, starting it from scratch without daddy paying for it.

Then, after that ten years is over, they have to swop.

Only then can they be considered suitable as an MP.

The chap is an IT engineer and his role is to go to premises when the IT desk cannot help and a hands-on approach is required. This can be hardware or software related so his qualifications are legion. He goes all over the south east, less London, in a van. He gets good money but does five nights a week with three off then five days with some off. He is also on call-out on his days off, although he gets paid extra for that.

None of us want to see our taxes wasted on the lazy but to suggest that laziness is endemic in workers is farcical. A few years ago, pre-recession, there was a report which said that the British work longer hours that anywhere in Europe, and much longer than the EU average.

turbobloke

117,580 posts

291 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
That's a coincidence, just before scanning NP&E I was reading this:

http://www.express.co.uk/posts/view/340517/MPs-bra...

As to the story being an exaggeration, far from it.

Employer shock as seven jobless recruits fail to show up because of rain

If it's not raining and shirkers somehow manage to get a job and stroll in to work, they need to be careful about farcebook and ttter - at least if they want to keep their job.

Tweeting about a bad day at work can get you the sack

Dixie68

3,091 posts

218 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
I've long been of the opinion that to be an MP you should have first in some way worked for your country on the front line - NOT an office-based Civil Servant or graduate in 'political sciences' or whatever bks they do at Oxbridge. Either a nurse, copper, military, fireman, whatever - someone who has seen the worst aspects of life and may actually have an idea of what people go through day-to-day.

phil-sti

2,983 posts

210 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Lots of companies now have social networking policies. I have made sure I have nobody I work with in my Facebook, everything is locked down and private. I make sure that if you search my name on google very little comes up and it can't link back to my twitter as twitter is near impossible to make private.

turbobloke

117,580 posts

291 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Dixie68 said:
I've long been of the opinion that to be an MP you should have first in some way worked for your country on the front line - NOT an office-based Civil Servant or graduate in 'political sciences' or whatever bks they do at Oxbridge. Either a nurse, copper, military, fireman, whatever - someone who has seen the worst aspects of life and may actually have an idea of what people go through day-to-day.
Agreed about the life and experience point and there's some heavy duty irony in MPs criticising others for being useless while many of our equally useless MPs live on Planet Zorg, but what these young MPs are saying has more than a grain of truth to it regardless of their background.

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
I've opened my email this morning to find a rant from a friend from evening classes some years ago. He gave me this link:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2189973/Kw...

He's just returned home from work after an all but 14 hours shift despite being contracted for nine. He gets no overtime. There is no parking at his company so has to get a bus in to work. There is an early bus he gets when working closer to 9 hours. It is full of people going to work, cleanears, shift workers, that sort of thing.

To cut some of the rant from his email, his questions amounted to:

How many jobs do you think those in the 'class of 2010' have held down over the years?

How many of them have had to queue for buses at 5.15 in the morning after a long night's work (coming out of a club and taxis refusing to run you home 'cause you've got vomit down your designer dress doesn't count).

How many have actually seen a worker?

We both believe that there should be restrictions on who can become an MP. Enforcement will have to be stricter than the one banning those who are mad.

Over a post class pub pint we came up with this 3-point plan:

Firstly, they should have had to have held down a job for ten years. And a real one. One where decisions matter, where a mistake could cost you your income. (Editor of politically biased magazines not couned. My addition.)

Or, alternatively, they could have run their own business for 10 years, starting it from scratch without daddy paying for it.

Then, after that ten years is over, they have to swop.

Only then can they be considered suitable as an MP.

The chap is an IT engineer and his role is to go to premises when the IT desk cannot help and a hands-on approach is required. This can be hardware or software related so his qualifications are legion. He goes all over the south east, less London, in a van. He gets good money but does five nights a week with three off then five days with some off. He is also on call-out on his days off, although he gets paid extra for that.

None of us want to see our taxes wasted on the lazy but to suggest that laziness is endemic in workers is farcical. A few years ago, pre-recession, there was a report which said that the British work longer hours that anywhere in Europe, and much longer than the EU average.
There's no parking at his company yet he goes everywhere in a van?

Why can't he take the van home? Or swap the space for his car when he gets to work?

Working 5 hours overtime for nothing makes him a mug, it does not make everyone who doesn't do it lazy.

Putting those conditions on the role of MP would mean that even fewer people would bother. You may feel that no representation would be better than what we have. I don't.

Simplistic bks, really.

hedgefinder

3,418 posts

201 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
is your mates name MOSS ?

stuartmmcfc

8,775 posts

223 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
on the conditions for being an MP, I've always thought that they should have to spend 2 weeks out of every year working for their constituencies largest employer to get an idea of the life their voters lead.

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
No, it's much simpler than that.

Anyone who wants to be an MP should be barred from doing so.

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Working 5 hours over is keeping someone else out of a job wink . I agree MP's should have worked in the real world before they can stand, going School, Uni, Party role, MP means you get people who's sole claim is that they are bland enough or popular enough to get through all the selection gates.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Pothole said:
There's no parking at his company yet he goes everywhere in a van?

Why can't he take the van home? Or swap the space for his car when he gets to work?

Working 5 hours overtime for nothing makes him a mug, it does not make everyone who doesn't do it lazy.

Putting those conditions on the role of MP would mean that even fewer people would bother. You may feel that no representation would be better than what we have. I don't.

Simplistic bks, really.
He takes it home when on call.

As for working the extra hours, he had a call to Sussex/Hants border and then had to drive back. He gets paid for the coverage. I'll tell him you've taken an interest in his welfare.

As for working for nothing, I had to work 9 12-hours shifts though late July - early September one summer. I didn't get paid for the overtime. I had the choice of telling my bosses to got get some stuffing or getting my pension.

I was on call 24/7 for two years, without pay, and got called into work at least once a month, probably 20 times each year. I was also available for advice in the matters that I was an expert on. No pay for any of that.

I don't know what your job is but if there's no union to protect you and you have a pension that is all but worthless if you jack your job in, you have to take it.

I think you missed the point of the suggestion I made. It wasn't a serious template. More a criticism of MPs who have no idea what life is really like for those of us who have, or had in my case, to work long hours, with no overtime payments.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,032 posts

279 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
No, it's much simpler than that.

Anyone who wants to be an MP should be barred from doing so.
I sent that to my mate when I read that. Much better than our suggestion.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
No, it's much simpler than that.

Anyone who wants to be an MP should be barred from doing so.
That. Selections from the Jury Service roll only.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Dixie68 said:
I've long been of the opinion that to be an MP you should have first in some way worked for your country on the front line - NOT an office-based Civil Servant or graduate in 'political sciences' or whatever bks they do at Oxbridge. Either a nurse, copper, military, fireman, whatever - someone who has seen the worst aspects of life and may actually have an idea of what people go through day-to-day.
but most people, day-to-day, don't have any need for the the NHS, the police, the fire service, or the army,,,

the idea that you need certain 'real world' experience to become an MP is stupid. It's stupid because there is no such thing as the real world. My experience of life as a PhD graduate who has worked as a scientist doing research in universities across the UK and in Europe is wholly different from the experience of someone who works in the city, or who left school at 16 and worked their way up through a company, or of someone who didn't and is a cleaner. but all of lives are 'real' for us. they just provide different day-to-day experiences.

I am sure that people from all walks of life have something to contribute to the governing of our country - even if they have only worked in politics (I didn't say I was sure what it was they had to contribute...).

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
actually I am very much in favour of governance by random selection as with juries... with a sensibly organised civil service and suitable advisors I think it would work quite well. certainly long-term decisions would be easier without pointless cross-party bickering.

an alternative, I think, is to outlaw political parties. keep the commons, keep the house of lords, just elect your local MP as an independent

Dixie68

3,091 posts

218 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Use Psychology said:
Dixie68 said:
I've long been of the opinion that to be an MP you should have first in some way worked for your country on the front line - NOT an office-based Civil Servant or graduate in 'political sciences' or whatever bks they do at Oxbridge. Either a nurse, copper, military, fireman, whatever - someone who has seen the worst aspects of life and may actually have an idea of what people go through day-to-day.
but most people, day-to-day, don't have any need for the the NHS, the police, the fire service, or the army,,,

the idea that you need certain 'real world' experience to become an MP is stupid. It's stupid because there is no such thing as the real world. My experience of life as a PhD graduate who has worked as a scientist doing research in universities across the UK and in Europe is wholly different from the experience of someone who works in the city, or who left school at 16 and worked their way up through a company, or of someone who didn't and is a cleaner. but all of lives are 'real' for us. they just provide different day-to-day experiences.

I am sure that people from all walks of life have something to contribute to the governing of our country - even if they have only worked in politics (I didn't say I was sure what it was they had to contribute...).
I disagree. In my job as a well-paid rail engineer my life experiences are different from those of someone who is, say, a bus driver. You will have had different experiences as a scientist than I will have had or the bus driver will have had. My point about people working in such areas as policing or nursing is that because of their jobs they see a wide range of personal circumstances and experiences.

munroman

1,908 posts

215 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Use Psychology said:
but most people, day-to-day, don't have any need for the the NHS, the police, the fire service, or the army,,,

the idea that you need certain 'real world' experience to become an MP is stupid. It's stupid because there is no such thing as the real world. My experience of life as a PhD graduate who has worked as a scientist doing research in universities across the UK and in Europe is wholly different from the experience of someone who works in the city, or who left school at 16 and worked their way up through a company, or of someone who didn't and is a cleaner. but all of lives are 'real' for us. they just provide different day-to-day experiences.

I am sure that people from all walks of life have something to contribute to the governing of our country - even if they have only worked in politics (I didn't say I was sure what it was they had to contribute...).
My concern is that we have ended up with a homogenised group of MP's, PPE degree at Oxbridge, job as a 'researcher' for an MP, and then parachuted into a vacant seat, often with no connection to the constituency they represent.
Their entire career depends on loyalty to the 'Party', so a strong leader can gain undue influence, as dissenters, could, in effect, end up losing their livelihoods and future career prospects.

As for 'Real World Experience', it does concern me that Teachers can spend their entire lives within the Education System, which, let's face it, is not exactly 'Real World' from the stories I hear from friends who are teachers....

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
but as I said, there is no such thing as the 'real world'.

do police really get an accurate picture of society through dealing with a broad cross section of it? Or do they spend most of their time interacting chiefly with the dregs of it?

do doctors and nurses get a good picture too? Or do they mostly spend their time treating old people.

etc. etc.

I agree 100 % with your concerns about the homogeneity of MPs... I think there is only 1 scientist from 600...

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
Pothole said:
There's no parking at his company yet he goes everywhere in a van?

Why can't he take the van home? Or swap the space for his car when he gets to work?

Working 5 hours overtime for nothing makes him a mug, it does not make everyone who doesn't do it lazy.

Putting those conditions on the role of MP would mean that even fewer people would bother. You may feel that no representation would be better than what we have. I don't.

Simplistic bks, really.
He takes it home when on call.

As for working the extra hours, he had a call to Sussex/Hants border and then had to drive back. He gets paid for the coverage. I'll tell him you've taken an interest in his welfare.

As for working for nothing, I had to work 9 12-hours shifts though late July - early September one summer. I didn't get paid for the overtime. I had the choice of telling my bosses to got get some stuffing or getting my pension.

I was on call 24/7 for two years, without pay, and got called into work at least once a month, probably 20 times each year. I was also available for advice in the matters that I was an expert on. No pay for any of that.

I don't know what your job is but if there's no union to protect you and you have a pension that is all but worthless if you jack your job in, you have to take it.

I think you missed the point of the suggestion I made. It wasn't a serious template. More a criticism of MPs who have no idea what life is really like for those of us who have, or had in my case, to work long hours, with no overtime payments.
Most MPs work very long hours. Their pay is pretty crap compared to the Private sector.

Damn you and your mate for making me defend MPs!

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Saturday 18th August 2012
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
I've opened my email this morning to find a rant from a friend from evening classes some years ago. He gave me this link:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2189973/Kw...

He's just returned home from work after an all but 14 hours shift despite being contracted for nine. He gets no overtime. There is no parking at his company so has to get a bus in to work. There is an early bus he gets when working closer to 9 hours. It is full of people going to work, cleanears, shift workers, that sort of thing.

To cut some of the rant from his email, his questions amounted to:

How many jobs do you think those in the 'class of 2010' have held down over the years?

How many of them have had to queue for buses at 5.15 in the morning after a long night's work (coming out of a club and taxis refusing to run you home 'cause you've got vomit down your designer dress doesn't count).

How many have actually seen a worker?

We both believe that there should be restrictions on who can become an MP. Enforcement will have to be stricter than the one banning those who are mad.

Over a post class pub pint we came up with this 3-point plan:

Firstly, they should have had to have held down a job for ten years. And a real one. One where decisions matter, where a mistake could cost you your income. (Editor of politically biased magazines not couned. My addition.)

Or, alternatively, they could have run their own business for 10 years, starting it from scratch without daddy paying for it.

Then, after that ten years is over, they have to swop.

Only then can they be considered suitable as an MP.

The chap is an IT engineer and his role is to go to premises when the IT desk cannot help and a hands-on approach is required. This can be hardware or software related so his qualifications are legion. He goes all over the south east, less London, in a van. He gets good money but does five nights a week with three off then five days with some off. He is also on call-out on his days off, although he gets paid extra for that.

None of us want to see our taxes wasted on the lazy but to suggest that laziness is endemic in workers is farcical. A few years ago, pre-recession, there was a report which said that the British work longer hours that anywhere in Europe, and much longer than the EU average.
Perhaps you should try a few facts mixed in with your opinions and anecdotes:

MP's work on average 71 hours per week for £65k.

http://www.public-standards.gov.uk/Library/Backgro...