War Graves of Nazis being Looted
War Graves of Nazis being Looted
Author
Discussion

Fishtigua

Original Poster:

9,786 posts

226 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
In many parts of Europe, the sale of Nazi memorabilia is illegal. In Britain there is a large market for it. Unfortunately in Eastern Europe, grave robbing is now taking place for these artifacts.

I have some odds and sods I've dug-up in Guernsey, certainly not from graves.

Caveat emptor.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/g...

telecat

8,528 posts

272 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Typical unfortunately. How many Sites in Egypt and China were looted before Archaeologists got to them. Turkey and Greece have similar Problems. Greece only recently has gotten a handle on it and even then Artefacts "disappear".

Fishtigua

Original Poster:

9,786 posts

226 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
telecat said:
Typical unfortunately. How many Sites in Egypt and China were looted before Archaeologists got to them. Turkey and Greece have similar Problems. Greece only recently has gotten a handle on it and even then Artefacts "disappear".
Living sons and daughters still looking for fathers though.....

jmorgan

36,010 posts

315 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
It was terrible what happened on the march into the USSR and the Red Army rampage to Berlin and there was no love lost. I wonder if that still plays a part, probably just greed today. I bet a ready market will not help.

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Maybe next time don't invade other people's countries if you don't want your long dead corpse violated?

CaptainSlow

13,179 posts

243 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Motorrad said:
Maybe next time don't invade other people's countries if you don't want your long dead corpse violated?
Fair for the politcal masters but not for the common soldier.

pokethepope

2,667 posts

219 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Motorrad said:
Maybe next time don't invade other people's countries if you don't want your long dead corpse violated?
We invaded France and Germany (and others) in WWII, are the graves of British soldiers in these countries fair game then?

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
pokethepope said:
Motorrad said:
Maybe next time don't invade other people's countries if you don't want your long dead corpse violated?
We invaded France and Germany (and others) in WWII, are the graves of British soldiers in these countries fair game then?
mmmmmm - maybe you could argue for Germany, but we didn't invade France unless you believe the Nazi occupation and Vichy regime had a legitimacy...

M.

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
telecat said:
Typical unfortunately. How many Sites in Egypt and China were looted before Archaeologists got to them. Turkey and Greece have similar Problems. Greece only recently has gotten a handle on it and even then Artefacts "disappear".
So 'archaeologists' are okay to open graves and pyramids and shrines etc and take the contents back to their own country?

But 'looters' who do the same thing are scorned??



How does one tell the difference???? confused

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
King Herald said:
telecat said:
Typical unfortunately. How many Sites in Egypt and China were looted before Archaeologists got to them. Turkey and Greece have similar Problems. Greece only recently has gotten a handle on it and even then Artefacts "disappear".
So 'archaeologists' are okay to open graves and pyramids and shrines etc and take the contents back to their own country?

But 'looters' who do the same thing are scorned??



How does one tell the difference???? confused
Most archaeologists record what they recover, in context for history.

Looters tend to dig it up with a JCB and stick it on eBay for a profit! smile

M

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
marcosgt said:
Most archaeologists record what they recover, in context for history.

Looters tend to dig it up with a JCB and stick it on eBay for a profit! smile

M
But the results are usually the same for the grave that was violated?

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
pokethepope said:
We invaded France and Germany (and others) in WWII, are the graves of British soldiers in these countries fair game then?
All I can say is that my Grandfather and many of his colleagues had zero qualms about removing 'souvenirs' from dead enemy soldiers. I see no difference when it happens.

XCP

17,763 posts

259 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Motorrad said:
All I can say is that my Grandfather and many of his colleagues had zero qualms about removing 'souvenirs' from dead enemy soldiers. I see no difference when it happens.
My mothers uncle was in the Army ( Infantry) from 1939 -45.
He also had a lot of German watches.
I don't think the two facts were unrelated.

telecat

8,528 posts

272 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
King Herald said:
marcosgt said:
Most archaeologists record what they recover, in context for history.

Looters tend to dig it up with a JCB and stick it on eBay for a profit! smile

M
But the results are usually the same for the grave that was violated?
Generally Archaeologists lay the bodies to rest in accordance with the tradition's of the locals or their descendants. In cases where the descendants are within a few generations then if possible the descendants are contacted. Hence when Battlefields or Aircraft of the first and second world wars are "disturbed" the remains found if identified are moved to a Military Cemetery or back to their relatives. Warships tend to be left as a "War Grave".

pokethepope

2,667 posts

219 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
Motorrad said:
All I can say is that my Grandfather and many of his colleagues had zero qualms about removing 'souvenirs' from dead enemy soldiers. I see no difference when it happens.
I think theres a big difference between a solder suffering the horrors of war taking a watch from a dead enemy on the battlefield, and some knob digging up a dead solider that has been laying in a war cemetery for more than 50 years just to make a quick buck.

CaptainSlow

13,179 posts

243 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
pokethepope said:
Motorrad said:
All I can say is that my Grandfather and many of his colleagues had zero qualms about removing 'souvenirs' from dead enemy soldiers. I see no difference when it happens.
I think theres a big difference between a solder suffering the horrors of war taking a watch from a dead enemy on the battlefield, and some knob digging up a dead solider that has been laying in a war cemetery for more than 50 years just to make a quick buck.
+1

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
pokethepope said:
Motorrad said:
All I can say is that my Grandfather and many of his colleagues had zero qualms about removing 'souvenirs' from dead enemy soldiers. I see no difference when it happens.
I think theres a big difference between a solder suffering the horrors of war taking a watch from a dead enemy on the battlefield, and some knob digging up a dead solider that has been laying in a war cemetery for more than 50 years just to make a quick buck.
First let me say that I am against robbing graves but it is an interesting point raised.

so you are saying
Taking a watch from a dead soldier above ground OK.
Taking a watch from a dead soldier underground not ok.

I'm struggling here to see that much difference to be honest at the moment taking emotion out of the argument.

smileymikey

1,446 posts

257 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
I've seen some of the videos on you tube of excavations...including the recovery of complete tanks that completely sunk into the mud during a WW2 battle and when pulled out the tracks and wheels are turning !

I'm in two minds about the rights and wrongs. Some of these areas are so remote that rotting helmets are still stuck on top of old rifles in the woods undisturbed after all these years. One part of me thinks leave them in peace. The other part thinks, these battlefields are just incredibly interesting, and should be properly and respectfully examined. The Time Team have just done the WW1 trenches only twenty years separate the two wars, and Tutankhamen had family that would rather he had been left alone. Where do you draw the line?

smileymikey

1,446 posts

257 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
BTW they aren't desecrating war graves in the main they are digging up areas of large battles where everything...and everyone is scattered all over the place

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Monday 20th August 2012
quotequote all
smileymikey said:
BTW they aren't desecrating war graves in the main they are digging up areas of large battles where everything...and everyone is scattered all over the place
I'd say thats quite a bit different than targeting marked graves.

Still in two minds about it though.

Difficult one.