Is research a waste of money?
Author
Discussion

Tant

Original Poster:

513 posts

223 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
As much as I can see the point of a lot of research, especially things like finding a cure for cancer, and to a point, such things as finding obscure particles, I wonder how much is spent on really pointless things and what good that money would do elsewhere.

There was a story on the radio this morning about researchers that had managed to place trackers on ants to find out what their habits and life was all about. As interesting as this might be to certain people, I do struggle to see if the money spent on this might be more beneficially spent..

So anyway, is this sort of stuff worthwhile? Should we stop investing in this sort of stuff, even at university level, and start spending it a bit more carefully?

GTIR

24,741 posts

297 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Isn't this thread a kind of research?

Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Lasers.

HowMuchLonger

3,041 posts

224 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Long term philosophical benefits vs immediate physical benefits.

Meoricin

2,880 posts

200 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Tant said:
As much as I can see the point of a lot of research, especially things like finding a cure for cancer, and to a point, such things as finding obscure particles, I wonder how much is spent on really pointless things and what good that money would do elsewhere.

There was a story on the radio this morning about researchers that had managed to place trackers on ants to find out what their habits and life was all about. As interesting as this might be to certain people, I do struggle to see if the money spent on this might be more beneficially spent..

So anyway, is this sort of stuff worthwhile? Should we stop investing in this sort of stuff, even at university level, and start spending it a bit more carefully?
What do you propose we spend money on, if not science and improving our understanding of the world? Surely investing in our future in this way is the most 'careful' way to spend money.

Du1point8

22,982 posts

223 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Newc said:
Lasers.
then sharks with lasers.

Tant

Original Poster:

513 posts

223 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
surely the social habits of ants, and having a deeper understanding of it, isn't going to do that much for us.....Some other aspects of the world about us , like understanding weather and the like might do....but maybe there are just some things we have to let go on a sort of cost/benefit thing?

HowMuchLonger

3,041 posts

224 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Tant said:
surely the social habits of ants, and having a deeper understanding of it, isn't going to do that much for us.....
Sociological aspects of high density living?

TwigtheWonderkid

49,290 posts

181 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Send me £50K and I'll look into it for you.

Du1point8

22,982 posts

223 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Tant said:
surely the social habits of ants, and having a deeper understanding of it, isn't going to do that much for us.....Some other aspects of the world about us , like understanding weather and the like might do....but maybe there are just some things we have to let go on a sort of cost/benefit thing?
So you are saying that a creature that has colonised pretty much everywhere on earth is not important to study?

Not to understand how they can live in harmony in their billions or why they are so important to the ecosystem?

Cause there just ants init...

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Tant said:
surely the social habits of ants, and having a deeper understanding of it, isn't going to do that much for us.....
I bet somebody once told Alexander Fleming that studying fungi was a waste of time as well.

Aizle

12,429 posts

206 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
GTIR said:
Isn't this thread a kind of research?
My thoughts.

otolith

69,800 posts

235 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
You don't know in advance what benefits will come from basic research.

Maybe someone will want to know something about ants in order to control them where they are pests.

Maybe something much more surprising could come from it:

http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v406/n6791/fu...


It's also how you train scientists.

David87

7,046 posts

243 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Without scientific research the world wouldn't be, err, quite the same as it is today. hehe

Rotary Madness

2,285 posts

217 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
I remember some people got paid to work out that french knights running through huge muddy fields before they got to the fighting at the battle of Agincourt, wait for it.............. would be exhausted. My fking cat could tell you that and he doesnt even talk.

Tant

Original Poster:

513 posts

223 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Symbolica said:
I bet somebody once told Alexander Fleming that studying fungi was a waste of time as well.
Well yes, there is always that, but we do have a bit more knowledge than there was back then. That discovery was made back in the time when mankind didn't generally know where babies came from....

I didn't say that we should stop looking...but do some things really have much point or benefit?

GTIR

24,741 posts

297 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Aizle said:
GTIR said:
Isn't this thread a kind of research?
My thoughts.
That'll £600 please.

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Tant said:
I didn't say that we should stop looking...but do some things really have much point or benefit?
How do you know before you try?

Du1point8

22,982 posts

223 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Tant said:
Symbolica said:
I bet somebody once told Alexander Fleming that studying fungi was a waste of time as well.
Well yes, there is always that, but we do have a bit more knowledge than there was back then. That discovery was made back in the time when mankind didn't generally know where babies came from....

I didn't say that we should stop looking...but do some things really have much point or benefit?
Is there any point in doing things like manufacturing in the UK if someone does it better abroad?

I mean there is no real point to it is there, so divert money away from those too...

bigandclever

14,423 posts

269 months

Friday 24th August 2012
quotequote all
Tant said:
Well yes, there is always that, but we do have a bit more knowledge than there was back then
So we have enough knowledge then?