Judge killed by javelin in sports competition
Discussion
Grim. Really feel for the poor kid who threw it, will be traumatised for life.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-19391807
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-19391807
An accident waiting to happen I'm afraid.
When we were at school (and this was very much pre health and safety days) every summer term before we started throwing pointy sticks around we were given A Talking To. Something along the lines of;
If you are in the area where javelins are being thrown, pay attention to what is going on.
DON'T enter the area until the javelin has been thrown and has landed.
DON'T, whatever you do, run towards the javelin. Because if you do then one day someone will slip up and impale themselves.
So, what do we see at every event? Over-eager judges rushing onto the field to be first one to get there and wave their flag. "Oooh look at meeeee, aren't I good, I minced on there and saved five seconds precious time".
When we were at school (and this was very much pre health and safety days) every summer term before we started throwing pointy sticks around we were given A Talking To. Something along the lines of;
If you are in the area where javelins are being thrown, pay attention to what is going on.
DON'T enter the area until the javelin has been thrown and has landed.
DON'T, whatever you do, run towards the javelin. Because if you do then one day someone will slip up and impale themselves.
So, what do we see at every event? Over-eager judges rushing onto the field to be first one to get there and wave their flag. "Oooh look at meeeee, aren't I good, I minced on there and saved five seconds precious time".
Zad said:
An accident waiting to happen I'm afraid.
When we were at school (and this was very much pre health and safety days) every summer term before we started throwing pointy sticks around we were given A Talking To. Something along the lines of;
If you are in the area where javelins are being thrown, pay attention to what is going on.
DON'T enter the area until the javelin has been thrown and has landed.
DON'T, whatever you do, run towards the javelin. Because if you do then one day someone will slip up and impale themselves.
So, what do we see at every event? Over-eager judges rushing onto the field to be first one to get there and wave their flag. "Oooh look at meeeee, aren't I good, I minced on there and saved five seconds precious time".
I am a qualified UKA field judge, and officiate at throwing events most weekends throughout the summmer. I have to say I do not recognise much of what you relate in your final paragraph. Why would anyone want to get to the javelin in order to wave a flag?When we were at school (and this was very much pre health and safety days) every summer term before we started throwing pointy sticks around we were given A Talking To. Something along the lines of;
If you are in the area where javelins are being thrown, pay attention to what is going on.
DON'T enter the area until the javelin has been thrown and has landed.
DON'T, whatever you do, run towards the javelin. Because if you do then one day someone will slip up and impale themselves.
So, what do we see at every event? Over-eager judges rushing onto the field to be first one to get there and wave their flag. "Oooh look at meeeee, aren't I good, I minced on there and saved five seconds precious time".
The only person with a flag would be the validity judge, who is not in the sector, and does not move.
Health and safety is taken very seriously at throwing events, and if people behaved as you describe they would not be officiating for very long without an attitude readjustment I can assure you.
Z06George said:
Terminator X said:
Chap at school got a javelin through the neck, didn't die believe it or not as they were able to saw each end off and get him to Hospital in time. Not recent though, early 80's ...
TX.
I don't suppose that school was Maiden Erlegh in Reading by any chance?TX.
XCP said:
Zad said:
An accident waiting to happen I'm afraid.
When we were at school (and this was very much pre health and safety days) every summer term before we started throwing pointy sticks around we were given A Talking To. Something along the lines of;
If you are in the area where javelins are being thrown, pay attention to what is going on.
DON'T enter the area until the javelin has been thrown and has landed.
DON'T, whatever you do, run towards the javelin. Because if you do then one day someone will slip up and impale themselves.
So, what do we see at every event? Over-eager judges rushing onto the field to be first one to get there and wave their flag. "Oooh look at meeeee, aren't I good, I minced on there and saved five seconds precious time".
I am a qualified UKA field judge, and officiate at throwing events most weekends throughout the summmer. I have to say I do not recognise much of what you relate in your final paragraph. Why would anyone want to get to the javelin in order to wave a flag?When we were at school (and this was very much pre health and safety days) every summer term before we started throwing pointy sticks around we were given A Talking To. Something along the lines of;
If you are in the area where javelins are being thrown, pay attention to what is going on.
DON'T enter the area until the javelin has been thrown and has landed.
DON'T, whatever you do, run towards the javelin. Because if you do then one day someone will slip up and impale themselves.
So, what do we see at every event? Over-eager judges rushing onto the field to be first one to get there and wave their flag. "Oooh look at meeeee, aren't I good, I minced on there and saved five seconds precious time".
The only person with a flag would be the validity judge, who is not in the sector, and does not move.
Health and safety is taken very seriously at throwing events, and if people behaved as you describe they would not be officiating for very long without an attitude readjustment I can assure you.
Edited by telecat on Tuesday 28th August 09:56
I was responding to the poster who was talking about what 'we see' nowadays.
With regard to the Olympics the judges for those events are at the very top of the heirarchy. Experience counts for a lot, and with a few exceptions, it is not a young persons activity. All the more reason not to go running about in the throwing sector!
My scariest experience was hammer throwing under floodlights. Several times I lost the hammer in flight in the darkness, only for it to land a few feet away. Thankfully this was just a training session and I called a halt PDQ.
With regard to the Olympics the judges for those events are at the very top of the heirarchy. Experience counts for a lot, and with a few exceptions, it is not a young persons activity. All the more reason not to go running about in the throwing sector!
My scariest experience was hammer throwing under floodlights. Several times I lost the hammer in flight in the darkness, only for it to land a few feet away. Thankfully this was just a training session and I called a halt PDQ.
XCP said:
I was responding to the poster who was talking about what 'we see' nowadays.
With regard to the Olympics the judges for those events are at the very top of the heirarchy. Experience counts for a lot, and with a few exceptions, it is not a young persons activity. All the more reason not to go running about in the throwing sector!
My scariest experience was hammer throwing under floodlights. Several times I lost the hammer in flight in the darkness, only for it to land a few feet away. Thankfully this was just a training session and I called a halt PDQ.
Why isn't it a young persons activity? I might be missing something but how difficult is it to wait for an object to land and then measure the distance?With regard to the Olympics the judges for those events are at the very top of the heirarchy. Experience counts for a lot, and with a few exceptions, it is not a young persons activity. All the more reason not to go running about in the throwing sector!
My scariest experience was hammer throwing under floodlights. Several times I lost the hammer in flight in the darkness, only for it to land a few feet away. Thankfully this was just a training session and I called a halt PDQ.
London424 said:
Why isn't it a young persons activity? I might be missing something but how difficult is it to wait for an object to land and then measure the distance?
The most common route into officiating is by being the parent of an athlete. It normally starts with holding one end of a tape.The other route is for former athletes, although more go into coaching. Some do both.
Young people tend to want to take part.
It's the same reason there are not many young referees in Football or Rugby.
This is very sad to see, hopefully more safety can be put in place for the judges, rather than have events cancelled due to danger. As has been said, the officials should have been around a track for a number of years and know the dangers.
I think a hammer is more dangerous than a javelin, but don't know if stats would back that up. At least with javelin it should travel in a pretty straight line.
I remember back to being at one of my first senior events, waiting around for an event near the start / finish line. The starter was in the inner track getting the gun ready, bent over looking in his bag. A hammer had some how exited the cage the wrong way and came down with a few metres of the judge. I think it may have been even closer than that but it is only a memory. Considering what had just happened, the starter didn't seem all that fussed!! Still started the race a couple of minutes later.
I think a hammer is more dangerous than a javelin, but don't know if stats would back that up. At least with javelin it should travel in a pretty straight line.
I remember back to being at one of my first senior events, waiting around for an event near the start / finish line. The starter was in the inner track getting the gun ready, bent over looking in his bag. A hammer had some how exited the cage the wrong way and came down with a few metres of the judge. I think it may have been even closer than that but it is only a memory. Considering what had just happened, the starter didn't seem all that fussed!! Still started the race a couple of minutes later.
thinfourth2 said:
Technical question
The point of the javelin is to get the javelin the furthest from the line as you can before it hits the ground
So did the thrower win?
In football the referee is part of the field of play so a ball which ricochets off him into the goal counts as a goal. Maybe it's the same in javelin.The point of the javelin is to get the javelin the furthest from the line as you can before it hits the ground
So did the thrower win?
OllyK said:
Z06George said:
Terminator X said:
Chap at school got a javelin through the neck, didn't die believe it or not as they were able to saw each end off and get him to Hospital in time. Not recent though, early 80's ...
TX.
I don't suppose that school was Maiden Erlegh in Reading by any chance?TX.

Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



ds both of them.