DfE pulls funding on free school.
DfE pulls funding on free school.
Author
Discussion

shed driver

Original Poster:

3,103 posts

191 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
Just a few days before term starts, uniforms bought, kids looking forward to their new school - and then this happens. The LA is then then forced to cater for 30 or so students who were not expected.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leeds-1939674...

Sounds like a complete arse up.

SD.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
You have to wonder if they'd have pulled funding if 49 enrolled. This is where arbitrary targets make little sense. It's not like there were just 4 waiting to go. A major inconvenience for the parents of those 30. Also a major inconvenience for the Local Authority, LA's have taken all sorts of beatings from various sides in the whole 'free school' debate but it's them who now have to find these kids somewhere to go to school.

Timing is terrible though. Dare I suggest it's because all the politicians have been off on holiday for the last two months nothing's been done?

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Timing is terrible though. Dare I suggest it's because all the politicians have been off on holiday for the last two months nothing's been done?
Unlikely as politicians don't do that job, it's civil servants.

I could see the argument if they were just under the required amount, but when you know you need 50 and you're 40% short, you haven't kept your side of the contract.

kowalski655

15,237 posts

174 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
According to the article taxpayers have already splashed out over £200K on the place,surely they could have hung on a bit longer & got our money's worth?
Also


some old dear said:
James has additional needs and there is not another school in this area that is suited to James' needs
How the hell does she know how the school would be best-it hasn't even opened!

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
Unlikely as politicians don't do that job, it's civil servants.
Oh well then it's just pure incompetence. I was trying to be kind and make an - albiet poor - excuse for them. When did these 30 enroll? Why couldn't they have announced this a month ago when it would've been more helpful?

Btw, if politicians don't do this and they don't do that, what the fk are we paying them for?


JagLover

46,848 posts

266 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Timing is terrible though.
The DFE claim that they have always made clear that a school needs a minimum of 50 pupils. If they are telling the school what they already know (that they can't open with only 30) how is this terrible timing?

miniman

30,237 posts

293 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
This thread could so easily be entitled "unpopular school fails in last ditch attempt to attract sufficient numbers".

172ff

3,777 posts

226 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
Market forces.

Live by the sword...

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Caulkhead said:
Unlikely as politicians don't do that job, it's civil servants.
Oh well then it's just pure incompetence. I was trying to be kind and make an - albiet poor - excuse for them. When did these 30 enroll? Why couldn't they have announced this a month ago when it would've been more helpful?

Btw, if politicians don't do this and they don't do that, what the fk are we paying them for?
Politicians write laws, civil servants implement them.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
JagLover said:
martin84 said:
Timing is terrible though.
The DFE claim that they have always made clear that a school needs a minimum of 50 pupils. If they are telling the school what they already know (that they can't open with only 30) how is this terrible timing?
More likely the school knew they were short and kept it quiet until the last minute in the hope of recruiting a enough kids.

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
More likely the school knew they were short and kept it quiet until the last minute in the hope of recruiting a enough kids.
yes They knew the rules from the get-go.

blearyeyedboy

6,814 posts

210 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
I read the series of events like this:

1) Enthusiastic and well meaning people (EaWMP) want to set up a free school.
2) EaWMP are given a chance and a wodge of cash to do it with by the authorities, but terms and conditions need to be met by EaWMP.
3) EaWMP don't just narrowly miss their targets but considerably fail to get anywhere near them.
4) Authorities realise that EaWMP just can't deliver the service and shut them down, coming up with a contingency plan.

Compare and contrast:

1) G4S say they can provide Olympic Security.
2) G4S are given a chance and a wodge of cash to do it with by the authorities, but terms and conditions need to be met by G4S.
3) G4S don't just narrowly miss their targets but considerably fail to get anywhere near them.
4) Authorities realise that EaWMP just can't deliver the service and shut them down, coming up with a contingency plan.

These aren't the fault of the people who shut them down. They're either the responsibility of whomever agreed to provide cash but didn't check to see how feasible it was, or they're the fault of people who were unrealistic about what they could deliver, or both.

(I'm not against free schools. I'm against people who promise what they can't deliver.)

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
JagLover said:
The DFE claim that they have always made clear that a school needs a minimum of 50 pupils. If they are telling the school what they already know (that they can't open with only 30) how is this terrible timing?
Oh no sorry I forgot 'free schools' is a Conservative Party policy so obviously criticism is forbidden on PH. Apologies.

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Oh no sorry I forgot 'free schools' is a Conservative Party policy so obviously criticism is forbidden on PH. Apologies.
That is not what he said at all. The school knew the requirements they had to fulfill, and they failed to reach them.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
That is not what he said at all. The school knew the requirements they had to fulfill, and they failed to reach them.
And you're trying to tell me nobody aside from the school themselves knew that until this week?

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
TheHeretic said:
That is not what he said at all. The school knew the requirements they had to fulfill, and they failed to reach them.
And you're trying to tell me nobody aside from the school themselves knew that until this week?
Why would anyone else need to know? The school knows the criteria and they know if they don't achieve it they won't get funded as has happened here.

BlackVanDyke

9,932 posts

242 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
martin84 said:
TheHeretic said:
That is not what he said at all. The school knew the requirements they had to fulfill, and they failed to reach them.
And you're trying to tell me nobody aside from the school themselves knew that until this week?
Why would anyone else need to know? The school knows the criteria and they know if they don't achieve it they won't get funded as has happened here.
yes

The whole Free Schools thingy has been notable by the absence of checks and balances in all sorts of areas (and them gaining back the right to discriminate against any kid they don't fancy taking on, for any reason at all).

Chrisw666

22,655 posts

230 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
JagLover said:
The DFE claim that they have always made clear that a school needs a minimum of 50 pupils. If they are telling the school what they already know (that they can't open with only 30) how is this terrible timing?
Oh no sorry I forgot 'free schools' is a Conservative Party policy so obviously criticism is forbidden on PH. Apologies.
Where has any reference (in the post you quoted) been made to a political party or any comment about the benefits of free schools?

FWIW I think in principle they're a great idea, in fact I've got half a proposal of my own written up just in case they're here to stay.

turbobloke

117,583 posts

291 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Chrisw666 said:
martin84 said:
JagLover said:
The DFE claim that they have always made clear that a school needs a minimum of 50 pupils. If they are telling the school what they already know (that they can't open with only 30) how is this terrible timing?
Oh no sorry I forgot 'free schools' is a Conservative Party policy so obviously criticism is forbidden on PH. Apologies.
Where has any reference (in the post you quoted) been made to a political party or any comment about the benefits of free schools?

FWIW I think in principle they're a great idea, in fact I've got half a proposal of my own written up just in case they're here to stay.
Good luck with that! If you think the Coalition or the Conservatives will be elected then waiting will be OK, otherwise consider going for 2014, though the submission deadline for proposals is early Jan 2013 - so in effect before Christmas.

This event has nothing to do with policy and everything to do with demand levels for one particular proposed free school. Far more free schools open over-subscribed than fail to open due to insufficient pupil numbers. It offers the left a straw to cling on to and wave about, really these triumphalist types ought to be offering sympathies to parents and pupils and asking the DfE and proposers what they were playing at...unless something very weird happened.