Damien Green and the 'Danny Boyle Test'
Damien Green and the 'Danny Boyle Test'
Author
Discussion

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 28th August 2012
quotequote all
This story came out yesterday so apologies for being slow on the uptake.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19389204

article said:
Mr Green said: "To succeed, the Conservative Party must be at home in modern Britain. Much in this country needs changing and improving; but we should not become nostalgists promoting a better yesterday.
Two things;

a) What exactly is modern Britain?

b) I find it a bit curious that a party which supposedly isn't part of modern Britain is in charge of modern Britain. Whatever it is.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
This story came out yesterday so apologies for being slow on the uptake.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19389204

article said:
Mr Green said: "To succeed, the Conservative Party must be at home in modern Britain. Much in this country needs changing and improving; but we should not become nostalgists promoting a better yesterday.
Two things;

a) What exactly is modern Britain?

b) I find it a bit curious that a party which supposedly isn't part of modern Britain is in charge of modern Britain. Whatever it is.
Do you never tire of posting these dull, passive-aggressive anti-tory threads?

You do realise this forum also does a small sideline in car-related threads as well don't you?

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
Do you never tire of posting these dull, passive-aggressive anti-tory threads?
This from someone who joins in every round of cut-and-pasted dull 'smash Labour' thread? Surely that gets boring too? I was going to post the biggest political story of the day (the man-or-mouse-third-runway stuff) as nobody else had done so but I suppose that'll be deemed anti-Tory too rolleyes

I just thought it was an odd thing for Damien Green to say, it's pretty much a non story as you'd expect at this time of year but I'm still trying to work out if he was trying to be positive or negative.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Caulkhead said:
Do you never tire of posting these dull, passive-aggressive anti-tory threads?
This from someone who joins in every round of cut-and-pasted dull 'smash Labour' thread? Surely that gets boring too? I was going to post the biggest political story of the day (the man-or-mouse-third-runway stuff) as nobody else had done so but I suppose that'll be deemed anti-Tory too rolleyes

I just thought it was an odd thing for Damien Green to say, it's pretty much a non story as you'd expect at this time of year but I'm still trying to work out if he was trying to be positive or negative.
The 'Topics I Started' section of your profile says it all really.

By all means continue your campaign, it's a (relatively) free site and you obviously have a lot of free time on your hands.

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
By all means continue your campaign, it's a (relatively) free site and you obviously have a lot of free time on your hands.
No life mate. Can't argue there.

smile


Bibbs

3,754 posts

241 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
a) What exactly is modern Britain?
It's Britain as of now, not the Britain of the past.

martin84 said:
b) I find it a bit curious that a party which supposedly isn't part of modern Britain is in charge of modern Britain. Whatever it is.
They are a part, but he says to succeed, Torys need to look at improving the "now", not looking back to how it was.

Basically telling the party, "we are not going back to how it was, we need to improve from here".

Isn't that obvious?



martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Bibbs said:
It's Britain as of now, not the Britain of the past.
Well fk me sideways!

Perhaps I should rephrase the question; How would you define so called modern Britain? What makes it not like old Britain?

Mr_B

10,480 posts

274 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Should I just cut the bullst dressing in the article, and say its meant to be a kick to the Tory Party that they are going to have to appeal to more than just white people since the make up of the country has changed a lot, and will continue to do so.

Bibbs

3,754 posts

241 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Well fk me sideways!

Perhaps I should rephrase the question; How would you define so called modern Britain? What makes it not like old Britain?
Well your the one who asked what it is!

What makes it different to what they are thinking? Depends how far back they think and only they know that. For some Tory backbenchers that could be wanting to be Lord of the mannor and having serfs toiling in fields.

But I'd suggest it would be trying to ditch the "thatcherite" mentality (as I'd suggest it wont get them re-elected).

Modern Britain to me is confused. It's no longer an industrial nation, it's moving away from the celtic & anglo-saxon country. It's also a time when the 90s "Cool Britania" (which New Labour linked to) is now old.

It's place that has delusions of grandeur at the moment. It wants the NHS, large police forces, good public transport, low taxes and free Sky if you can't be arsed to work. But no idea how to pay for all this now it's broke.

maxfan

1,622 posts

174 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
It mean that the tories are going to have to get down wiv de bros if they is ever gonna pile up dem votes in de inner cities
It means that the tories are going to have to do more ethnically diverse stuff such as going down the local mosque on a friday, going out and getting pissed up and pissing in doorways on saturday night and then doing a bit of tarmacing bstyle on saturday afternoons whilst nicking the metal gates off next doors driveway
It means that instead of the tory faithful old women holding scone and tea parties they need to be doing dress making classes for gypo girls with fantastic big bouncy lovely jubbly fill yer mouth with them breasts a bit similar ton what thelma managed to achieve in thelmas gyspsy girls
More tories need to go on the jeremy kyle show with confessions of having shagged their partners sister etc, more tories need to embrace th egay culture and be in same sex partnerships especially in scotland where it will go down a treat
Its nothing at ball NOTHING just as CLegg saying Tax the rich and Adman Milliband saying lets have a review about virgin losing zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
NON of this latest posturing has any real meaning purely than to be seen to raise profiles and keep us talking about them the more things change bthe more things stay the same its all bks really

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Two things;

a) What exactly is modern Britain?

b) I find it a bit curious that a party which supposedly isn't part of modern Britain is in charge of modern Britain. Whatever it is.
I don't understand your angle here.

Sure, I do not doubt that there is a core of Tory voters who see the country through a lens which sets things in the 1950's and with Elgar playing as the soundtrack. Hang on - Danny Boyle played Elgar didn't he ? Anyway..

You could equally take the notion of modern Britain and throw it in the face of a core vote in the left as well. Some of the trade union movement still wish it was 1970. They too, need to modernise.

There is no story here other than the usual BBC , Guardian inspired rhetoric.

Your position seems to suggest that the government isn't part of modern Britain. If I am to infer that Labour is a part of modern Britain, in comparison, then let me state in advance that your position is wrong. bks, in fact.

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Modern Britain?
Its not actually a bad place. All the ingredients are there, same as they have always been.

What is lacking is an almost criminal lack of self-belief, confidence and leadership from our political elite. The last Labour govt believed too much in the power of unending other-peoples-money and used it to sell the idea to society that money/the economy was self-perpetuating and would therefore always and always be willing/able to fund a truely equal and just society.

The current Tory lead govt lacks any sort of gumption to make the argument to the country about what is needed from the country, about how the economy and society work and how they are balanced together.

There will be no advancement of modern Britain until one of those two things changes and we get genuine political leadership back in the country. There is nothing wrong in trying to make society a more just place, but by God you need to do it from a bedrock fit for your means. During lean times that means your emphasis is less about a just society and more about tending your economy to lead back to growth. During times of plenty you can look at rebalancing your society.

Britain has incompetent politicians whatever colour you believe in.

0000

13,966 posts

222 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Two things;

a) What exactly is modern Britain?
A buzzphrase for people who want to slate someone else without having anything substantial to say about them.

martin84 said:
b) I find it a bit curious that a party which supposedly isn't part of modern Britain is in charge of modern Britain. Whatever it is.
Ok.

sjc

16,509 posts

301 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
DJRC said:
Modern Britain?
Its not actually a bad place. All the ingredients are there, same as they have always been.

What is lacking is an almost criminal lack of self-belief, confidence and leadership from our political elite. The last Labour govt believed too much in the power of unending other-peoples-money and used it to sell the idea to society that money/the economy was self-perpetuating and would therefore always and always be willing/able to fund a truely equal and just society.

The current Tory lead govt lacks any sort of gumption to make the argument to the country about what is needed from the country, about how the economy and society work and how they are balanced together.

There will be no advancement of modern Britain until one of those two things changes and we get genuine political leadership back in the country. There is nothing wrong in trying to make society a more just place, but by God you need to do it from a bedrock fit for your means. During lean times that means your emphasis is less about a just society and more about tending your economy to lead back to growth. During times of plenty you can look at rebalancing your society.

Britain has incompetent politicians whatever colour you believe in.
Terrific post, as was Maxfan's from a different angle.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Yay, Blue tie v Red tie thread. Of course the problem is the monkeys in charge, not the system is completely flawed.

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
0000 said:
martin84 said:
Two things;

a) What exactly is modern Britain?
A buzzphrase for people who want to slate someone else without having anything substantial to say about them.

martin84 said:
b) I find it a bit curious that a party which supposedly isn't part of modern Britain is in charge of modern Britain. Whatever it is.
Ok.
What really get my temperature rising is when you get a Labour politician claiming that they are about "progressive" politics. WTF does "progressive" mean and why does Labour feel that it is something they represent? I heard that smooth saville row suited man of the people Chuka Umunna use the "progressive" tag the other day. Meaningless political babble from the mouth of yet another snake oil salesman.

maxfan

1,622 posts

174 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
sjc said:
Terrific post, as was Maxfan's from a different angle.
Do you like large bangers too then mate smile

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Yay, Blue tie v Red tie thread. Of course the problem is the monkeys in charge, not the system is completely flawed.
What system? System of what? Britain has had the same political system for the last 400+ yrs.
Social system? British society has always been a widely diverse society, highly stratified from the very rich to the very poor.
High tax? Britain has always been a high tax country.

So what system are you whinging about this time?

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
toppstuff said:
There is no story here other than the usual BBC , Guardian inspired rhetoric.
Hardly. It's not an editorial, it's direct quotes from the Immigration Minister who has gone out of his way to say his party needs to embrace modern Britain so if anyone was 'guardian inspired' it was the Immigration Minister. The BBC, Guardian and indeed other news outlets merely reported it. Reporting what a minister says is sort of standard fare for newspapers.

toppstuff said:
Your position seems to suggest that the government isn't part of modern Britain. If I am to infer that Labour is a part of modern Britain, in comparison, then let me state in advance that your position is wrong. bks, in fact.
I didn't suggest any political party was a part of modern Britain. I brought up the thread in an attempt to start a discussion about what 'modern Britain' actually is and how you would define it. But because I brought it up it has to be dragged down into a 'well Labour are st too' thread, despite me never claiming anything to the contrary.

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Wednesday 29th August 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
I didn't suggest any political party was a part of modern Britain. I brought up the thread in an attempt to start a discussion about what 'modern Britain' actually is and how you would define it. But because I brought it up it has to be dragged down into a 'well Labour are st too' thread, despite me never claiming anything to the contrary.
I see what you did there. You wear your agenda like a waistcoat.