A response to the Lib Dems
Discussion
martin84 said:
Foreign Aid pays some people to stay in their own country rather than coming here to claim asylum, it's actually a fairly economic policy. First thing I'd do is cut the house of commons by a third and halve the number of councillors.
Are there any figures that demonstrate this return on investment? martin84 said:
Foreign Aid pays some people to stay in their own country rather than coming here to claim asylum, it's actually a fairly economic policy. First thing I'd do is cut the house of commons by a third and halve the number of councillors.
What an incredibly childish, naive, and innocent point of view.Don
--
Ozzie Osmond said:
So why not start by cutting out the whole nonsense of "asylum"?
Says the person who was lucky enough to be born into a country which is not in a civil war and does not torture you based on your religion. You're not better than any of the people who come here asking for our help, you were just lucky enough to be born here.ETA: Even if you abolished Asylum you'd still get more illegal immigration if you abolished foreign aid.
don4l said:
What an incredibly childish, naive, and innocent point of view.
Oh right you might want to mention that to the Conservative Party/UK Prime Minister who also wants to reduce the size of the house of commons.Murph7355 said:
Are there any figures that demonstrate this return on investment?
Nobody else on here is ever asked for figures to back up their ideas as they spout their various vitriol. Why should I be judged by standards nobody else is?Edited by martin84 on Thursday 30th August 00:49
martin84 said:
Nobody else on here is ever asked for figures to back up their ideas as they spout their various vitriol. Why should I be judged by standards nobody else is?
Because you always tell us how right you are, plus you didn't call it an idea , you presented it as a fact. If it was going to increase immigration , maybe some kinda control over that would also be a good idea too ? Now, how about those figures ?Edited by martin84 on Thursday 30th August 00:49
Mr_B said:
Because you always tell us how right you are, plus you didn't call it an idea , you presented it as a fact. If it was going to increase immigration , maybe some kinda control over that would also be a good idea too ? Now, how about those figures ?
Every PH'er presents their own opinions as cast iron fact irrespective of figures, why can't I join in? By the way can you provide a quote of me somewhere saying how right I am?First world nations have used foreign aid as a means to buy other countries off for decades. Most of the first world throws billions at impoverished nations to not only help out on humanitarian grounds but also to stop more of Africa coming to the first world. The fact people naturally flock to where money is shouldn't be something I have to spell out with figures, it's pretty f
king obvious. In the same way a million Poles came to Britain when they joined the EU, some would've stayed at home if we'd thrown billions at Poland. Many Mexicans get into America every year through hope of a better life, if Mexico had the opportunities America has then less would take the chance of illegally entering America. It's basic stuff.We pay around £9billion a year in foreign aid, add that to the foreign aid of other first world countries and you have enough money to limit some movement in other parts of the world. I don't know how much we'd 'pay' in the long run for cutting foreign aid, but I do know it doesn't take too much of a population increase to cost the state £9billion.
martin84 said:
Every PH'er presents their own opinions as cast iron fact irrespective of figures, why can't I join in? By the way can you provide a quote of me somewhere saying how right I am?
First world nations have used foreign aid as a means to buy other countries off for decades. Most of the first world throws billions at impoverished nations to not only help out on humanitarian grounds but also to stop more of Africa coming to the first world. The fact people naturally flock to where money is shouldn't be something I have to spell out with figures, it's pretty f
king obvious. In the same way a million Poles came to Britain when they joined the EU, some would've stayed at home if we'd thrown billions at Poland. Many Mexicans get into America every year through hope of a better life, if Mexico had the opportunities America has then less would take the chance of illegally entering America. It's basic stuff.
We pay around £9billion a year in foreign aid, add that to the foreign aid of other first world countries and you have enough money to limit some movement in other parts of the world. I don't know how much we'd 'pay' in the long run for cutting foreign aid, but I do know it doesn't take too much of a population increase to cost the state £9billion.
So you present it as fact, then it changes to just being your own idea when you are asked to back up your claim, now its an opinion. OK.First world nations have used foreign aid as a means to buy other countries off for decades. Most of the first world throws billions at impoverished nations to not only help out on humanitarian grounds but also to stop more of Africa coming to the first world. The fact people naturally flock to where money is shouldn't be something I have to spell out with figures, it's pretty f
king obvious. In the same way a million Poles came to Britain when they joined the EU, some would've stayed at home if we'd thrown billions at Poland. Many Mexicans get into America every year through hope of a better life, if Mexico had the opportunities America has then less would take the chance of illegally entering America. It's basic stuff.We pay around £9billion a year in foreign aid, add that to the foreign aid of other first world countries and you have enough money to limit some movement in other parts of the world. I don't know how much we'd 'pay' in the long run for cutting foreign aid, but I do know it doesn't take too much of a population increase to cost the state £9billion.
No , not every PH'er does present their opinions as fact without any basis or figures, plenty do so and do it rather well I think.
You are free to join in with your facts/ideas/opinions, but if asked to actually provide some proof of your claims, don't be to miffed if people think you maybe talking crap, when you are asked for figures and you won't do so on the basis that someone else didn't, because you will just get ignored.
martin84 said:
Nobody else on here is ever asked for figures to back up their ideas as they spout their various vitriol. Why should I be judged by standards nobody else is?
...]
Because call me old fashioned but I'm interested in the facts of a situation and thought you might be too, rather than just spouting unsubstantiated b...]
ks (e.g. "ETA: Even if you abolished Asylum you'd still get more illegal immigration if you abolished foreign aid"). I'd treat everyone else the same and would expect to be challenged myself if doing the same.You might be right on the benefits of foreign aid (stranger things have happened). Wouldn't it be nice if our leaders could demonstrate the wisdom of their actions with cold hard numbers that you could quote though? As it stands, however, they do as you do - publish rubbish to support some lily livered view.
iphonedyou said:
don4l said:
What an incredibly childish, naive, and innocent point of view.
Don
--
Agreed. I can't imagine cutting that number of staff would be anybody's first port of call, unless they were just looking to make a political point.Don
--
It is abundantly cear that there are thousands employed in meaningless, non productive roles in central, local and European Government.
Reducing MPs and councillors significantly would remove the structure by which all that waste is derived. Nothing but a good thing.
odyssey2200 said:
Ozzie Osmond said:
martin84 said:
Foreign Aid pays some people to stay in their own country rather than coming here to claim asylum, it's actually a fairly economic policy.
So why not start by cutting out the whole nonsense of "asylum"?The day Britain turns its back on migration is the day we can all pack our bags and leave the mortal realm. The country was goddam built on migration, immigration and emmigration. Asylum is merely a part of that, not to mention it brings with it a certain amount of honour. You do not ever turn your back on asylum for what you will gain by the minute amount of relative resources you expend upon asylum folks you lose 10 times over around the world due to how you are now represented.
There is this ludicrously weird and ignorant view on ph of Britain, propogated by those who spend 99% of their time inside looking out through the keyhole, that we are somehow a kicking and punching bag for the rest of the world. Some piss easy target. We arent. Britain is highly highly respected around the world, it is frequently viewed as a place of hope and wonder. Even in bloody Europe the UK and London remain the goto places.
To turn our back to asylum would do Britain untold damage around the world. It would be a policy so foolish, so bad, so f
king idiotically useless that it would make everything Gordon Brown ever said look like the wisdom of Solomon.Now if we were to talk of controlling immigration and the number of asylum seekers, with clear and easy processes in place for dealing with them, including quick and efficient processing with clear, transparent and easy to understand guidelines...then that would be a different debate. Or perhaps the debate intended but horrendously badly stated?
Edited by DJRC on Thursday 30th August 09:53
Back to the OP's question:
Cut HMRC staff. How?
Cut HMRC staff. How?
- Efficiency drive & 'normal' HR policy. Can;t say too much on this other than I have inside knowledge of how truly, obviously and enormously bloated and inefficient the organisation is and there's pounds and pounds of fat waiting to be trimmed.
- Rationalise tax, reducing the number of HMRC 'admin' required.
- The above will also simplify the system from the POV of business and will reduce overhads across the board, for all employers.
DJRC said:
To turn our back to asylum would do Britain untold damage around the world.
The best way to do that is to say you're going to invade another country's London embassy when someone claiming to defend free speech seeks asylum there. Oh wait a minute.... Asylum is hogwash. Unless you say you're going to accept enyone and everyone who turns up from a particular country.
On your analysis of immigration one wonders how quickly the polulation of UK would rise to 250,000,000. Sometime around Christmas 2012 I should think.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



