Bin Laden's end.. what really happened..
Discussion
I'm assuming you can't write an entire book about one operation but interesting non the less:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-19409426
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-19409426
Having just returned today from Texas, there are several strands to this story, why did American media release the real name of the author? Who is now alleged to be in danger from attack himself. I would have thought it was not a clever thing to name him, particularly as I heard it on Fox. Having thought perhaps it had been a government leak in revenge. How much truth or not is there in the story? I suspect we will never know. In the USA the book is being sold by the media as much as an attack on Obama as it is as the story of the event itself. The view of many appears to be Obama had little to do with the attack being ordered. I suspect we will never know the real truth of that either.
Just thinking back to when he was killed, there didnt seem to be any 'song and dance about it'.
News reports were minimal, and afterwards normality resumed quite quickly.
One would have thought that after many, many years of hunting him down, costing countless loves, there would be more than there was.
I could, of course, be talking absolute b
ks.
News reports were minimal, and afterwards normality resumed quite quickly.
One would have thought that after many, many years of hunting him down, costing countless loves, there would be more than there was.
I could, of course, be talking absolute b
ks.Oakey said:
He's still dead. IIRC the conspiracy theorists didn't believe he'd been killed.
for what it's worth, I suspect he was long dead at the time of his reported death but it is only a suspicion and i have no proof or evidence so there is no point in discussing it 
Having said that, as far as i am aware there is no proof or proper evidence for the official story either

Alucidnation said:
Just thinking back to when he was killed, there didnt seem to be any 'song and dance about it'.
News reports were minimal, and afterwards normality resumed quite quickly.
One would have thought that after many, many years of hunting him down, costing countless loves, there would be more than there was.
I could, of course, be talking absolute b
ks.
With the absolute greatest of respect - and solely because you proffered the possibility yourself - you probably are News reports were minimal, and afterwards normality resumed quite quickly.
One would have thought that after many, many years of hunting him down, costing countless loves, there would be more than there was.
I could, of course, be talking absolute b
ks.

The last thing they want is Bin Laden elevated to martyrdom. So they treat the body with respect, and a minimum of fuss. You're also forgetting the political context; they had no right, legally - morally is quite a different story, in my view! - to be in Pakistan, and jumping up and down in celebration on a governmental level afterwards would not help things settle down.
There's more, but those are the salient points I suppose.
DSM2 said:
I'm not sure why this matters either way?
It matters because of the claims of how the body was treated after death. The official US claims are of repsectful treatment; the book claims using him as a bench.We've seen how excited the Talinutters get at some slight against them.
The Author's an idiot because all it does is increase the hatred against currently serving personnel.
Of course it matters how he died. We are civilised people, we are supposed to bring criminals to justice, not shoot unarmed old men, no matter what they have been accused of.
If he was reaching for a weapon then it a justified shoot, if he was trying to surrender it was murder....
Personally, I'd have had no problem with them saying they killed him on sight because they didn't want the publicity of a trial. He deserved no rights and I'm glad he was never put on a show trial.
If he was reaching for a weapon then it a justified shoot, if he was trying to surrender it was murder....
Personally, I'd have had no problem with them saying they killed him on sight because they didn't want the publicity of a trial. He deserved no rights and I'm glad he was never put on a show trial.
TTmonkey said:
Of course it matters how he died. We are civilised people, we are supposed to bring criminals to justice, not shoot unarmed old men, no matter what they have been accused of.
If he was reaching for a weapon then it a justified shoot, if he was trying to surrender it was murder....
Personally, I'd have had no problem with them saying they killed him on sight because they didn't want the publicity of a trial. He deserved no rights and I'm glad he was never put on a show trial.
Doesnt that kind of contradict yourself ?If he was reaching for a weapon then it a justified shoot, if he was trying to surrender it was murder....
Personally, I'd have had no problem with them saying they killed him on sight because they didn't want the publicity of a trial. He deserved no rights and I'm glad he was never put on a show trial.
Think I'll get myself a copy - unless 'the man' somehow stops me.
Could be the 'bravo two zero' of the 2012.
As for how true it is... aside from the fact that if you ask 12 people in the same room when anything happens you'll generally get 12 different versions of events, never mind something as chaotic as an armed raid.
Pretty much every major story in America is politicised it seems. The killing of Bin Laden was Obama's great victory that GWB's decade long war in Afghanistan could never achieve and made him more palatable with Republicans, maybe his book has been slanted to redress some of that.
As for the Military letting the story out etc, you could argue that helping Mitt Romney into the Whitehouse would be good for them compared to another 4 years of Obama who cut their funding.
Could be the 'bravo two zero' of the 2012.
As for how true it is... aside from the fact that if you ask 12 people in the same room when anything happens you'll generally get 12 different versions of events, never mind something as chaotic as an armed raid.
Pretty much every major story in America is politicised it seems. The killing of Bin Laden was Obama's great victory that GWB's decade long war in Afghanistan could never achieve and made him more palatable with Republicans, maybe his book has been slanted to redress some of that.
As for the Military letting the story out etc, you could argue that helping Mitt Romney into the Whitehouse would be good for them compared to another 4 years of Obama who cut their funding.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



