BBC break rules on payments to Diana Abbott
BBC break rules on payments to Diana Abbott
Author
Discussion

thinfourth2

Original Poster:

32,414 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Do not read this if you are easily annoyed as you will burst with rage

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19423658

The rest of us can have a giggle at the beeb having its fingers wrapped

It would be nice if she had to return the payments but this won't happen

scenario8

8,008 posts

210 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Intersting. I heard this earlier (on the BBC) and I'm probably going to go against the usual PH crowd on this as I don't have a kneejerk black and white view that she appears on the show as a Labour politican representing her party but as a political commentator albeit one clearly supportive of the Labour Party. Similarly I don't see Michael Portillo as solely representing the Conservative Party (although I understand the distinction that she remained an MP).

I appreciate many won't see a distinction but I watch that show as political commentary rather than as Andrew Neil interviewing two representatives. Regardless, the Trust doesn't agree and has ruled.

A bit more ammo for the Mail and the regulars on here to throw at the BBC. All is well with the world.

Digga

48,636 posts

314 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Where can I claim my "disturbance fee" for having to live in an environment where the BBC broadcast out raw, biased sewage on national networks? Granted, I don't have to watch it, but I do have to live with the noise of their ill-formed opinions, echoing out of the empty heads of voters and, owrse still, consequences of their idiotic ideals.

matchmaker

9,093 posts

231 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
Do not read this if you are easily annoyed as you will burst with rage

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19423658

The rest of us can have a giggle at the beeb having its fingers wrapped

It would be nice if she had to return the payments but this won't happen

Mark Benson

8,264 posts

300 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
I don't think they should have paid her...... primarily because as a panelist on This Week, she was inept.
Alan Johnson is far better at it than DA ever was.

But in principle, I don't have a problem with any MP being paid if they're prepared to discuss the week's political events in the way they do on This Week - Perhaps ask them to do it for free the first time, and if they turn it into a Party Political Broadcast (as some have tried to do in the past) then simply don't ask them back - if they do a good job, they're paid from then on.

don4l

10,058 posts

207 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
I dislike the stupid, lardy, racist, race card weilding woman as much as the next man, but I cannot see anything wrong with paying someone to be on a show like This Week.

Both Abbott and Portillo regularily strayed from the party line and seemed to be only representing themselves.

Appearences on "Question Time" are a completely different matter.

Don
--

JDRoest

1,126 posts

181 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
don4l said:
I dislike the stupid, lardy, racist, race card weilding woman as much as the next man, but I cannot see anything wrong with paying someone to be on a show like This Week.
So....you would be comfortable if Cameron was paid by Newsnight to appear on it?

Mr_B

10,480 posts

274 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
No serving MP should be paid to be on a show like that

Mark Benson

8,264 posts

300 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
JDRoest said:
don4l said:
I dislike the stupid, lardy, racist, race card weilding woman as much as the next man, but I cannot see anything wrong with paying someone to be on a show like This Week.
So....you would be comfortable if Cameron was paid by Newsnight to appear on it?
I'd be comfortable if he were paid to be on This Week, which is the programme in question.

don4l

10,058 posts

207 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
JDRoest said:
don4l said:
I dislike the stupid, lardy, racist, race card weilding woman as much as the next man, but I cannot see anything wrong with paying someone to be on a show like This Week.
So....you would be comfortable if Cameron was paid by Newsnight to appear on it?
No, not at all.

You cut out the bit where I said
"Both Abbott and Portillo regularily strayed from the party line and seemed to be only representing themselves.

Appearences on "Question Time" are a completely different matter.

Newsnight appearances would be very similiar to Question Time."


Have you watched "This Week"?

Don
--


Edited by don4l on Thursday 30th August 13:54

Blue62

10,587 posts

183 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
I have never, ever seen Abbott spelt Abutt, was this perchance a Freudian slip?

On the flip side, it seems that the BBC Trust is doing a reasonable job of monitoring standards and output on the BBC. I have never felt that Abutt (sic) was representing the views of the Labour Party and that part of the appeal of this programme is that the main players engage in a less partisan debate.

Miguel Alvarez

5,194 posts

201 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Why not. She'll of course be paying tax on her earnings.


DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
don4l said:
Have you watched "This Week"?

Don
--


Edited by don4l on Thursday 30th August 13:54
Not since Abbott started to appear on it, no. Can't abide the left wing parasite.

colonel c

8,059 posts

270 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
I can't see a problem either. It's a bit rich that Lord Laird complained about Abbott being paid by The BBC. He is not unaccustomed to filling his pockets either. In 2008/09 he became the most expensive peer in the House of Lords, claiming more than £73,000 in expenses and allowances.


thinfourth2

Original Poster:

32,414 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Blue62 said:
I have never, ever seen Abbott spelt A butt, was this perchance a Freudian slip?

Maybe

Blue62

10,587 posts

183 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
DSM2 said:
Not since Abbott started to appear on it, no. Can't abide the left wing parasite.
That's a very good life skill, every chance your opinions will remain unchanged for a whole lifetime.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
It's what you expect from the BBC - a current shadow cabinet minister/MP to push labour party line and ex's on the other side.

colonel c

8,059 posts

270 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
It's what you expect from the BBC - a current shadow cabinet minister/MP to push labour party line and ex's on the other side.
It's what you expect from the BBC.

oyster

13,801 posts

279 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
So a TV programme has a former Tory cabinet minister and a current Labour minister and pay them both, yet some perceive this as part of the BBC bias.

Good grief.

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Thursday 30th August 2012
quotequote all
Give Abbott a break - she's got school fees to pay wink

I'd rather they had Russ Abbott and Michael Portillo.