Bruce Willis to take Apple to court
Discussion
Bought my wife an ipod, and she used iTunes for about 5 tracks - now, we use Amazon MP3, which is much better, and much fairer with zero restrictions on how you can use the tracks. Like the other poster, I do not buy into the silly 'lifestyle' choice of Apple, never understood it - iTunes seemed way too restrictive compared to other offerings.
chris watton said:
Bought my wife an ipod, and she used iTunes for about 5 tracks - now, we use Amazon MP3, which is much better, and much fairer with zero restrictions on how you can use the tracks. Like the other poster, I do not buy into the silly 'lifestyle' choice of Apple, never understood it - iTunes seemed way too restrictive compared to other offerings.
What restrictions? There is no DRM on itunes music, so you can use it on whatever device can play AAC music. Are you sure you aren't buying into what other people's crap, rather than what actually is?TheHeretic said:
chris watton said:
Bought my wife an ipod, and she used iTunes for about 5 tracks - now, we use Amazon MP3, which is much better, and much fairer with zero restrictions on how you can use the tracks. Like the other poster, I do not buy into the silly 'lifestyle' choice of Apple, never understood it - iTunes seemed way too restrictive compared to other offerings.
What restrictions? There is no DRM on itunes music, so you can use it on whatever device can play AAC music. Are you sure you aren't buying into what other people's crap, rather than what actually is?Our kids didn't Apple, they chose Samsung - kids seem more canny than adults......
chris watton said:
Have Apple changed the rules on their MP3's then? I am talking about a few years ago, and trying to move the tracks on another (non-Apple) device was nigh on impossible.
Our kids didn't Apple, they chose Samsung - kids seem more canny than adults......
Apple use AAC, rather than .mp3. However, if you have older music that has DRM, (pre-2007)Our kids didn't Apple, they chose Samsung - kids seem more canny than adults......
I think), then just delete, and redownload a DRM free copy from iTunes. AAC will work on all sorts of devices, consoles, and so on.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Audio_Coding...
Don't believe everything you hear.
TheHeretic said:
chris watton said:
Bought my wife an ipod, and she used iTunes for about 5 tracks - now, we use Amazon MP3, which is much better, and much fairer with zero restrictions on how you can use the tracks. Like the other poster, I do not buy into the silly 'lifestyle' choice of Apple, never understood it - iTunes seemed way too restrictive compared to other offerings.
What restrictions? There is no DRM on itunes music, so you can use it on whatever device can play AAC music. Are you sure you aren't buying into what other people's crap, rather than what actually is?I understand the Apple brand camp and those that follow in an almost religious way, and althoughI'm not one of these people, I still find their OS one of the easiest and trouble-free methods of listening to, buying and managing my music.
Are the licenses really that radically different than for CDs? Technically I didn't think you were legally allowed to do these things with CDs. Ownership of the physical media does not give rights to do what you want with it (copy it, play it in public etc).
When iTunes tracks were DRM'd it used to be easier to copy CDs, but iTunes has been DRM free for ages now.
Also, AIUI the DRM thing was a condition of some of the music labels. I imagine the current license conditions are too.
iTunes as a piece of software has its faults (though on a Mac it's actually pretty good if you're prepared to roll with how it's designed to work - I used to be a naysayer until I "got it"). But the iTunes store has done much that is positive for easy, legitinate access to music.
When iTunes tracks were DRM'd it used to be easier to copy CDs, but iTunes has been DRM free for ages now.
Also, AIUI the DRM thing was a condition of some of the music labels. I imagine the current license conditions are too.
iTunes as a piece of software has its faults (though on a Mac it's actually pretty good if you're prepared to roll with how it's designed to work - I used to be a naysayer until I "got it"). But the iTunes store has done much that is positive for easy, legitinate access to music.
TheHeretic said:
Apple use AAC, rather than .mp3. However, if you have older music that has DRM, (pre-2007)
I think), then just delete, and redownload a DRM free copy from iTunes. AAC will work on all sorts of devices, consoles, and so on.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Audio_Coding...
Don't believe everything you hear.
I have some DRM'd music from iTunes store. Apple wanted something like 20p per track to upgrade items to the non-DRM versions. that was a year or so ago, but I don't think it's changed. I think), then just delete, and redownload a DRM free copy from iTunes. AAC will work on all sorts of devices, consoles, and so on.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Audio_Coding...
Don't believe everything you hear.
Murph7355 said:
Are the licenses really that radically different than for CDs? Technically I didn't think you were legally allowed to do these things with CDs. Ownership of the physical media does not give rights to do what you want with it (copy it, play it in public etc).
He's not after the rights to copy it, play it in public, etc... just to pass it on to his children, which you can do with ownership of physical media.Pints said:
Good on him.
I support his efforts.
I disagree. He must have read the T&Cs he signed up to when he bought/rented them. It's a legal agreement. He then appears to have changed his mind later and said it's "not fair". He had an open choice to go and purchase music elsewhere if he wanted. I support his efforts.
This will just feed the typical silly anti-apple bods. AFAIK this issues NOT solely an Apple thing, it's a licencing thing that applies to nearly ALL digital media purchased online (music, apps, films, games etc.).
Someone mentioned Amazon, a quick peruse of their T&C indicates that purchases are non-transferable.
I stand to be corrected though, anyone knowledgable around?
Someone mentioned Amazon, a quick peruse of their T&C indicates that purchases are non-transferable.
I stand to be corrected though, anyone knowledgable around?
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


