Why should public sector pay tax?
Why should public sector pay tax?
Author
Discussion

Somewhatfoolish

Original Poster:

5,104 posts

217 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Would it not be considerably more logical to pay public sector employees the equivilant of their current after-tax pay, but with no tax.

You could have similar things for other kinds of tax that the public sector pays.

This would save on a lot of paperwork.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
This has been covered many times before on PH. The issues are many and include,

  • Tax allowances
  • People with two jobs
  • Keeping up appearances

good40

286 posts

175 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Ha ha ha just as if ! My wife recently did some work at a tax office through an agency, to my astonishment she was paid £17.62p per hour, god knows what they pay the agency ?

She said it was a complete shambles & could not believe how inept the managers are, she said they were all back biting etc & decided not to go there again after 1 month, even though the money was good!

My rather convoluted point(sorry) is any change even the one you suggest would cost more as they are in such a mess.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Somewhatfoolish said:
Would it not be considerably more logical to pay public sector employees the equivilant of their current after-tax pay, but with no tax.

You could have similar things for other kinds of tax that the public sector pays.

This would save on a lot of paperwork.
What about the tax due on items other than their salary?

Countdown

49,589 posts

227 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Massive number of reasons. - As well as the ones mentioned above what is "Private sector" and what is "Public Sector"? If we employ an agency worker are they private sector or public sector? What about a "Mgmt Consultant" who operates through an umbrella company?

Also what jobs would it save? The amount of time spent calculating Tax/NI/Superann is fairly small. We apply a patch to our system at year end and there is relatively minimum work spent in-year on tax/NI issues.

Then there's the impact on people on low incomes and welfare benefits.