Especially for Crankedup...
Author
Discussion

DJRC

Original Poster:

23,563 posts

267 months

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
ARRRGGHHH at the first comment!

Indy Reader said:
Oh dear; long-term, hi-tech weapons spending is suicidal. Money invested mostly goes to small numbers of highly-specialized scientists & techies. Old-tech musket & battleship manufacture, etc., employed tens of thousands.

If nations buy peaceful products, like buses & tractors, these contribute to total prosperity, since they are 'productive'. Weapons are a negative. They suck money out of the global economy.

Nevertheless, in a post-capitalist world where 40% fight for the bare necessities of life, splurging gazillions on armaments of baroque complexity makes sense: the sense that prevails in an asylum with maniacs in charge. OGT
It's well recorded that weapons research is responsible for so many of the big advances in civilian technology. Let's take GPS and space travel for a start!

Tartan Pixie

2,216 posts

178 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Puggit said:
It's well recorded that weapons research is responsible for so many of the big advances in civilian technology. Let's take GPS and space travel for a start!
So let me get this straight, are you suggesting that if world peace happened tomorrow we'd suddenly stop wanting to explore space, or that without war Einstein wouldn't have bothered discovering relativity (the maths that makes GPS work)?

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
"tech-geeks"
"one very mad-looking fellow, who bears a remarkable resemblance to Back to the Future's Doc Brown"
"big-brained boffins"
"perhaps the apprentices should avoid taking fashion tips from the wild-haired, shorts-wearing Doc Brown wannabe."

wow. is that what passes for journalism at the independent?

turbobloke

117,583 posts

291 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
fbrs said:
"tech-geeks"
"one very mad-looking fellow, who bears a remarkable resemblance to Back to the Future's Doc Brown"
"big-brained boffins"
"perhaps the apprentices should avoid taking fashion tips from the wild-haired, shorts-wearing Doc Brown wannabe."

wow. is that what passes for journalism at the independent?
After the Johann Hari epoisode you'd think they'd get a grip!

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Tartan Pixie said:
Puggit said:
It's well recorded that weapons research is responsible for so many of the big advances in civilian technology. Let's take GPS and space travel for a start!
So let me get this straight, are you suggesting that if world peace happened tomorrow we'd suddenly stop wanting to explore space, or that without war Einstein wouldn't have bothered discovering relativity (the maths that makes GPS work)?
Not at all, they would have happened eventually - but no where near as fast.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
fbrs said:
"tech-geeks"
"one very mad-looking fellow, who bears a remarkable resemblance to Back to the Future's Doc Brown"
"big-brained boffins"
"perhaps the apprentices should avoid taking fashion tips from the wild-haired, shorts-wearing Doc Brown wannabe."

wow. is that what passes for journalism at the independent?
After the Johann Hari epoisode you'd think they'd get a grip!
just regular second rate, liberal arts, sneering. they can never just write engineer, has to be boffin or geek, i'm a little disapoointed he didnt go for the hatrick with nerd

MX7

7,902 posts

205 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
fbrs said:
wow. is that what passes for journalism at the independent?
Buy a paper copy and then put on your spelingz an gramer hat. It's incredible that it's still printed.

DJRC

Original Poster:

23,563 posts

267 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
fbrs said:
"tech-geeks"
"one very mad-looking fellow, who bears a remarkable resemblance to Back to the Future's Doc Brown"
"big-brained boffins"
"perhaps the apprentices should avoid taking fashion tips from the wild-haired, shorts-wearing Doc Brown wannabe."

wow. is that what passes for journalism at the independent?
Actually the mad looking fellow is pretty much the site personality! We all know/knew him and yet to this day Ive got no idea what he was called or what he did! Nobody else ever seemed to know either! Currently causing some giggles down at Roch that others were named, yet he wasnt smile Nigel Wright mentioned in the article is a good guy to work for.

Its good to see Roch getting some good press, it is afterall pretty much the home of UK aviation, not that you would ever hear any of the glory boys at Farnie admit it.

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
fbrs said:
"tech-geeks"
"one very mad-looking fellow, who bears a remarkable resemblance to Back to the Future's Doc Brown"
"big-brained boffins"
"perhaps the apprentices should avoid taking fashion tips from the wild-haired, shorts-wearing Doc Brown wannabe."

wow. is that what passes for journalism at the independent?
After the Johann Hari epoisode you'd think they'd get a grip!
It appears to have been written by a Mr Mark Leftly. rofl

Tartan Pixie

2,216 posts

178 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Puggit said:
Not at all, they would have happened eventually - but no where near as fast.
So by that thinking we should be glad of the Taliban and all the other fighting in the middle east, as it's speeding up our rate of engineering invention?

By what mechanism does this occur? Does an engineer working on a bomb have some accelerated thought process that an engineer working on a car wouldn't have? smile

Jokes aside I'm actually intrigued by your way of thinking as I just don't get it.

Take for example the US military budget of $683.7Bn vs NASA's budget of $18.7Bn. If NASA had all that money instead of the military I bet we'd get loads of civilian tech to play with, almost certainly more than what dribbles down from DARPA.



On an unrelated note, the independent's worth reading just for Robert Fisk, one of the most clued up Middle East correspondents you'll find in any paper.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Tartan Pixie said:
So let me get this straight, are you suggesting that if world peace happened tomorrow we'd suddenly stop wanting to explore space
You'd have to be stupid to suggest that. We stopped wanting to explore space 40 years ago.

Lost_BMW

12,955 posts

207 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Anyone else clicked the initial link (quoting shows it is supposedly aimed at a genuine Independent site) to get this crap?

http://www.affiliatefuture.co.uk/

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
Yes I got that.

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
TP - here you go:
http://www.csmonitor.com/Innovation/Tech-Culture/2...
http://www.highestfive.com/combat/wartime-innovati...

Roman Roads (the worlds first paved roads), canned food, instant coffee, prosthetic limbs, infra-red imaging, UAVs, space travel, GPS, microwave ovens, Internet- all originally had military purposes.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
War didn't make these things happen, War made us justify spending the money to make it happen. War is only a vehicle for technological progression because war is also a vehicle for spending money.

DJRC

Original Poster:

23,563 posts

267 months

Monday 3rd September 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Tartan Pixie said:
So let me get this straight, are you suggesting that if world peace happened tomorrow we'd suddenly stop wanting to explore space
You'd have to be stupid to suggest that. We stopped wanting to explore space 40 years ago.
No we didnt. More space exploration programmes are currently ongoing by more countries than ever before.

Tartan Pixie

2,216 posts

178 months

Tuesday 4th September 2012
quotequote all
First article from your top link:

article said:
MIT researcher Hugh Herr says he had trouble finding funding for his research into prosthetic limbs before US forces invaded Iraq. Now, thanks to military grants, his innovations can help both soldiers and civilians.
The problem was money, the engineer never lacked the will to make a better product. The idea that without war people wouldn't have thought to pave roads, improve food storage, explore the electromagnetic spectrum or connect computers together is very hard to believe.

Against your examples I'd cite Pythagoras, Isac Newton, Isambard Brunel, Stephen Hawking, Guglielmo Marconi, Thomas Edison and Henry Ford as just a small fraction of people who prospered and invented during peace time. I'd go as far as saying that the number of inventions made during peace time utterly dwarf those made in the name of war.

Don't get me wrong here, in the uncivilized world in which we live I'm glad that our army's got decent kit, however mankind has far more constructive ways of creating the competitive spirit that drives some engineers. Sport and industry would be the obvious examples.


Tartan Pixie

2,216 posts

178 months

Tuesday 4th September 2012
quotequote all
DJRC said:
martin84 said:
Tartan Pixie said:
So let me get this straight, are you suggesting that if world peace happened tomorrow we'd suddenly stop wanting to explore space
You'd have to be stupid to suggest that. We stopped wanting to explore space 40 years ago.
No we didnt. More space exploration programmes are currently ongoing by more countries than ever before.
+1 If the interest sparked by the hubble telescope, curiosity rover or CERN are anything to go by then science never goes out of style. The problem is getting the resources to do it, which does somewhat come back to the topic of war.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Tuesday 4th September 2012
quotequote all
Tartan Pixie said:
Puggit said:
It's well recorded that weapons research is responsible for so many of the big advances in civilian technology. Let's take GPS and space travel for a start!
So let me get this straight, are you suggesting that if world peace happened tomorrow we'd suddenly stop wanting to explore space, or that without war Einstein wouldn't have bothered discovering relativity (the maths that makes GPS work)?
Without war, we would have never got into space to start with. Read up on your history.