A battle for the future of Islam?
Discussion
Let's see if we can have a constructive, rational debate about Islam.
I've been inspired to post after watching Ross Kemp's documentary from Karachi, where to be honest I was really shocked at the level of violence going on out there. Muslims are killing each other in the thousands in the most brutal and shocking of ways.
Now I don't want to turn this into a discussion about religion. This is not a debate about the merit or otherwise of having faith, so let's not get into the "imaginary friend" discussion.
I am not a Muslim, but I have a couple of friends who are Pakistani and next time I see them I will ask what their take on this is, but in the meantime I'm interested to hear of the PH view.
My Pakistani friends have always impressed me with their quiet dignity and their sense of morality. They are studied Muslims with a high sense of morality and their honesty and integrity has really impressed me over the years. They paint a very positive impression of how faith offers a moral code. One of them is named in my will as a guardian if the wife and I should both die.
So how on earth is Islam so corrupted and twisted in the minds of others, to the extent that Muslims apparently can exercise such brutality against each other? Thousands of innocent women, men and children are cut down , slaughtered every year in Karachi alone by people who share the same faith. They are killed because they may be Pashtun, or Sunni, or whatever, with the Taliban also there committing horrifying acts of cruelty.
What is going on? Can anyone here enlighten me so that I can better understand how this faith ( that my experience with my friends is revealed as peaceful and respectful) can also manifest itself with such criminality , apparently perpetuated in the name of their own interpretation of Islam? Or is it just about thugs and gangs fighting over turf - in which case, how do they reconcile this with their faith?
I feel a bit baffled. Enlighten me someone, please.

I've been inspired to post after watching Ross Kemp's documentary from Karachi, where to be honest I was really shocked at the level of violence going on out there. Muslims are killing each other in the thousands in the most brutal and shocking of ways.
Now I don't want to turn this into a discussion about religion. This is not a debate about the merit or otherwise of having faith, so let's not get into the "imaginary friend" discussion.
I am not a Muslim, but I have a couple of friends who are Pakistani and next time I see them I will ask what their take on this is, but in the meantime I'm interested to hear of the PH view.
My Pakistani friends have always impressed me with their quiet dignity and their sense of morality. They are studied Muslims with a high sense of morality and their honesty and integrity has really impressed me over the years. They paint a very positive impression of how faith offers a moral code. One of them is named in my will as a guardian if the wife and I should both die.
So how on earth is Islam so corrupted and twisted in the minds of others, to the extent that Muslims apparently can exercise such brutality against each other? Thousands of innocent women, men and children are cut down , slaughtered every year in Karachi alone by people who share the same faith. They are killed because they may be Pashtun, or Sunni, or whatever, with the Taliban also there committing horrifying acts of cruelty.
What is going on? Can anyone here enlighten me so that I can better understand how this faith ( that my experience with my friends is revealed as peaceful and respectful) can also manifest itself with such criminality , apparently perpetuated in the name of their own interpretation of Islam? Or is it just about thugs and gangs fighting over turf - in which case, how do they reconcile this with their faith?
I feel a bit baffled. Enlighten me someone, please.

Those issues in Pakistan are unlikely JUST to be about faith. Those societies are a lot more tribal and unnaccepting of differences - which is why there are always issues.
Faith is one differentiating fatcor between them all (and probably the main).
If They were not Muslim the killings might not be as much (less to fight about) but there would still be fighting about something or other IMO.
Faith is one differentiating fatcor between them all (and probably the main).
If They were not Muslim the killings might not be as much (less to fight about) but there would still be fighting about something or other IMO.
Mojooo said:
Those issues in Pakistan are unlikely JUST to be about faith. Those societies are a lot more tribal and unnaccepting of differences - which is why there are always issues.
Faith is one differentiating fatcor between them all (and probably the main).
If They were not Muslim the killings might not be as much (less to fight about) but there would still be fighting about something or other IMO.
+1. Tribalism is your answer rather than straight forward religious issues.Faith is one differentiating fatcor between them all (and probably the main).
If They were not Muslim the killings might not be as much (less to fight about) but there would still be fighting about something or other IMO.
steveatesh said:
Mojooo said:
Those issues in Pakistan are unlikely JUST to be about faith. Those societies are a lot more tribal and unnaccepting of differences - which is why there are always issues.
Faith is one differentiating fatcor between them all (and probably the main).
If They were not Muslim the killings might not be as much (less to fight about) but there would still be fighting about something or other IMO.
+1. Tribalism is your answer rather than straight forward religious issues.Faith is one differentiating fatcor between them all (and probably the main).
If They were not Muslim the killings might not be as much (less to fight about) but there would still be fighting about something or other IMO.
Sometimes it's easier to look at others through the lens of your own culture.
By taking the OP then substituting the word Muslim with Christian and Pakistani with Irish, it's possible possible to arrive at a very similar question.
The recent violence in Belfast has very deep roots that arguably go back far beyond Martin Luther, beyond the birth of Jesus, right back to when the Gales first met some blokes from across the water and decided they didn't like each other very much.
For over 2,000 years the same fight has continued, just wrapped in different flags at different times. This is something happening today in the supposedly educated UK, supposedly in the name of Catholic and Protestant.
It's not a fight that can be easily understood without knowing a considerable amount of both European and British history, or the lengths Westminster went to in an attempt to wipe out the Gaelic language. (This isn't ancient history by the way. In Scotland at least, speaking Gaelic in school was outlawed in 1882 and could get you the belt, even as recently as the 1970's).
The reason I write this is that it's easy to be complacent when viewing Pakistan through the lens of Ross Kemp, while sitting in your nice, civilized living room. Sometimes it's better to look through the lens of our own history because, when viewed with warts and all, we're not that different from our Asian friends.
I'm no islamic scholar but would take a guess that for over 2,000 years the same fight has continued, just wrapped in different flags at different times.
By taking the OP then substituting the word Muslim with Christian and Pakistani with Irish, it's possible possible to arrive at a very similar question.
The recent violence in Belfast has very deep roots that arguably go back far beyond Martin Luther, beyond the birth of Jesus, right back to when the Gales first met some blokes from across the water and decided they didn't like each other very much.
For over 2,000 years the same fight has continued, just wrapped in different flags at different times. This is something happening today in the supposedly educated UK, supposedly in the name of Catholic and Protestant.
It's not a fight that can be easily understood without knowing a considerable amount of both European and British history, or the lengths Westminster went to in an attempt to wipe out the Gaelic language. (This isn't ancient history by the way. In Scotland at least, speaking Gaelic in school was outlawed in 1882 and could get you the belt, even as recently as the 1970's).
The reason I write this is that it's easy to be complacent when viewing Pakistan through the lens of Ross Kemp, while sitting in your nice, civilized living room. Sometimes it's better to look through the lens of our own history because, when viewed with warts and all, we're not that different from our Asian friends.
I'm no islamic scholar but would take a guess that for over 2,000 years the same fight has continued, just wrapped in different flags at different times.
Tartan Pixie said:
Sometimes it's easier to look at others through the lens of your own culture.
By taking the OP then substituting the word Muslim with Christian and Pakistani with Irish, it's possible possible to arrive at a very similar question.
The recent violence in Belfast has very deep roots that arguably go back far beyond Martin Luther, beyond the birth of Jesus, right back to when the Gales first met some blokes from across the water and decided they didn't like each other very much.
For over 2,000 years the same fight has continued, just wrapped in different flags at different times. This is something happening today in the supposedly educated UK, supposedly in the name of Catholic and Protestant.
It's not a fight that can be easily understood without knowing a considerable amount of both European and British history, or the lengths Westminster went to in an attempt to wipe out the Gaelic language. (This isn't ancient history by the way. In Scotland at least, speaking Gaelic in school was outlawed in 1882 and could get you the belt, even as recently as the 1970's).
The reason I write this is that it's easy to be complacent when viewing Pakistan through the lens of Ross Kemp, while sitting in your nice, civilized living room. Sometimes it's better to look through the lens of our own history because, when viewed with warts and all, we're not that different from our Asian friends.
I'm no islamic scholar but would take a guess that for over 2,000 years the same fight has continued, just wrapped in different flags at different times.
I think you are reaching here. The widespread slaughter across the Middle East between different elements of the same faith does not have a parallel in modern Christian history IMO. Not since the 1940's. By taking the OP then substituting the word Muslim with Christian and Pakistani with Irish, it's possible possible to arrive at a very similar question.
The recent violence in Belfast has very deep roots that arguably go back far beyond Martin Luther, beyond the birth of Jesus, right back to when the Gales first met some blokes from across the water and decided they didn't like each other very much.
For over 2,000 years the same fight has continued, just wrapped in different flags at different times. This is something happening today in the supposedly educated UK, supposedly in the name of Catholic and Protestant.
It's not a fight that can be easily understood without knowing a considerable amount of both European and British history, or the lengths Westminster went to in an attempt to wipe out the Gaelic language. (This isn't ancient history by the way. In Scotland at least, speaking Gaelic in school was outlawed in 1882 and could get you the belt, even as recently as the 1970's).
The reason I write this is that it's easy to be complacent when viewing Pakistan through the lens of Ross Kemp, while sitting in your nice, civilized living room. Sometimes it's better to look through the lens of our own history because, when viewed with warts and all, we're not that different from our Asian friends.
I'm no islamic scholar but would take a guess that for over 2,000 years the same fight has continued, just wrapped in different flags at different times.
It seems that Islamists not only hate the west, but hate much of their own people too. I don't understand enough of it to get my head around it.
toppstuff said:
How does tribalism trump Islam? That's not in the book. What about brotherhood?
IMO "religion" is one significant way tribes are identified and differentiated. Look at the years of conflict between CofE and Catholics. In reality they're the same religion but a slightly different flavour gives people all the excuse they need to start an argument. Stupid people will always find an excuse and clever people can always invent one.toppstuff said:
I think you are reaching here. The widespread slaughter across the Middle East between different elements of the same faith does not have a parallel in modern Christian history IMO. Not since the 1940's.
It seems that Islamists not only hate the west, but hate much of their own people too. I don't understand enough of it to get my head around it.
It's not Islam's fault. Take a look at why they've been rowing since the 40s. It was one of our excellent post colonial "I can't work out where the tribal boundaries are, so I'll just make up some borders using my set square" exercises. It seems that Islamists not only hate the west, but hate much of their own people too. I don't understand enough of it to get my head around it.
It's not about faith that much - it's just that religious differences provide a much more "moral" reason for slaughter than "I want his land/cows/oil/wives/whatever".
davepoth said:
It's not Islam's fault. Take a look at why they've been rowing since the 40s. It was one of our excellent post colonial "I can't work out where the tribal boundaries are, so I'll just make up some borders using my set square" exercises.
It's not about faith that much - it's just that religious differences provide a much more "moral" reason for slaughter than "I want his land/cows/oil/wives/whatever".
With all due respect, that's bIt's not about faith that much - it's just that religious differences provide a much more "moral" reason for slaughter than "I want his land/cows/oil/wives/whatever".
ks.These people think that all infidels i.e non muslims are a lesser breed and inferior and not worthy of life, therefore to kill them is not a crime in islam, medieval superstitious bulls
t at its worst. The religion of peace and tolerance? Really?Got to bugger off to Landsend in a mo, well, Crewkern (or something like that) to get the car serviced so I’ve little time to deeply consider this, but…
Is it not the case that many of our international cousins are, well, a little behind us?
If we were not involved, would their industrial revolution, unions, strikes, minimum wage, mass health care, mass education etc. not evolve thus heightening their responsibility to one another and the state?
Well housed, well fed and well educated ‘brothers’ do not beat the living daylights out of one another.
Perhaps we shouldn’t get involved?
On a side note (and please do not rip me to shreds), am I right in recalling that two countries with a McDonalds have never gone to war? (for those in doubt, I do not work at McDonalds)

Is it not the case that many of our international cousins are, well, a little behind us?
If we were not involved, would their industrial revolution, unions, strikes, minimum wage, mass health care, mass education etc. not evolve thus heightening their responsibility to one another and the state?
Well housed, well fed and well educated ‘brothers’ do not beat the living daylights out of one another.
Perhaps we shouldn’t get involved?
On a side note (and please do not rip me to shreds), am I right in recalling that two countries with a McDonalds have never gone to war? (for those in doubt, I do not work at McDonalds)

Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




