Faith or job... Government lawyers claim at court...
Faith or job... Government lawyers claim at court...
Author
Discussion

Du1point8

Original Poster:

22,982 posts

223 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
In the European court its been said, leave your faith at home or look for another job... Christians in UK told...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2198201/Ch...

They offer prayer mats to those who want them so they dont offend for other non christian faiths... however its fine to offend the locals if your a Christian.

I hope this gets completely over ruled for such bad double standards.

BJG1

5,966 posts

243 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
The other two cases are those of Lilian Ladele, who was sacked as a registrar by Islington council because she declined to conduct civil partnerships and Gary McFarlane, a Relate counsellor who lost his job in Bristol after admitting to bosses that he felt unable to give sex therapy to gays.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2198201/Ch...

See no reason why these two should have kept their jobs. If your faith does not allow you to do the role required then go find somewhere else to work. I see no reason why Relate should fork out for an extra member of staff because somebody is homophobic.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
They wanted to display their faith by wearing crosses outside their uniforms. The companies were quite happy for both to wear discrete cloth crosses on their clothing but they wanted specifics. The odd thing is that there is no religious requirement for christians to wear crosses so not wearing one is not a mortal sin, like, for instance, wearing a condom. It is a choice of the person. It is not a requirement of their faith. So what they are trying to do is advertise their faith.

spaximus

4,365 posts

284 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
I am not deeply religous but what is wrong is the double standards, if I had a rep who refused to shake hands with a female customer I would be on sticky ground to get rid, equally we allow jews to wear caps Hijabs full viels which I would find strange in a customer facing role.
Now the two cases, if a christian refuses to marry same sex couples due to a belief how would they have handled it if it was a muslim?
The other case, sex therapy would they not want someone who could relate to them and encourage their relationship rather than someone who belives it is wrong.
In both these cases they could have accommadated their beliefs had they wanted to, they weren't the only ones employed in that role.
The laywer in this case who said leave it at the door is correct, so long as it is equally applied.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Correct me if I'm wrong but I can't imagine such a law getting very far in America.

Blib

48,392 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
spaximus said:
Now the two cases, if a christian refuses to marry same sex couples due to a belief how would they have handled it if it was a muslim?
.
My take on this is if the individual has deeply held beliefs which will preclude them from carrying out their contracted duties to their fullest extent, they should not have applied for the job in the first place.

Blib

48,392 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Correct me if I'm wrong but I can't imagine such a law getting very far in America.
The National Secular Society(sic?) are using the example of Rosa Parks to highlight the problems with the claimants' position. In effect, say the NSS, the Christians are saying that it would have been OK for Parks to have been discriminated against and thrown off of the bus for being black so long as a following bus was available that would accept her.

That they, the claimants, should be free to discriminate against gay people and others because there are those in their place of work who do not who could do the job that they refuse to.

otolith

69,806 posts

235 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
They claim they are being picked on, when all that is actually happening is that they are not being allowed to flout the rules everybody else has to obey.

Du1point8

Original Poster:

22,982 posts

223 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Depends what you mean by prelude them from doing their job?

There was a case of a hairdresser that declined to hire a muslim girl as she worn a hijab, part of the hired hairdressers job was to have the latest style and act like a walking advertisement for the salon.

The muslim girl couldnt do this, however this was not the reason given as to why she was not hired, but this is the reason as to the discrimination case and why the girl sued for £32k.

Cant do a job because of faith that makes you not suitable, sue instead.

Blib

48,392 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Applying for and not getting a job is totally different to actually being hired to do a job and refusing to do it to the full extent of the contract that you've signed.

spaximus

4,365 posts

284 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
But in this case what if the registar was employed before the law allowed same sex partnerships to be carried out? There are so many variable and to me it is the fear that it will be once sided that I do not like.

Steameh

3,155 posts

241 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
BJG1 said:
The other two cases are those of Lilian Ladele, who was sacked as a registrar by Islington council because she declined to conduct civil partnerships and Gary McFarlane, a Relate counsellor who lost his job in Bristol after admitting to bosses that he felt unable to give sex therapy to gays.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2198201/Ch...

See no reason why these two should have kept their jobs. If your faith does not allow you to do the role required then go find somewhere else to work. I see no reason why Relate should fork out for an extra member of staff because somebody is homophobic.
And they have gone to the ECHR complaining of discrimination and still have the cheek to call the Government out on double standards? rofl

You couldn't make it up

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
The issue is they chose to make their faith an issue, If you want to wear a crucifix wear one, if your boss says please wear it under your top do it, it isn't discrimination if they are asking for all necklaces to be under a top, in some jobs something round your neck could be a health and safety risk or an infection risk. There are other situations were a religious observance might cause an issue with work.

Zaxxon

4,057 posts

191 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
So, do Rabbi's, Priests and Imam's conduct marriage ceremonies for same sex couples?

If not can they be fired from their role? Would solve a hell of a lot of problems. smile

Blib

48,392 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Zaxxon said:
So, do Rabbi's, Priests and Imam's conduct marriage ceremonies for same sex couples?

If not can they be fired from their role? Would solve a hell of a lot of problems. smile
Not relevant. These people were working for Public bodies.

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
In the European court its been said, leave your faith at home or look for another job... Christians in UK told...
Presumably this will apply to all religions which will result in an awful lot of terminations.....

hornet

6,333 posts

281 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
If the Church wants to deny gay couples the right to be married on the basis it undermines their view on the concept of marriage, then to my mind a manager in an organisation is equally within his/her right to deny employees the right to wear overt religious symbols on the basis it undermines their concept of "work". Can't have it both ways.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Du1point8 said:
In the European court its been said, leave your faith at home or look for another job... Christians in UK told...
Presumably this will apply to all religions which will result in an awful lot of terminations.....
That will be entertaining.

I can see lots of certain religions being very upset and getting very shouty.

hehe

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
Depends what you mean by prelude them from doing their job?

There was a case of a hairdresser that declined to hire a muslim girl as she worn a hijab, part of the hired hairdressers job was to have the latest style and act like a walking advertisement for the salon.

The muslim girl couldnt do this, however this was not the reason given as to why she was not hired, but this is the reason as to the discrimination case and why the girl sued for £32k.

Cant do a job because of faith that makes you not suitable, sue instead.
So when are we getting seperate tills at checkouts that are pork free or alcohol free so as not to offend staff members 'beliefs' (Obviously this will not apply to small shops that sell alcohol to infidels smile)

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 5th September 2012
quotequote all
Blib said:
Zaxxon said:
So, do Rabbi's, Priests and Imam's conduct marriage ceremonies for same sex couples?

If not can they be fired from their role? Would solve a hell of a lot of problems. smile
Not relevant. These people were working for Public bodies.
Unlike the 'religous' couple who rent rooms out in their home but were shafted in the courts for not wanting 'certain' people to patronise their business.

It seems some/many people will complain if they think there's a few quid in it, I'd rather take my business elsewhere or publicly donate any 'winnings' to charity smile