A different side to the benefits trap
Discussion
So I know everyone (myself included) slags off people who sit on benefits not trying to get a job
So here is another side to the story
We recently employed a young lad, on 12k a year, he lives with his missus and they have a young child, they were both on benefits
Young man didn't want to be on benefits so came and got a job and proceeded to work very hard
He has just resigned as he could no longer afford to work for us, essentially as well as losing his benefits, due to having a working partner his missus also lost hers, this meant a 4k drop for them per annum, he just couldn't cope
So well done government, a young tried to escape the benefits trap and he has been plunged right back into it
So here is another side to the story
We recently employed a young lad, on 12k a year, he lives with his missus and they have a young child, they were both on benefits
Young man didn't want to be on benefits so came and got a job and proceeded to work very hard
He has just resigned as he could no longer afford to work for us, essentially as well as losing his benefits, due to having a working partner his missus also lost hers, this meant a 4k drop for them per annum, he just couldn't cope
So well done government, a young tried to escape the benefits trap and he has been plunged right back into it
anonymous said:
[redacted]
How would he have fared under the Universal Credit?http://www.dwp.gov.uk/policy/welfare-reform/univer...
And yeah, perhaps you could have paid him more, that'd show the Gubmint right?
Marf said:
How would he have fared under the Universal Credit
http://www.dwp.gov.uk/policy/welfare-reform/univer...
And yeah, perhaps you could have paid him more, that'd show the Gubmint right?
Looking at it, probably betterhttp://www.dwp.gov.uk/policy/welfare-reform/univer...
And yeah, perhaps you could have paid him more, that'd show the Gubmint right?
We couldn't have paid him more, as it is we did offer a bit more but we couldn't offer enough
TTwiggy said:
Maybe you should have paid him more? 
TBH, and we see this regularly in our region, a lot of kids - in the condition they [airrive[/i] from school or a few years of no job following - are not even fit to earn £12k. Without some sort of restructuring, the benefit trap is very real and seemingly without end.
Marf said:
Fair enough. Shame that something couldn't have been sorted out to hold him over till the UC came in.
I am gonna forward that to his Line Manager and see if we can keep in touch with him, I have a plan to promote a couple of people next year which would leave a slot open for himin a similar situation by sister in law is a single parent nad has just moved house to be nearer to her family. the school her daughter is going to at 5 yrs old can't take her for 5 weeks for some reason.
she gave up a part time job in hull to move to leeds for job and family prospects, and now can't claim jobseekers for 3 weeks and has to stay home to look after her youngest cos she can't got to school yet.... I mean come on....
to add insult to injury someone ran into the back of the car we gave her 3 months ago last night and looks like a right off...
she needs a break!
she gave up a part time job in hull to move to leeds for job and family prospects, and now can't claim jobseekers for 3 weeks and has to stay home to look after her youngest cos she can't got to school yet.... I mean come on....
to add insult to injury someone ran into the back of the car we gave her 3 months ago last night and looks like a right off...
she needs a break!
Did he have an Iphone? Did he run broadband at home for his xbox? Runs a car?
Starting wages are tough - £12k isn't much. But I started out on £11k, lived in a bedsit with my girlfriend for years and years. It was not luxuary. Paid for rent and travel card not much else. You need to tough it out, get the promotions, get the tranining experiance, move job etc in 5 years he could be clearing £20-25k easy.
Starting wages are tough - £12k isn't much. But I started out on £11k, lived in a bedsit with my girlfriend for years and years. It was not luxuary. Paid for rent and travel card not much else. You need to tough it out, get the promotions, get the tranining experiance, move job etc in 5 years he could be clearing £20-25k easy.
Nom de ploom said:
in a similar situation by sister in law is a single parent nad has just moved house to be nearer to her family. the school her daughter is going to at 5 yrs old can't take her for 5 weeks for some reason.
she gave up a part time job in hull to move to leeds for job and family prospects, and now can't claim jobseekers for 3 weeks and has to stay home to look after her youngest cos she can't got to school yet.... I mean come on....
to add insult to injury someone ran into the back of the car we gave her 3 months ago last night and looks like a right off...
she needs a break!
I suppose an 'unnecessary' whiplash claim could be construed as a break she gave up a part time job in hull to move to leeds for job and family prospects, and now can't claim jobseekers for 3 weeks and has to stay home to look after her youngest cos she can't got to school yet.... I mean come on....
to add insult to injury someone ran into the back of the car we gave her 3 months ago last night and looks like a right off...
she needs a break!
.Misuss is looking to stop someones unemployment benefit, in a couple of weeks
Appt 1 not 'cannot make, anniversary of aunties death'
Appt 2, Just didn't show.
Appt 3 Not convenient as going to Blackpool & I don't want to go an hr later,
Personally I'd tell them to FO & whistle for cash when they couldn't make appt 1

JDRoest said:
Marf said:
And yeah, perhaps you could have paid him more, that'd show the Gubmint right?
Of course he could, because it's so easy to make a bigger profit these days....speedyguy said:
Nom de ploom said:
in a similar situation by sister in law is a single parent nad has just moved house to be nearer to her family. the school her daughter is going to at 5 yrs old can't take her for 5 weeks for some reason.
she gave up a part time job in hull to move to leeds for job and family prospects, and now can't claim jobseekers for 3 weeks and has to stay home to look after her youngest cos she can't got to school yet.... I mean come on....
to add insult to injury someone ran into the back of the car we gave her 3 months ago last night and looks like a right off...
she needs a break!
I suppose an 'unnecessary' whiplash claim could be construed as a break she gave up a part time job in hull to move to leeds for job and family prospects, and now can't claim jobseekers for 3 weeks and has to stay home to look after her youngest cos she can't got to school yet.... I mean come on....
to add insult to injury someone ran into the back of the car we gave her 3 months ago last night and looks like a right off...
she needs a break!
.Misuss is looking to stop someones unemployment benefit, in a couple of weeks
Appt 1 not 'cannot make, anniversary of aunties death'
Appt 2, Just didn't show.
Appt 3 Not convenient as going to Blackpool & I don't want to go an hr later,
Personally I'd tell them to FO & whistle for cash when they couldn't make appt 1

cars can be repaired, ppl not so easily so no real drama - the job / benefits things still rankles though...
Marf said:
Whilst my comment was somewhat tongue in cheek there are two factors at play here, the young man's salary and the outgoing benefits policy. Only one of these is within the control of the OP's company.
And profit is directly in the control of the company as well? Not really. I know it was tongue in cheek, but profit does not simply grow on trees. If this guy is ultimately useful to the company, they will pay him to keep him as he certainly impressed them enough. But they can't.I totally agree with the OP. My father's company struggled for years trying to get people, but were constantly outbid by the generosity of benefits. And it's no good saying "pay them more" when they up against Chinese manufacturers paying a fraction of what they can offer.
Prime example.
Single mother, not worked in 8 years. lived in a 1 bed private rent flat (paid for by housing benefit) In Dagenham, Essex.
her rent is an extortionate £1200 per month so her outgoings should she return to work would be (there are other things not listed but to give an example)
£1200 rent
£400 childcare
£100 council tax
£200 monthly travel card
so a girl with no qualifications and hadn't worked for 8 years would need to land a job where she takes home (after tax) £1900 a month before she can break even.
No wonder she's still on benefit.
makes me sick to think of all these private landlords that are making thousands off the government because they sold off all their council houses and have spunked the money before they paid for any new ones to be built..
Single mother, not worked in 8 years. lived in a 1 bed private rent flat (paid for by housing benefit) In Dagenham, Essex.
her rent is an extortionate £1200 per month so her outgoings should she return to work would be (there are other things not listed but to give an example)
£1200 rent
£400 childcare
£100 council tax
£200 monthly travel card
so a girl with no qualifications and hadn't worked for 8 years would need to land a job where she takes home (after tax) £1900 a month before she can break even.
No wonder she's still on benefit.
makes me sick to think of all these private landlords that are making thousands off the government because they sold off all their council houses and have spunked the money before they paid for any new ones to be built..
Pixelpeep said:
Prime example.
Single mother, not worked in 8 years. lived in a 1 bed private rent flat (paid for by housing benefit) In Dagenham, Essex.
her rent is an extortionate £1200 per month so her outgoings should she return to work would be (there are other things not listed but to give an example)
£1200 rent
£400 childcare
£100 council tax
£200 monthly travel card
so a girl with no qualifications and hadn't worked for 8 years would need to land a job where she takes home (after tax) £1900 a month before she can break even.
No wonder she's still on benefit.
makes me sick to think of all these private landlords that are making thousands off the government because they sold off all their council houses and have spunked the money before they paid for any new ones to be built..
That is crazy! One of my best friends lives in a council house, a 2 bed semi, and they (he and his wife - both working and no benefits) pay around £280 per month rent. How can £1200 per month ever be justified, and for a flat, too!Single mother, not worked in 8 years. lived in a 1 bed private rent flat (paid for by housing benefit) In Dagenham, Essex.
her rent is an extortionate £1200 per month so her outgoings should she return to work would be (there are other things not listed but to give an example)
£1200 rent
£400 childcare
£100 council tax
£200 monthly travel card
so a girl with no qualifications and hadn't worked for 8 years would need to land a job where she takes home (after tax) £1900 a month before she can break even.
No wonder she's still on benefit.
makes me sick to think of all these private landlords that are making thousands off the government because they sold off all their council houses and have spunked the money before they paid for any new ones to be built..
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




