Cleggie & 'Bigot-Gate'
Discussion
Clegg has had to backtrack faster than an Italian Tank over his leaked speech calling those against gay marrage bigots. The Catholic Church and parts of the C of E are against same sex marriage and feel being called a bigot for having a strong religious standpoint is too strong a term.
Does standing up for your beliefs make you a bigot? If so, that's an awful lot of people put in the same catagory as the loony Tea Party nutters in the States.
On the other hand, a sad story has emerged from Ieuan Evans, the Welsh rugby player, whose sister threw herself off a cliff because she had feelings for another woman and was so ashamed.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/lifestyle/9525840/Ieuan...
As a society, are we that bigotted as to drive someone to do that?
Does standing up for your beliefs make you a bigot? If so, that's an awful lot of people put in the same catagory as the loony Tea Party nutters in the States.
On the other hand, a sad story has emerged from Ieuan Evans, the Welsh rugby player, whose sister threw herself off a cliff because she had feelings for another woman and was so ashamed.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/lifestyle/9525840/Ieuan...
As a society, are we that bigotted as to drive someone to do that?
Fishtigua said:
Does standing up for your beliefs make you a bigot?
If those beliefs assert that certain types of people are worth less than others and should be treated differently by society at large then yes, bigot fits the bill quite nicely.Religion is a prime example of this and Clegg shouldn't be shamed into editing his speech.
TonyHetherington said:
I just looked up the term, to be 100% sure on its meaning;
I would suggest that the bigots are those that insist on equality - as they are utterly intolerant of those that don't believe in equality dictionary said:
a person who is utterly intolerant of any differing creed, belief, or opinion.
So, yes, they are by their very definition 'bigots'.
TonyHetherington said:
So, yes, they are by their very definition 'bigots'.
Nope - one can be tolerant of a belief without agreeing with it. By your definition, in order to avoid being a bigot, one would have to agree with everyone.And since you seem intolerant of their beliefs - what does that make you?
Bluebarge said:
TonyHetherington said:
So, yes, they are by their very definition 'bigots'.
Nope - one can be tolerant of a belief without agreeing with it. By your definition, in order to avoid being a bigot, one would have to agree with everyone.And since you seem intolerant of their beliefs - what does that make you?
Clegg should have grown a spine and stuck to it.
If the CofE are upset by it, they should look inwardly and if committed to their belief, why be concerned what others think of it?
Personally I think religion and politics should be 100% separated. They should be free to let into their club whoever they want, but if they do not want politicians expressing views on their club, they should keep their mouths shut when they have opinions on policitians.
If the CofE are upset by it, they should look inwardly and if committed to their belief, why be concerned what others think of it?
Personally I think religion and politics should be 100% separated. They should be free to let into their club whoever they want, but if they do not want politicians expressing views on their club, they should keep their mouths shut when they have opinions on policitians.
Fishtigua said:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/lifestyle/9525840/Ieuan...
As a society, are we that bigotted as to drive someone to do that?
From reading that story there is no evidence at all that anyone treated her in a bigoted way, it's a very sad story, but from what I read what was really cutting her up wasn't so much being a closet Lesbian as the fact that she felt terrible guilt about breaking up her family and upsetting her children and her husband by leaving them. I suspect she would have felt just as guilty had the 'other person' been a man. As a society, are we that bigotted as to drive someone to do that?
TonyHetherington said:
Is being "against" something, "tolerant" of it? I don't believe so.
The Church is opposed to the proposals on gay marriage. That doesn't make it intolerant. It just means it disagrees with the proposal. Tolerance is about acknowledging the right of alternative viewpoints to exist, it doesn't mean agreeing with them. Ironically, in characterising opponents of his reforms as "bigots" Cleggie is himself showing intolerance of other's beliefs. Which is odd, for a liberal.Fishtigua said:
Clegg has had to backtrack faster than an Italian Tank over his leaked speech calling those against gay marrage bigots. The Catholic Church and parts of the C of E are against same sex marriage and feel being called a bigot for having a strong religious standpoint is too strong a term.
Does standing up for your beliefs make you a bigot? If so, that's an awful lot of people put in the same catagory as the loony Tea Party nutters in the States.
On the other hand, a sad story has emerged from Ieuan Evans, the Welsh rugby player, whose sister threw herself off a cliff because she had feelings for another woman and was so ashamed.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/lifestyle/9525840/Ieuan...
As a society, are we that bigotted as to drive someone to do that?
I love the way you begin a discussion on bigottry with an aside of describing as "loony nutters" people whos politics you disagree with. Nice.Does standing up for your beliefs make you a bigot? If so, that's an awful lot of people put in the same catagory as the loony Tea Party nutters in the States.
On the other hand, a sad story has emerged from Ieuan Evans, the Welsh rugby player, whose sister threw herself off a cliff because she had feelings for another woman and was so ashamed.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/lifestyle/9525840/Ieuan...
As a society, are we that bigotted as to drive someone to do that?
I'm happy enough if Clegg wants to call people who, because of their own religious belief, would prevent homosexuals having the same rights as heterosexuals bigots. Sexual orientation is innate, religion is a matter of choice. The religious are free to practice their religion, not to impose it or its tenets on others.
Against Gay Marriage? Nah, couldn't care less. I have a cousin who likes cock and he seems very happy with his partner so why not let them get wed.
Gay couples adopting/having kids? Completely different ball game and I guess I'd have to live with being called a bigot if that's what I'd be labeled as.
Gay couples adopting/having kids? Completely different ball game and I guess I'd have to live with being called a bigot if that's what I'd be labeled as.
rohrl said:
I'm happy enough if Clegg wants to call people who, because of their own religious belief, would prevent homosexuals having the same rights as heterosexuals bigots. Sexual orientation is innate, religion is a matter of choice. The religious are free to practice their religion, not to impose it or its tenets on others.
But they have the same rights - civil partnerships.What Cleggie wants to do is force Churches to conduct same-sex marriages when that is contrary to their beliefs. Apart from Stalin and the Chinese Communist party, who else has tried to interfere with religious doctrine in this way?
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




