Two UK Troops Shot Dead
Author
Discussion

Apache

Original Poster:

39,731 posts

315 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
The sooner they get our boys out of that sthole the better, senseless waste of life

http://news.sky.com/story/985600/afghan-attack-two...

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Should never have waded in to begin with.

"oh but what about the taliban and womens rights? What about supporting democracy?" people will cry

What the f-ck do you think will happen the moment the coalition pulls out? It'll go back to the tribal medieval sh-thole it's always been.

Elroy Blue

8,858 posts

223 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
It ceased to become anywhere near viable when Cameron traded the lives of British troops for a few votes and announced to all the World we would be withdrawing in 2014 regardless. Our Military leaders were aghast at this comment

The Taleban have no reason to stop, negotiate or anything. They now know they just need to sit until 2014. Why stop fighting when you KNOW you're going to win in a few years.

They should just get them out now. Waiting till 2014 means we're just wasting lives.

glazbagun

15,383 posts

228 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Eight Afghan women killed in NATO airstrike. NATO apologises for civilian deaths.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-19616356

I can't help but feel that the US/Western powers have played straight into the hands of Al Qaeda since Sep 11. If the Soviets gave up on the place, what chance did we ever have of building a stable nation? That said, I haven't read much (anything) on life in Afghanistan before/after the invasion. Maybe our efforts are worth it in the eyes of Johhny Afghan Everyman.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
It ceased to become anywhere near viable when Cameron traded the lives of British troops for a few votes and announced to all the World we would be withdrawing in 2014 regardless. Our Military leaders were aghast at this comment

The Taleban have no reason to stop, negotiate or anything. They now know they just need to sit until 2014. Why stop fighting when you KNOW you're going to win in a few years.

They should just get them out now. Waiting till 2014 means we're just wasting lives.
Erm, your point doesn't make sense.

If you know the forces are pulling out in 2 years time do you:-

A) Keep fighting an enemy you know are withdrawing in 24 months, losing lives, resources and credibility or;

B) Sit back and wait for two years until the enemy has withdrawn then take over the country with little resistance using the resources and planning you've been saving up for 2 years?

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
It ceased to become anywhere near viable when Cameron traded the lives of British troops for a few votes and announced to all the World we would be withdrawing in 2014 regardless. Our Military leaders were aghast at this comment
You say this as if any other leader would have never pulled out. We were always going to pull out and we would always have announced it ahead of time, otherwise how would the power structures we've put in place prepare for our departure.


Elroy Blue said:
They should just get them out now.
Agreed.

Zaxxon

4,057 posts

191 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
It ceased to become anywhere near viable when Cameron traded the lives of British troops for a few votes and announced to all the World we would be withdrawing in 2014 regardless. Our Military leaders were aghast at this comment

The Taleban have no reason to stop, negotiate or anything. They now know they just need to sit until 2014. Why stop fighting when you KNOW you're going to win in a few years.

They should just get them out now. Waiting till 2014 means we're just wasting lives.
It ceased to be viable when the Labour murderer joined in the invasion of Afghanistan and also Iraq beforehand.


Elroy Blue

8,858 posts

223 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
Erm, your point doesn't make sense.

If you know the forces are pulling out in 2 years time do you:-

A) Keep fighting an enemy you know are withdrawing in 24 months, losing lives, resources and credibility or;

B) Sit back and wait for two years until the enemy has withdrawn then take over the country with little resistance using the resources and planning you've been saving up for 2 years?
Oh! You again.

It's not bloody rocket science. The Taleban lose every encounter with the Coalition. If they think our troops are there for the long haul, then they MIGHT be persuaded to negotiate and seek a settlement.

They now KNOW that the troops are leaving. So they carry on fighting enough to remind eveyone they are still around. They don't have to worry about preserving their strength. They can afford to take losses over the coming months knowing that their major enemies will be gone in the near future.

You can disagree with my view, but it just happens to have been the view of the military who were not only mortified at Cameron's announcement, they were completely surprised by it as well

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
They now KNOW that the troops are leaving.
Granted, but we were always going to leave, weren't we? As such the timing is largely irrelevant as the Taleban would just bide their time until we did leave, whether we left tomorrow, in 2014 or 2020.

Afghanistan has been a folly.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
Oh! You again.

It's not bloody rocket science. The Taleban lose every encounter with the Coalition. If they think our troops are there for the long haul, then they MIGHT be persuaded to negotiate and seek a settlement.

They now KNOW that the troops are leaving. So they carry on fighting enough to remind eveyone they are still around. They don't have to worry about preserving their strength. They can afford to take losses over the coming months knowing that their major enemies will be gone in the near future.

You can disagree with my view, but it just happens to have been the view of the military who were not only mortified at Cameron's announcement, they were completely surprised by it as well
The Taliban beat the Russians and they'll beat the West. They were there before 9/11 and they'll be there long after we've all gone home.

You can make cheap and simplistic political shots against the government all you want, it doesn't make you any more right.

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Exactly, the colour of the tie in number 10 is totally irrelevant, we'd always have left and the taleban would always have returned.

Countdown

49,592 posts

227 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
It's not bloody rocket science. The Taleban lose every encounter with the Coalition. If they think our troops are there for the long haul, then they MIGHT be persuaded to negotiate and seek a settlement.

They now KNOW that the troops are leaving. So they carry on fighting enough to remind eveyone they are still around. They don't have to worry about preserving their strength. They can afford to take losses over the coming months knowing that their major enemies will be gone in the near future.
I think you're wrong. Your judgement is based on what we in the west would consider win-lose. As you point out they "lose" every encounter with the Coalition AND they know the Coalition will be leaving soon. Any logical military commander would save his strengths for the war that will take place AFTER the Coalition have left.

But Afghans in general and Pathans in particular don't think like that. It's a primarily a matter of family / tribal pride, mixed with Jihadi fervour, and financed by Opium money. There's other peripheral issues, such as a proxy war going on between Pakistan and India.

The only way to have imposed "peace" would have been to inflict total war (including the use of chemical / biological weapons) combined with extensive bribery of the warlords (As the saying goes - you can never buy an Afghan's loyalty, but you may be able to rent it).

Forget the democracy and human rights stuff - when you're fighting an enemy who lives in the 15th Century on his ground you will only win by playing under his rules.

Or, even better, not get involved in pointless wars that bring no benefit and huge cost.

Apache

Original Poster:

39,731 posts

315 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
To me the most repulsive thing about it all is the absurd and lethal RoE that our guys have to operate under

Elroy Blue

8,858 posts

223 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
You can make cheap and simplistic political shots against the government all you want, it doesn't make you any more right.
Best you e-mail that comment to the Military leaders who were amazed at Cameron's announcement. I'm sure they'll take it on board.

I don't care what colour the Government of the day is. A Politician demonstrating they are an idiot will always be an idiotic Politician.

Perhaps you should stop being a Tory fanboy for a day. You might sound a bit more credible.

Countdown

49,592 posts

227 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Apache said:
To me the most repulsive thing about it all is the absurd and lethal RoE that our guys have to operate under
Which rules would you change?

The only we we will win is by adapting the same barbaric ROE that the enemy use.

Apache

Original Poster:

39,731 posts

315 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Apache said:
To me the most repulsive thing about it all is the absurd and lethal RoE that our guys have to operate under
Which rules would you change?

The only we we will win is by adapting the same barbaric ROE that the enemy use.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2167103/UK-troops-told-Dont-shoot-unless-shot--Helmand-casualties-soar.html

croyde

26,548 posts

261 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
I know that there are people that need helping over there but we can't help everyone especially at the cost of young lads being killed and crippled. Plenty of people need help closer to home and would be grateful for it.

Leave the fekin' savages to sort their own stinking sthole out. They don't even have proper toilets fer chrissakes!

Better idea would be to build a wall around the place and make sure no one gets out. Might make the world a safer place. I'm really sick that my life gets affected by a these idiots, from getting on a plane to never having seen the twin towers.

Nuke 'em from orbit I say biggrin

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Countdown said:
I think you're wrong. Your judgement is based on what we in the west would consider win-lose. As you point out they "lose" every encounter with the Coalition AND they know the Coalition will be leaving soon. Any logical military commander would save his strengths for the war that will take place AFTER the Coalition have left.

But Afghans in general and Pathans in particular don't think like that. It's a primarily a matter of family / tribal pride, mixed with Jihadi fervour, and financed by Opium money. There's other peripheral issues, such as a proxy war going on between Pakistan and India.

The only way to have imposed "peace" would have been to inflict total war (including the use of chemical / biological weapons) combined with extensive bribery of the warlords (As the saying goes - you can never buy an Afghan's loyalty, but you may be able to rent it).

Forget the democracy and human rights stuff - when you're fighting an enemy who lives in the 15th Century on his ground you will only win by playing under his rules.

Or, even better, not get involved in pointless wars that bring no benefit and huge cost.
sounds good to me.