Sarah Catt jailed for full-term abortion of baby
Discussion
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-york-north-yo...
I'm a little unsure of what to make of it. very disturbing and she got 8 years, I'm sure if i feel a little sorry for her and the size of her sentence or that she deserves it sue to aborting a 39 week baby.
There are some strange people about.
I'm a little unsure of what to make of it. very disturbing and she got 8 years, I'm sure if i feel a little sorry for her and the size of her sentence or that she deserves it sue to aborting a 39 week baby.
There are some strange people about.
Heard this on the lunchtime news. She's effectively been done for murder hasn't she?
All the same, bizarre woman:
All the same, bizarre woman:
Article said:
The defendant gave a child up for adoption in 1999, the court was told.
She later had a termination with the agreement of her husband, tried to terminate another pregnancy but missed the legal limit and concealed another pregnancy from her husband before the child's birth.
She later had a termination with the agreement of her husband, tried to terminate another pregnancy but missed the legal limit and concealed another pregnancy from her husband before the child's birth.
I just don't understand why she just didn't put the baby up for adoption, and how the hell did the husband not notice she was pregnant!!!
i believe that at 38 weeks a baby is classed as full term nowadays so yes, she was probably treated as if she had murder the baby, although i feel the mental is strong in that particular woman.
i believe that at 38 weeks a baby is classed as full term nowadays so yes, she was probably treated as if she had murder the baby, although i feel the mental is strong in that particular woman.
Davel said:
Mixed thoughts really.
I feel sorry for her and feel that she's been made an example of.
Equally, I'm not sure how aware or formed the 'baby' would have been and if he/she would have suffered.
Should / Could she not have had the termination done earlier?
Baby was 1 week before due date. Baby is classed as full term (ie completely normal birth) from 38 weeks old. And can survive an awful lot younger, too. Friend of ours was 6 weeks early, no real problems. Another friend had twins born at about 30 weeks iirc, they were both ill and small but pulled through.I feel sorry for her and feel that she's been made an example of.
Equally, I'm not sure how aware or formed the 'baby' would have been and if he/she would have suffered.
Should / Could she not have had the termination done earlier?
I hadn't read the number of weeks to be honest - and I have twin boys who were six weeks premature who also survived, thanks to the amazing hospital Doctors and Nurses.
I'm just not sure, in my own mind, if 'murder' is still the right term for the termination and if eight years is the right penalty in this case.
Maybe it is.
I'm just not sure, in my own mind, if 'murder' is still the right term for the termination and if eight years is the right penalty in this case.
Maybe it is.
Not sure how formed and aware the child was?
Picture a Nazi stormtrooper ripping a new born from its mother's grip and bayoneting it - That's pretty disturbing and emotive, no?
Well aborting a 39 week old 'foetus' is basically the same thing...
Either an evil, self absorbed woman or a certifiable head case...
M.
Picture a Nazi stormtrooper ripping a new born from its mother's grip and bayoneting it - That's pretty disturbing and emotive, no?
Well aborting a 39 week old 'foetus' is basically the same thing...
Either an evil, self absorbed woman or a certifiable head case...
M.
Zod said:
Davel said:
Equally, I'm not sure how aware or formed the 'baby' would have been and if he/she would have suffered.
At 39 weeks? That's a week before term.Either way, it's 15 weeks after the limit for abortions, and roughly 15 weeks later than the most prematurely born baby that has survived.
CommanderJameson said:
I'm not a doctor so it's with a vastly misplaced sense of confidence that I pronounce that she's probably mentally ill and should be in a hospital, not a prison.
If that were the case I suspect she'd have used it as a defense or mitigation to reduce sentance.IMO an 8 stretch is too good for her, she deserves a life sentance and should have been tried for murder (which carries mandatory life sentancing)
Catweazle said:
I think there is a crime of infanticide on the statute.Article doesn't actually say what she was charged with does it?
Thats an apalling crime. She's had children before and let it get to 30 weeks before noticing she was pregnant? Then decided to wait another 9 weeks to abort what could well have been a totally healthy baby?
Shocking. She's either mental or unbelievably dumb/selfish. How can aborting your own child at 39 weeks be facourable to telling your husband you've been playing away?
Shocking. She's either mental or unbelievably dumb/selfish. How can aborting your own child at 39 weeks be facourable to telling your husband you've been playing away?
hornetrider said:
mattnunn said:
Article doesn't actually say what she was charged with does it?
Yeah - but its a weird one.Article said:
The defendant pleaded guilty in July to administering a poison with intent to procure a miscarriage.
I don't suspect she'll get an easy time in jail if "Cell Block H" is anything to go by kiddy killers aren't liked in womens jails. I hope Rita gets a hold of her.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


