New housing development locking out the needy, your views
New housing development locking out the needy, your views
Author
Discussion

rogerthefish

Original Poster:

2,400 posts

262 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all

I am aware that lots of developers hate having to create a portion of new builds to social housing, and there would be nothing worse than using your hard earned to purchase a flat then have social "layabouts" move in underneath you which I believe is a big inner city problem.

Anyway the views of the country mansion owning PH users are welcome, as well as the bedsit dwellers.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/its...

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
rogerthefish said:
I am aware that lots of developers hate having to create a portion of new builds to social housing, and there would be nothing worse than using your hard earned to purchase a flat then have social "layabouts" move in underneath you which I believe is a big inner city problem.

Anyway the views of the country mansion owning PH users are welcome, as well as the bedsit dwellers.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/its...
As it has been shown if you throw a load of people together who are all jobless, formerly hopeless, in need of care, etc then the area will despoil rather quickly.

Look at how the developments of the 60s have now turned out.

This is why they have looked to create a mix of people, business and properties.

dav123a

1,220 posts

190 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
What was there before ?

greygoose

9,674 posts

226 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
dav123a said:
What was there before ?
Land owned by railways and DHL so sidings and warehousing I guess. I think adding in homeless residents is a mistake as these will probably be the most troubled of residents, they wouldn't be my ideal neighbours that's for sure.

I'm surprised it is legal to say the mentally ill cannot apply for these homes, sounds like discrimination confused .

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
greygoose said:
dav123a said:
What was there before ?
Land owned by railways and DHL so sidings and warehousing I guess. I think adding in homeless residents is a mistake as these will probably be the most troubled of residents, they wouldn't be my ideal neighbours that's for sure.

I'm surprised it is legal to say the mentally ill cannot apply for these homes, sounds like discrimination confused .
This will be for those requiring attention or care and having a certain number of people who need as a maximum

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Social/cheap housing need not be scumball housing

blueg33

47,015 posts

255 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Social engineering rarely works and in some cases mixing social housing with luxury housing doesnt work, although you get rich scum bags too.

Mental health is a tricky one. One of my JV companies creates developments for people with mental health problems, they need to be in the community but not all communities are suitable as there are some with a very high proportion of bigots.

I think the developer is wrong in the case stated and he hasn't taken steps to properly understand the imp-act on his sales and development which will be negligable. Some years ago, I bought a site for luxury homes and was later dismayed to find that it shared an access with homes for people with mental health problems, and they would often be wandering in and out. This had absolutely zero impact on the sales and the site remains popular when houses come onto the market.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Maybe i'm miss reading the article but it appears they are keeping the window lickers and scumballs out of it.

So why should they not make houses for people who are on low wages. you know ones like me who aren't earning 6 figure salaries

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
An unusually sensible decision for a labour run council.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
Maybe i'm miss reading the article but it appears they are keeping the window lickers and scumballs out of it.

So why should they not make houses for people who are on low wages. you know ones like me who aren't earning 6 figure salaries
Nobody is suggesting that. But there is no need for someone on an average or below average salary to live in one of the most expensive parts of one of the most expensive cities in the world. You are less than an hour away from the far suburbs by underground, where rent is much more reasonable.

A section 106 agreement means that the developer gets to build the social housing somewhere a bit cheaper in return for building more social housing than it otherwise would have under the normal regulations.

Developer makes more money from selling posh flats, more social housing gets built. This is a good thing.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
elster said:
As it has been shown if you throw a load of people together who are all jobless, formerly hopeless, in need of care, etc then the area will despoil rather quickly.

Look at how the developments of the 60s have now turned out.
Quite. Some developments in the 70's were torn down before the end of the decade. Look at America for a different way of doing things, they don't favour integration and instead seek to contain problems in certain areas. This makes the problem even worse and results in areas of cities where you simply cannot go. When a friend of mine finally buckled and took the kids to Disneyland, Florida; one of the first things they were told when arriving in Orlando was 'don't go to x, y and z' because all the criminal scum is essentially caged in to certain neighbourhoods with extremely high levels of gun crime, drugs, homelessness, murder, poverty etc. But two streets away it's fine.

Here we believe if we put wasters in the same street as non-wasters it'll bring them closer to civilisation and improvement. For the most part it does work. The downside is any development - even a small one - of social housing does bring down property prices and there will always be those claiming it 'brings down the tone' of the neighbourhood.

blueg33

47,015 posts

255 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
davepoth said:
A section 106 agreement means that the developer gets to build the social housing somewhere a bit cheaper in return for building more social housing than it otherwise would have under the normal regulations.

Not necessarily. Housing needs assessment decides where affordable housing is located, it decides the mix and tenure mix. The developer negotiates this. The S106 is merely a legal document setting out the obligations to deliver what has been agreed.

Its actually very difficult to negotiate away social housing onto another site, a developer will rarely have access to a suitable site close enough, not many land owners will sell a site at below market value, most developers have to make each site stack up on its own merits, buying land on a portfolio basis (ie valuing based on your other land holdings) can be very risky

Colonial

13,553 posts

236 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
I live in a nice, modern unit development.

Very well built and finished, excellent appliances etc etc.

It is in one of the best suburbs in the city.

In the security parking area there is a mix of relatively tasty motors (this is Australia, so cars do cost more etc) - Turbo'd S200, plenty of late model Aussie muscle, Maserati coupe, a lot of 4WDs, a few BMWs and Mercs.

It is around 35 units. 4 or 5 of them are social housing.

And, to be honest, they are the best, most well behaved neighbours in the entire block. They recognise how fortunate they are to have accomodation in a nice building, of a far higher standard than state provided housing and respond as such.

cptsideways

13,906 posts

283 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all

Next door was bought up by the local Housing Association, nothing but Psycho's (she was sectioned) Noise making jobless scum & currently Drug Dealers.

Do not buy a property with social housing next door!


Edited by cptsideways on Tuesday 25th September 10:55

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Nobody is suggesting that. But there is no need for someone on an average or below average salary to live in one of the most expensive parts of one of the most expensive cities in the world. You are less than an hour away from the far suburbs by underground, where rent is much more reasonable.
I don't live in London, how much does an underground season ticket cost?

blueg33

47,015 posts

255 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
EDLT said:
I don't live in London, how much does an underground season ticket cost?
About £3k pa, thats £57 per week or £250 a month.

fido

18,938 posts

286 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
EDLT said:
I don't live in London, how much does an underground season ticket cost?
http://www.tfl.gov.uk/tickets/14416.aspx

Zones 1-4 is about £1,600 p.a. It's a typical commute for most non-subsidised workers.

Borghetto

3,286 posts

214 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
What is wrong with favouring social housing applicants who hold down jobs, pay their rent and do not have a history of bad behaviour. Certainly in the 60's local council tenants could improve the properties they could move into, by being responsible tenants. These 'good' tenants were of course the one's who took advantage of the right to buy legislation. If being a good tenant has some upside, perhaps the bad tenants will make the effort to improve.

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
Borghetto said:
What is wrong with favouring social housing applicants who hold down jobs, pay their rent and do not have a history of bad behaviour. Certainly in the 60's local council tenants could improve the properties they could move into, by being responsible tenants. These 'good' tenants were of course the one's who took advantage of the right to buy legislation. If being a good tenant has some upside, perhaps the bad tenants will make the effort to improve.
When you say bad tenant Im assuming you mean the unemployable who are giving a nice place via the council to live in?

What makes you think that they will become a good tenant, like those holding down jobs or trying to get key-time housing, there is no incentive and it has been seen time and time again that they just dont care.

Yet time and time again, people will fight for the right of these people and demand they are housed with people paying for the right to live in the expensive property... if they are so concerned why is it they never want these people near them, only in the new housing projects.

Also as has been mentioned, sell the expensive stuff to those that can pay for it and redevelop some other area with the extra cash??

For example if the KX property would at the moment bring in £40 million in current guise, but would bring in £50 million if social housing not done, then the extra £10 million can be used to redevelop another location instead of giving up prime location for free.

Developers only need to build 3/4 sites like that and hey presto a brand new development for free at no cost to anyone where social housing in london can take place. Then stick strict 3 strike and out rules on the development and anyone breaking them is kicked out asap.

Borghetto

3,286 posts

214 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
When you say bad tenant Im assuming you mean the unemployable who are giving a nice place via the council to live in?

What makes you think that they will become a good tenant, like those holding down jobs or trying to get key-time housing, there is no incentive and it has been seen time and time again that they just dont care.

Yet time and time again, people will fight for the right of these people and demand they are housed with people paying for the right to live in the expensive property... if they are so concerned why is it they never want these people near them, only in the new housing projects.

Also as has been mentioned, sell the expensive stuff to those that can pay for it and redevelop some other area with the extra cash??

For example if the KX property would at the moment bring in £40 million in current guise, but would bring in £50 million if social housing not done, then the extra £10 million can be used to redevelop another location instead of giving up prime location for free.

Developers only need to build 3/4 sites like that and hey presto a brand new development for free at no cost to anyone where social housing in london can take place. Then stick strict 3 strike and out rules on the development and anyone breaking them is kicked out asap.
I think you have misunderstood my argument. If you are a bad tenant you don't get offered the better properties. The current situation is one based on need, so single mums, large families and other 'needy' types get priority. So single working people and working couples are at the bottom of the list, these are the same people who may have low paid jobs and see non workers living better than them. Somebody with a work ethic could easily find work within a short walk of N1 and they are likely to meet my definition of a good tenant. In case you think I have no experience of good and bad tenants, I had two years as a volunteer adviser at the CAB and I've seen close up how 'bad tenants' can blight the lives of all their neighbours.