Schools ripped off and left with debts
Schools ripped off and left with debts
Author
Discussion

Miguel Alvarez

Original Poster:

5,195 posts

201 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews...

I heard about this on the radio this morning. Long and short some schools appear to have been duped into dodgy finance deals for over priced IT equipment.


zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Miguel Alvarez said:
... some schools appear to have been duped into dodgy finance deals for over priced IT equipment.
Replace "Some Schools" with "The Entire Government" and "IT" with "Anything you care to mention" (hospitals, buildings, entire schools, complete IT networks and systems) and you have PFI, courtesy of the last administration.

And the words 'Ripped off' are most definitely accurate.


Oli.

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
zcacogp said:
Replace "Some Schools" with "The Entire Government" and "IT" with "Anything you care to mention" (hospitals, buildings, entire schools, complete IT networks and systems) and you have PFI, courtesy of the last administration.

And the words 'Ripped off' are most definitely accurate.


Oli.
This.

And let's face it, we all knew it was coming.

Carfiend

3,186 posts

240 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Well from reading a few pieces on this it seems the company bought the PCs at a huge price claiming that the school didn't need to pay anything as they were being paid for by corporate sponsorship. The company then goes bust leaving the school needing to service the debt.

The question I have is why are head teachers making decisions involving money and snake in the grass leasing companies. I would make sure anything with that kind of value was gone over by a solicitor before putting ink to paper.

Sticks.

9,726 posts

282 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
zcacogp said:
Replace "Some Schools" with "The Entire Government" and "IT" with "Anything you care to mention" (hospitals, buildings, entire schools, complete IT networks and systems) and you have PFI, courtesy of the last administration.

And the words 'Ripped off' are most definitely accurate.


Oli.
Started under John Major iirc.

muffinmenace

1,100 posts

219 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Sticks. said:
Started under John Major iirc.
And 'blossomed' in the last ten years...

Miguel Alvarez

Original Poster:

5,195 posts

201 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
zcacogp said:
Replace "Some Schools" with "The Entire Government" and "IT" with "Anything you care to mention" (hospitals, buildings, entire schools, complete IT networks and systems) and you have PFI, courtesy of the last administration.

And the words 'Ripped off' are most definitely accurate.


Oli.
Lol. Well corrected. Point taken.

Happy82

15,078 posts

200 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
"Liz Steel was forced to quit as head of Glemsford Primary School, Suffolk, when it emerged her school owed more than £500,000 for 125 laptops"


eek

Surely she'd have looked through the figures before agreeing to it? Or were head teachers given a bribe to accept them?

Miguel Alvarez

Original Poster:

5,195 posts

201 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Well when the topic came up on the radio this morning someone I forget their name now suggested that teachers shouldn't be liable for blame as they don't have the business/commercial experience to make these decisions. I'm sure it wasn't meant as the comical quote it was but it certainly made me laugh.


Miguel Alvarez

Original Poster:

5,195 posts

201 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Guam said:
Miguel Alvarez said:
Well when the topic came up on the radio this morning someone I forget their name now suggested that teachers shouldn't be liable for blame as they don't have the business/commercial experience to make these decisions. I'm sure it wasn't meant as the comical quote it was but it certainly made me laugh.
Yeah, except they are at the front of the line at Party conferences and such, pretending they know better than we filthy capitalists on how to run businesses!
Exactly.

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Miguel Alvarez said:
Well when the topic came up on the radio this morning someone I forget their name now suggested that teachers shouldn't be liable for blame as they don't have the business/commercial experience to make these decisions. I'm sure it wasn't meant as the comical quote it was but it certainly made me laugh.
TBH I quite agree.

There may be exceptions to the rule, but by and large I would not want a teacher to be in control of a large budget organisation. Making decisions on contracts, purchases and infrastructure is something a teacher does not have experience of.

RicksAlfas

14,607 posts

275 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
But surely she must have twigged that £4000 a laptop is going a bit?
confused

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
RicksAlfas said:
But surely she must have twigged that £4000 a laptop is going a bit?
confused
Not if they have no knowledge of contracts. There are ways to hide it so they just read the ONLY £30 a month.

When in reality there will be penalty clauses and interest galore.


Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
elster said:
Miguel Alvarez said:
Well when the topic came up on the radio this morning someone I forget their name now suggested that teachers shouldn't be liable for blame as they don't have the business/commercial experience to make these decisions. I'm sure it wasn't meant as the comical quote it was but it certainly made me laugh.
TBH I quite agree.

There may be exceptions to the rule, but by and large I would not want a teacher to be in control of a large budget organisation. Making decisions on contracts, purchases and infrastructure is something a teacher does not have experience of.
I've sold technology to schools over the years and they are finally realising they don't know the first thing about business and many now are employing SBMs (School Business Managers) who are allegedly commercially aware people to deal with this sort of thing.

Some of the deals I've seen schools lumped with over the years are horrific and you think to yourself even if you're not particularly commercially aware, you just wouldn't sing up to that. Then it begins to dawn on you that brown paper bags full of money are rife and it starts to make more sense sadly.

Miguel Alvarez

Original Poster:

5,195 posts

201 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Guam said:
elster said:
Not if they have no knowledge of contracts. There are ways to hide it so they just read the ONLY £30 a month.

When in reality there will be penalty clauses and interest galore.
Perhaps they could do what a businessman would do? You know, run a contract you dont understand, past a solicitor <or accountant> BEFORE signing the damned thing?
Or failing that read the thing. I'll put money on it most of them just signed it without giving it more than a cursory glance.



Miguel Alvarez

Original Poster:

5,195 posts

201 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
elster said:
Miguel Alvarez said:
Well when the topic came up on the radio this morning someone I forget their name now suggested that teachers shouldn't be liable for blame as they don't have the business/commercial experience to make these decisions. I'm sure it wasn't meant as the comical quote it was but it certainly made me laugh.
TBH I quite agree.

There may be exceptions to the rule, but by and large I would not want a teacher to be in control of a large budget organisation. Making decisions on contracts, purchases and infrastructure is something a teacher does not have experience of.
I've sold technology to schools over the years and they are finally realising they don't know the first thing about business and many now are employing SBMs (School Business Managers) who are allegedly commercially aware people to deal with this sort of thing.

Some of the deals I've seen schools lumped with over the years are horrific and you think to yourself even if you're not particularly commercially aware, you just wouldn't sing up to that. Then it begins to dawn on you that brown paper bags full of money are rife and it starts to make more sense sadly.
I'm not quite at the sad stage just yet. I see it more as what do you expect when you fill these rolls with people who have no real world experience. I realise that sounds harsh and some of these people will have been products of a changing system over the years where they are given/lumbered with more responsibility but something is clearly wrong here and employing for a specific role to now deal with this seems to be masking the underlying problem.



ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Miguel Alvarez said:
I'm not quite at the sad stage just yet. I see it more as what do you expect when you fill these rolls with people who have no real world experience. I realise that sounds harsh and some of these people will have been products of a changing system over the years where they are given/lumbered with more responsibility but something is clearly wrong here and employing for a specific role to now deal with this seems to be masking the underlying problem.
Depends if you think the underlying problem is people doing roles they aren't good at (teachers trying to run schools as a business) or people being unable to do a role (people failing to analyse contracts for example).

You could train headteachers in business skills or you could let headteachers be head of the teaching staff (as their role title would suggest and as fits their likely experience) and employ someone with business skills to run the school finances (a decent accountant should have the skills required).

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Miguel Alvarez said:
Caulkhead said:
elster said:
Miguel Alvarez said:
Well when the topic came up on the radio this morning someone I forget their name now suggested that teachers shouldn't be liable for blame as they don't have the business/commercial experience to make these decisions. I'm sure it wasn't meant as the comical quote it was but it certainly made me laugh.
TBH I quite agree.

There may be exceptions to the rule, but by and large I would not want a teacher to be in control of a large budget organisation. Making decisions on contracts, purchases and infrastructure is something a teacher does not have experience of.
I've sold technology to schools over the years and they are finally realising they don't know the first thing about business and many now are employing SBMs (School Business Managers) who are allegedly commercially aware people to deal with this sort of thing.

Some of the deals I've seen schools lumped with over the years are horrific and you think to yourself even if you're not particularly commercially aware, you just wouldn't sing up to that. Then it begins to dawn on you that brown paper bags full of money are rife and it starts to make more sense sadly.
I'm not quite at the sad stage just yet. I see it more as what do you expect when you fill these rolls with people who have no real world experience. I realise that sounds harsh and some of these people will have been products of a changing system over the years where they are given/lumbered with more responsibility but something is clearly wrong here and employing for a specific role to now deal with this seems to be masking the underlying problem.
I disagree. Schools employing SBM's makes sense - they're teachers, not business people. It's the same reason lawyers and doctors employ practice managers. The real issue is the corruption in school and council that excludes certain suppliers and encourages the use of the more 'generous' suppliers, irrespective of how expensive their offerings are.

nosubstitute

750 posts

213 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Many teachers have had previous careers in business and are quite capable of managing budgets. There are quite a few assumptions made about teachers on Pistonheads.

nosubstitute

750 posts

213 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
My reply was in response to some posters who made comments which imply teachers have no business experience which is simply not the case.

Some don't but some do.