Benefit Vouchers?
Author
Discussion

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Should benefit claimants be prevented from spending the money given to them by the state on alcohol, gambling, cigarettes and other "vices"?

A poll commissioned by think tank Demos suggests most people would support such a move.

Full article: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19792066

Discuss

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
vouchers.. yes, i support this

( currently unemployed )

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
I can see some of the logic but surely what matters is the bottom line. If setting up such a system sees us pay out more than we currently do then it won't get us very far.

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
But surely the tax revenue on booze and cigs is rather more than that on fresh fruit and veg?...

Pixelpeep

9,050 posts

173 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
I can see some of the logic but surely what matters is the bottom line. If setting up such a system sees us pay out more than we currently do then it won't get us very far.
in theory if people can't buy 'treats' it won't be as comfortable to live on benefits so you might have more incentive to return to work.

- also currently unemployed.

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Personally I think if people actually do buy beer rather than clothes when they need clothes then no revamped welfare system will help these people.

Happy82

15,078 posts

200 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
I can see some of the logic but surely what matters is the bottom line. If setting up such a system sees us pay out more than we currently do then it won't get us very far.
But if people cannot spend the money on fags and booze they might think twice about a life living on welfare. I think this is about social change as much as trying to save money.



KrazyIvan

4,341 posts

206 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
I can see some of the logic but surely what matters is the bottom line. If setting up such a system sees us pay out more than we currently do then it won't get us very far.
I don't think that's the point. If you can no longer use your free money to buy the frivolous stuff (sky/fags/booze/lottery)the rest of us have to work to buy, then it may encourage you to find another source of income.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
What about the creation of a black market in vouchers - somebody who wants to purchase fags will sell their £10 food voucher for six pounds in cash, or buy a tenner's worth of food for someone else in exchange for the cash.

How do small retailers handle the vouchers? Will they be required to install an extra EFT terminal?

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Pixelpeep said:
in theory if people can't buy 'treats' it won't be as comfortable to live on benefits so you might have more incentive to return to work.

- also currently unemployed.
I question how comfortable it actually is to live on benefits. For sure if you completely give up, have 7 children and claim absolutely everything then you'll probably be fine but the vast majority of unemployed people are not on the front page of The Sun. I'm not sure 'comfortable' is the right word.

We can easily get back into an argument about there not being enough jobs anyway with this, you can't return to work which isn't there irrespective of how incentivised you are. Also is the type of person who'd happily live on benefits so long as he had beer really the type of person anybody would want to employ anyway?

Pixelpeep

9,050 posts

173 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
i'm sure it will be blocked by some ooman rights crap saying that it degrades them at the checkout.

same rubbish why they don't put everybody that does community service in fluorescent orange overalls for the world to see

Oakey

27,984 posts

247 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
joewilliams said:
What about the creation of a black market in vouchers - somebody who wants to purchase fags will sell their £10 food voucher for six pounds in cash, or buy a tenner's worth of food for someone else in exchange for the cash.

How do small retailers handle the vouchers? Will they be required to install an extra EFT terminal?
Why vouchers? Why not a credit card with a photo of the claimants face on that cannot be used to buy fags, alcohol, scratch cards?

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
KrazyIvan said:
... it may encourage you to find another source of income.
Such as crime perhaps?

Pixelpeep

9,050 posts

173 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Oakey said:
fags, alcohol, scratch cards?
Wanna finish that stereotype with Jeremy Kyle and a trip to the bookies ?

smile

Oakey

27,984 posts

247 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
What is your job Martin? Do you get paid to post on here? 300 posts a month is a lot in anybodys book

Oakey

27,984 posts

247 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Pixelpeep said:
Wanna finish that stereotype with Jeremy Kyle and a trip to the bookies ?

smile
What are you on about? That is exactly what the article in the OP is about;

"Should benefit claimants be prevented from spending the money given to them by the state on alcohol, gambling, cigarettes and other "vices"?"

Pixelpeep

9,050 posts

173 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Oakey said:
What is your job Martin? Do you get paid to post on here? 300 posts a month is a lot in anybodys book
Woah.... INCOMING!!!!

martin84

Original Poster:

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
I have no problem with them buying lottery tickets. If they win £4million they won't need our help anymore. And they're taxed anyway. So are cigarettes (heavily) and alcohol.

ralphrj

4,135 posts

222 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Oakey said:
Why vouchers? Why not a credit card with a photo of the claimants face on that cannot be used to buy fags, alcohol, scratch cards?
The US already has something similar. The SNAP system replaced food stamps and is a payment card that is pre-loaded with your benefit. You use it to pay the same way as a chip and pin credit/debit card and it can only be used to buy authorised food items.

However, I suspect that this doesn't end the problems of welfare being spent on alcohol, tobacco etc but just shifts it elsewhere (selling food purchased with the card to buy booze).

Pixelpeep

9,050 posts

173 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Oakey said:
Pixelpeep said:
Wanna finish that stereotype with Jeremy Kyle and a trip to the bookies ?

smile
What are you on about? That is exactly what the article in the OP is about;

"Should benefit claimants be prevented from spending the money given to them by the state on alcohol, gambling, cigarettes and other "vices"?"
what are you on about? and why are you repeating the topic in your post.. thats not very helpful is it? tongue out