Ed Milliband conference speech
Discussion
Just watched the conference speech from the comfort of my armchair, if, like I did, you think milliband is a dead duck in the water as leader of the Labour Party, well this speech has cemented his leadership credentials IMHO. Lack of substance? of course, with another two conferences before the next G.E. he has plenty of time to provide that. Certainly his presentation and style was quite brilliant, he spoke for over one hour, no notes at all covering all the bases expected at conference from a leader. I don't know where he has been receiving his presentation skills from but it is definitely working for him.
Getting back to the substance elements of exactly what Labour will be including in a manifesto, maybe next year we will know more. He did announce some aspirations of course, but we all have them. Repeal the NHS reforms, Companies bidding for public service work must be employing apprentices, force banks by Law to split retail and 'casino' elements, if no progress made by next G.E. Nothing on growth plan ideas as yet.
Getting back to the substance elements of exactly what Labour will be including in a manifesto, maybe next year we will know more. He did announce some aspirations of course, but we all have them. Repeal the NHS reforms, Companies bidding for public service work must be employing apprentices, force banks by Law to split retail and 'casino' elements, if no progress made by next G.E. Nothing on growth plan ideas as yet.
Ed Miliband seems to be obsessed with the fact David Cameron went to Eton. Ed is trying to paint himself as a 'normal person' and yes he went to a Comprehensive but a very nice one in a wealthy part of North London. He went to Corpus Christi, Oxford and the LSE.
He is not Harold Wilson ffs - and even he went to Oxford, despite what the pipe and Yorkshire accent would have you believe.
He is not Harold Wilson ffs - and even he went to Oxford, despite what the pipe and Yorkshire accent would have you believe.
I love how the Labia spinners have been using the phrase "Ed is doing..." for a whole lot of nothing all day.
No he's not doing anything. He's aspiring. He's hoping. He's wishing.
One made me laugh particularly... "Ed is creating one million new jobs...". IMO he's a bit crap, by the same measure, I've created 2 million before breakfast.
No he's not doing anything. He's aspiring. He's hoping. He's wishing.
One made me laugh particularly... "Ed is creating one million new jobs...". IMO he's a bit crap, by the same measure, I've created 2 million before breakfast.
martin84 said:
How was 'Ed - The Movie' then?
Still trying to make out he's just a poor boy from a poor family?
Indeed, of course he uses the 'same as most of you upbringing' and appealed to the 50% of young people abandoned in the education system,because they are vocational rather than academic. How this may be addressed blah blah blah. By standards of politicians today, he did very well in conference and cameras. Reminded me of the performance Clegg produced during the televised three leader questions debate just prior to last G.E. Also will be interesting to hear the views of the Conservatives this evening regarding todays Labour conference. Still trying to make out he's just a poor boy from a poor family?
IainT said:
I love how the Labia spinners have been using the phrase "Ed is doing..." for a whole lot of nothing all day.
No he's not doing anything. He's aspiring. He's hoping. He's wishing.
One made me laugh particularly... "Ed is creating one million new jobs...". IMO he's a bit crap, by the same measure, I've created 2 million before breakfast.
The trouble is, I think that many of the electorate can't tell the difference between an opposition announcement on what they might do, an announcement by the government on what they might do, and an actual policy which has been approved by parliament.No he's not doing anything. He's aspiring. He's hoping. He's wishing.
One made me laugh particularly... "Ed is creating one million new jobs...". IMO he's a bit crap, by the same measure, I've created 2 million before breakfast.
The media doesn't help here either in the way they present things.
Eric Mc said:
I don't think anyone has anything to fear from Milliband. he will be as effective a Labour Party leader as Ian Duncan-Smith was as Conservative Party leader.
But that is not the point, if he is perceived 'to care' and 'be one of the peoples people' he will win the next G.E. Cameron has blown it with to many sectors of the working society to have a hope of re-election. The last Budget sealed their fate.crankedup said:
Just watched the conference speech from the comfort of my armchair, if, like I did, you think milliband is a dead duck in the water as leader of the Labour Party, well this speech has cemented his leadership credentials IMHO. Lack of substance? of course, with another two conferences before the next G.E. he has plenty of time to provide that. Certainly his presentation and style was quite brilliant, he spoke for over one hour, no notes at all covering all the bases expected at conference from a leader. I don't know where he has been receiving his presentation skills from but it is definitely working for him.
Getting back to the substance elements of exactly what Labour will be including in a manifesto, maybe next year we will know more. He did announce some aspirations of course, but we all have them. Repeal the NHS reforms, Companies bidding for public service work must be employing apprentices, force banks by Law to split retail and 'casino' elements, if no progress made by next G.E. Nothing on growth plan ideas as yet.
Why would they repeal NHS reforms? they were labours idea. and in their 2010 manifesto.Getting back to the substance elements of exactly what Labour will be including in a manifesto, maybe next year we will know more. He did announce some aspirations of course, but we all have them. Repeal the NHS reforms, Companies bidding for public service work must be employing apprentices, force banks by Law to split retail and 'casino' elements, if no progress made by next G.E. Nothing on growth plan ideas as yet.
The Black Flash said:
IainT said:
I love how the Labia spinners have been using the phrase "Ed is doing..." for a whole lot of nothing all day.
No he's not doing anything. He's aspiring. He's hoping. He's wishing.
One made me laugh particularly... "Ed is creating one million new jobs...". IMO he's a bit crap, by the same measure, I've created 2 million before breakfast.
The trouble is, I think that many of the electorate can't tell the difference between an opposition announcement on what they might do, an announcement by the government on what they might do, and an actual policy which has been approved by parliament.No he's not doing anything. He's aspiring. He's hoping. He's wishing.
One made me laugh particularly... "Ed is creating one million new jobs...". IMO he's a bit crap, by the same measure, I've created 2 million before breakfast.
The media doesn't help here either in the way they present things.
Do you think people vote for a particular party purely because they want a particular PM?
This isn't the US you know. We don't vote for PMs or Presidents.
And if people swallow this "I'm an ordinary chap from an ordinary background" junk, then they deserve Labour and Milliband.
And why should a person's economic background dictate their ability to lead the country or be an effective PM.
This isn't the US you know. We don't vote for PMs or Presidents.
And if people swallow this "I'm an ordinary chap from an ordinary background" junk, then they deserve Labour and Milliband.
And why should a person's economic background dictate their ability to lead the country or be an effective PM.
NoNeed said:
crankedup said:
Just watched the conference speech from the comfort of my armchair, if, like I did, you think milliband is a dead duck in the water as leader of the Labour Party, well this speech has cemented his leadership credentials IMHO. Lack of substance? of course, with another two conferences before the next G.E. he has plenty of time to provide that. Certainly his presentation and style was quite brilliant, he spoke for over one hour, no notes at all covering all the bases expected at conference from a leader. I don't know where he has been receiving his presentation skills from but it is definitely working for him.
Getting back to the substance elements of exactly what Labour will be including in a manifesto, maybe next year we will know more. He did announce some aspirations of course, but we all have them. Repeal the NHS reforms, Companies bidding for public service work must be employing apprentices, force banks by Law to split retail and 'casino' elements, if no progress made by next G.E. Nothing on growth plan ideas as yet.
Why would they repeal NHS reforms? they were labours idea. and in their 2010 manifesto.Getting back to the substance elements of exactly what Labour will be including in a manifesto, maybe next year we will know more. He did announce some aspirations of course, but we all have them. Repeal the NHS reforms, Companies bidding for public service work must be employing apprentices, force banks by Law to split retail and 'casino' elements, if no progress made by next G.E. Nothing on growth plan ideas as yet.
Eric Mc said:
Do you think people vote for a particular party purely because they want a particular PM?
This isn't the US you know. We don't vote for PMs or Presidents.
And if people swallow this "I'm an ordinary chap from an ordinary background" junk, then they deserve Labour and Milliband.
And why should a person's economic background dictate their ability to lead the country or be an effective PM.
Not at all, although some voters will vote simply because they like the Leader of a political party I suppose. No its not the U.S, but it is following those footsteps of presentation and meet the people razz a matazz. It is of course vital that the Leaders have these skill sets of effective presentation to a mass audience. I think you may agree with television/radio and all the other instant media to public mechanisms.This isn't the US you know. We don't vote for PMs or Presidents.
And if people swallow this "I'm an ordinary chap from an ordinary background" junk, then they deserve Labour and Milliband.
And why should a person's economic background dictate their ability to lead the country or be an effective PM.
The people so often derided in here do have the right to a vote, loads of voters will just vote against 'the last lot' in Government.
Eric Mc said:
Do you think people vote for a particular party purely because they want a particular PM?
This isn't the US you know. We don't vote for PMs or Presidents.
Technically you're right but the fact is people vote for the leader more and more these days. Even more so now with the addition of US-style television debates and the London Mayor elections which are US-style personality contests themselves. When most voters get their ballot paper they don't know the name of their local MP candidates, they look down the list at the party and put a cross in the box and it's the leader who persuades them to do (or not do) that.This isn't the US you know. We don't vote for PMs or Presidents.
Red Ed said:
And here is the genius of one nation: it doesn’t just tell us the country we can be, it tells us how we must rebuild. We won the War because we were one nation, we built the peace because Labour governments and Conservative governments understood we needed to be one nation.
Fantastic, one nation with everyone paying 20% income tax. No hammering wealth creators and job providers.Red Ed said:
We must be the party of the private sector just as much as the party of the public sector. As much the party of the small business struggling against the odds ads the home help struggling against the cuts. We must be the party of south just as much as the party of the north. We must be the party as much as the squeezed middle as those in poverty. There is no future for this party as the party of one sectional interest of our country.
Brilliant, no more expansion of the public sector at the expense of hardworking class people in the private sector and no more redistribution of wealth from the SE where it's created, to the north with its Labour voting tribal enclaves.Red Ed said:
You can’t be a one nation prime minister if your chief whip insults the great police officers of our country by calling them plebs
As it happens, you can. Apart from that, we can only hope that somewhere else in his spinfest he mentioned something about not being a short-term opportunist focusing on headlines rather than the economy.Red Ed said:
Have you ever seen a more incompetent...
Stop right there. Yes, New Labour 1997 - 2010 and by a wide margin.The man is deluded, maybe even worse than previously thought.
Guido said:
Little policy...
As expected. Full-on rhetoric, policy lite.
The Sweet said:
He hasn't got a clue what to do
Looking back Thatcher was considered unelectable (maybe it was because of her gender) and Major was no media darling, so perhaps we over estimate the whole personality thing when it comes to GE's? From what I've glimpsed this afternoon, he appears to have done ok but you have to laugh at how all party leaders attempt to portray themselves as 'ordinairy' people, when they are anything but.
martin84 said:
Eric Mc said:
Do you think people vote for a particular party purely because they want a particular PM?
This isn't the US you know. We don't vote for PMs or Presidents.
Technically you're right but the fact is people vote for the leader more and more these days. Even more so now with the addition of US-style television debates and the London Mayor elections which are US-style personality contests themselves. When most voters get their ballot paper they don't know the name of their local MP candidates, they look down the list at the party and put a cross in the box and it's the leader who persuades them to do (or not do) that.This isn't the US you know. We don't vote for PMs or Presidents.
And having the "common touch" is nothing to do with background. It's to do with the individual's natural ability to sense the national mood. I would suggest that Mrs Thatcher and Tony Blair possessed this ability - as does Boris Johnson.
All come from wildly differing backgrounds.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



