Stop thief!
Author
Discussion

HOGEPH

Original Poster:

5,249 posts

217 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19879314

Householders who overreact when confronted by burglars are to get more protection in law, Justice Secretary Chris Grayling will say.

"Grossly disproportionate" force will still be against the law, but the bar will be set higher than the current "proportionate" force test.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
This meeja-friendly announcement is light on detail. What is the revised test to be, I wonder. Somewhere between proportionate and grossly disproportionate, but how do you characterise that?

The extant subjective self defence test has recently been reiterated by the Lord Chief Justice, and it works pretty well in practice. Several recent cases in which homeowners have used force against intruders have resulted in no action against the homeowners, and there is no instance that I know of in which a homeowner has been convicted after acting in legitimate self defence (as opposed to revenge or punishment), although it is right to say that in the most recent case the homeowners were held for too long before being cleared.

HOGEPH

Original Poster:

5,249 posts

217 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
I've just re read that first line. "Householders who overreact when confronted by burglars ."


The fker is in MY house!

southendpier

6,244 posts

260 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
CMD gave an example of not being able to stab an unconcious burglar.

So i assume you can still kick him.

Is there little else to discuss that might be of greater interest to the nation?

Rollin

6,339 posts

276 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
We're going to need sample photos to see how much damage can be done to burglars. Hit with rolling pin..Compare with photo..repeat.

With regards to using a knife, maybe have Chris Grayling recreate the pig scene in Gangs of New York.
"That's a conviction", "That's a conviction"
I think Bill the Butcher's top hat would suit him.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
What is disproportionate? If someone is prepared to break in to an occupied house to deprive me of my possessions then I'm going to assume they are prepared to stop at nothing to carry out their objective. Deadly force is entirely reasonable.

Anti tank weapons or a nuclear strike might cut it, but I don't see many stories about homeowners employing such methods.

Land mines are a grey area.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Deadly Kung Fu Grip? Harsh and cutting remarks? Take off and nuke site from orbit? Tricky to get the balance right.

robmlufc

5,229 posts

217 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
Take off and nuke site from orbit?
Its the only way to be sure.

XB70

2,494 posts

227 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Reasoned and considered debate with the intruder is the only option.



Discuss it, challenge his ideas, convince him otherwise.

(for anyone that has seen The Last Supper)


Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
It is hardly a massive change. Currently you can get away with anything below grossly disproportionate and, as has been shown, get away with grossly disproportionate response.


The Wookie

14,209 posts

259 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
XB70 said:
Reasoned and considered debate with the intruder is the only option.



Discuss it, challenge his ideas, convince him otherwise.

(for anyone that has seen The Last Supper)
The time for talking is over. Now call it extreme if you like, but I propose we hit them hard, and we hit them fast, with a major, and I mean major, leaflet campaign.


AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
It is hardly a massive change. Currently you can get away with anything below grossly disproportionate and, as has been shown, get away with grossly disproportionate response.
What is the definition of "grossly disproportionate"?

hedgefinder

3,418 posts

201 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
What is the definition of "grossly disproportionate"?
removing their balls with a rusty wall paper scraper..

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
hedgefinder said:
AJS- said:
What is the definition of "grossly disproportionate"?
removing their balls with a rusty wall paper scraper..
I can see if you capture and torture them it's beyond reason, but what I mean is if I catch someone half way through my window in the small hours then I'm likely to swing something heavy at their head, and it could end up killing them. Is that disproportionate?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
I can see the problems here.

There was once a time when I genuinely believed that once a criminal breaks and enters your home, to steal your things and/or threaten you, they should lose all their rights as soon as they climb through that window or whatever.

Simple as that. Once they enter, you can legally beat/stab them to within a whisker of death and then phone the police to come and collect what was left of them. End of. They came into your home to steal, why should they have rights?

But now I can see the issues more clearly, I actually think the law as it stands is pretty reasonable.

How much further do we go? Will we end up with a thief being duck taped to a kitchen chair while an angry home owner goes Reservoir Dogs on them once they are clearly no longer a threat?

As I understand it, you can use any vicious household item you like to remove the threat from your home of you are in fear of your safety, which of course you are. Golf club, crow bar, axe...

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
How about cable tying their testicles to the stair banisters?

superkartracer

8,959 posts

253 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
We have two 110kg Great Danes that people assume are lovely soft cuddly dogs ( which they are with us ) , in-fact pissed off they become very powerful animals capable of talking down huge wild boar let along some robbing scumbag, i'm hoping the site of them would be enough.

Edited by superkartracer on Tuesday 9th October 09:45

Manks

28,176 posts

253 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
superkartracer said:
We have two 110kg Great Danes that people assume are lovely soft cuddly dogs ( which they are with us ) , in-fact pissed off they become very powerful animals capable of talking down huge wild boar let along some robbing scumbag, i'm hoping the site of them would be enough.

Edited by superkartracer on Tuesday 9th October 09:45
You get many wild boar in Warwickshire?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
How about cable tying their testicles to the stair banisters?
Hmmm... I'll be honest, I'm not wild about having to handle the testicles of some sweaty criminal.

I suppose you could retrieve your largest carving knife and suggest politely that they do it themselves? smile



Mr E

23,108 posts

290 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
After we were burgled, I asked the officer who came to take details if he thought the hallway was the best place to display my bear trap collection (which I keep purely for sentimental reasons) after dark.

He declined to comment.