7 Royal Marines arrested for 'murder'
7 Royal Marines arrested for 'murder'
Author
Discussion

Norfolkit

Original Poster:

2,394 posts

221 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
The quotation marks are mine
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19918398

So what are they supposed to do with (as the MOD confirms) insurgents, read them bedtime stories.
Just as well the rules of engagement were a bit more flexible in 1939.


FiF

49,059 posts

282 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
As much of a wtf moment as this news is, I make no apologies for the quote that sprang to mind.

Lock Stock said:
Eddie: They're armed.
Soap: What was that? Armed? What do you mean armed? Armed with what?
Eddie: Err, bad breath, colourful language, feather duster... what do you think they're gonna be armed with? Guns, you tit!
Back on topic but wtf.


Citizen09

882 posts

202 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
Norfolkit said:
The quotation marks are mine
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-19918398

So what are they supposed to do with (as the MOD confirms) insurgents, read them bedtime stories.
Numerous media outlets are reporting that somebody was shot while possibly unarmed/having been disarmed.

MadMullah

5,299 posts

224 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
Citizen09 said:
Numerous media outlets are reporting that somebody was shot while possibly unarmed/having been disarmed.
thats what i read it as too

that after a possible firefight and possible surrender someone was killed/executed

petemurphy

10,974 posts

214 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
not sure how any soldier can be charged with murder in a war zone.

bitchstewie

68,630 posts

241 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
petemurphy said:
not sure how any soldier can be charged with murder in a war zone.
I can see how it can happen. I'd also like to put the people who decide whether to charge them in a battlefield situation where they may be deprived of sleep for several days with people trying to shoot them and blow them up at every opportunity and see how they handle it - it's very easy to say "You have to be professional" I sure as hell don't know how I would deal with it.

I guess it's all speculation until the details come out though.

XCP

17,764 posts

259 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
How is this different from shooting prisoners in WW2 or WW1 ?
Particularly if they weren't in uniform.

JensenA

5,671 posts

261 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
XCP said:
How is this different from shooting prisoners in WW2 or WW1 ?
Particularly if they weren't in uniform.
Explain exactly what you mean by this please.

StottyZr

6,860 posts

194 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
It seems British soliders can be held accountable but Americans can't.

If they executed an unarmed person at a checkpoint they should be held accountable.

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all

Why do we insist on making our soldiers fight by Queensbury rules when we're dealing with murderous people who obey no rules at all?

Utterly ridiculous. We're at WAR for God's sake.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
Soovy said:
Why do we insist on making our soldiers fight by Queensbury rules when we're dealing with murderous people who obey no rules at all?

Utterly ridiculous. We're at WAR for God's sake.
No we aren't.

We haven't been at war since WW2.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaration_of_war_by...

Strange that the last country the UK declared war on was Thailand. That would be a killer pub quiz question. Also seems odd that War was declared on Finland.

Edited by Fittster on Friday 12th October 10:20

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Soovy said:
Why do we insist on making our soldiers fight by Queensbury rules when we're dealing with murderous people who obey no rules at all?

Utterly ridiculous. We're at WAR for God's sake.
No we aren't.

We haven't been at war since WW2.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaration_of_war_by...
A fair point well made, but I should imagine that when under fire from the Taliban or feeling an IED go off under your Land Rover it probably feels much the same.

XCP

17,764 posts

259 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
JensenA said:
Explain exactly what you mean by this please.
Some prisoners were shot by both sides in WWI and WW2. The chances of this happening were higher if the prisoner was not in uniform or was disguised.

Frankly if people in civilian clothes are attacking our troops I see very little difference with applying the same standards.

onyx39

11,349 posts

181 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
How would things stand with the SAS for example.
I realise that pretty much all I have seen on this has been semi fictional accounts, but how do they stand legally when they just "open up" and kill everyone in the room, they don't ask people nicely to put down their weapons first do they?

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
XCP said:
JensenA said:
Explain exactly what you mean by this please.
Some prisoners were shot by both sides in WWI and WW2. The chances of this happening were higher if the prisoner was not in uniform or was disguised.

Frankly if people in civilian clothes are attacking our troops I see very little difference with applying the same standards.
So morally it's OK for us to operate with the same standards as the enemy?

As long as no one was taking picture Abu Ghraib style I doubt anything will happen.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
onyx39 said:
How would things stand with the SAS for example.
I realise that pretty much all I have seen on this has been semi fictional accounts, but how do they stand legally when they just "open up" and kill everyone in the room, they don't ask people nicely to put down their weapons first do they?
I would imagine it somewhat depends on whose in the room.

What I find slightly odd is that the Yanks are happy to target their own citizens with drones.

XCP

17,764 posts

259 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
[quote=Fittster]

So morally it's OK for us to operate with the same standards as the enemy?

We shot German spies. They shot ours.



anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
Just been chatting to a friend at work who did 20 years in the armed forces, about this and he thinks it's a good thing people have been arrested.

Obviously we don't know the details, but it will probably be something along the lines of they purposely shot 'a very bad guy' who was unarmed or who had surrendered.

Or they may have even been a bit of torture/interrogation, eg "tell us where your mates are hiding... No? Ok then!" BANG!

The reason said friend says that it's a good thing is because of the whole 'hearts and minds' ethos of the British Forces. You cannot win a war without also winning the hearts and minds of the country you are fighting in/with and things like this put the whole ethos in jeopardy.

We need to show the world that we take our role as a responsible and 'caring' army seriously.

I know it sounds ridiculous, but the above came from someone who has been there and done it for 20 years.


Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
petemurphy said:
not sure how any soldier can be charged with murder in a war zone.
Google Mai Lai.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
Justayellowbadge said:
petemurphy said:
not sure how any soldier can be charged with murder in a war zone.
Google Mai Lai.
Worth watching four hours in Mai Lai if you haven't seen it. Some seriously tortured souls in that documentary.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYzb9DH7YAE