So you want to leave the EU.... Why?
Poll: So you want to leave the EU.... Why?
Total Members Polled: 168
Discussion
There are lots of threads for people to rant about the EU itself, so hopefully people can keep the rants to those. 
What I was hoping to understand here was more why people want to leave. Personally, I look at the size of the US, China and possibly in the future India and I think I'd rather be part of a European bloc than a smallish individual nation. On the other hand, though, the EU as it currently exists is clearly a complete clusterf
k.
I wouldn't mind at all if we had a completely Federal Europe with a European government, military, tax system, currency, benefits system and so on, just so long as it was properly democratically elected and run.
However, when I look at the current political landscape, no party seems to be pushing for the "fix the EU" option. We have strongly pro-EU-as-is parties and strongly anti-EU-altogether parties.
So, the question in the poll really boils down to why the supporters of those anti-EU parties support them.
Is it out of Patriotism? Thinking "I just don't want my country to be governed in any way from elsewhere", in which case there would presumably be no support for an alternative European bloc, no matter how democratic and efficient, unless that system was governed from the UK?
Or is it out of pragmatism? Thinking "it's f
ked, so what's the point". Not minding it being changed into something that works, but just not believing it's ever going to happen. If it's this one, then why isn't there a political voice behind this line of thinking that I could vote for?
Or is it something completely different?

What I was hoping to understand here was more why people want to leave. Personally, I look at the size of the US, China and possibly in the future India and I think I'd rather be part of a European bloc than a smallish individual nation. On the other hand, though, the EU as it currently exists is clearly a complete clusterf
k.I wouldn't mind at all if we had a completely Federal Europe with a European government, military, tax system, currency, benefits system and so on, just so long as it was properly democratically elected and run.
However, when I look at the current political landscape, no party seems to be pushing for the "fix the EU" option. We have strongly pro-EU-as-is parties and strongly anti-EU-altogether parties.
So, the question in the poll really boils down to why the supporters of those anti-EU parties support them.
Is it out of Patriotism? Thinking "I just don't want my country to be governed in any way from elsewhere", in which case there would presumably be no support for an alternative European bloc, no matter how democratic and efficient, unless that system was governed from the UK?
Or is it out of pragmatism? Thinking "it's f
ked, so what's the point". Not minding it being changed into something that works, but just not believing it's ever going to happen. If it's this one, then why isn't there a political voice behind this line of thinking that I could vote for?Or is it something completely different?
Your question asks specifically about the EU. That's not f&*cked, that's proceeding nicely apace. Fiscal union - now that's broken,just not imploded yet. The EEC seems like a nice way of proceeding - free trade, lots of enlightened self-interest about not invading trade partners.
I really can't see the point of being on a path to political union when the last twenty years have shown quite effectively that an unelected body of public sector parasites who refuse to show any fiscal competence cannot manage their way out of a paper bag.
I really can't see the point of being on a path to political union when the last twenty years have shown quite effectively that an unelected body of public sector parasites who refuse to show any fiscal competence cannot manage their way out of a paper bag.
Kermit power said:
Or is it out of pragmatism? Thinking "it's f
ked, so what's the point". Not minding it being changed into something that works, but just not believing it's ever going to happen. If it's this one, then why isn't there a political voice behind this line of thinking that I could vote for?
For me, this.
ked, so what's the point". Not minding it being changed into something that works, but just not believing it's ever going to happen. If it's this one, then why isn't there a political voice behind this line of thinking that I could vote for?I have no objection in principle to a group of nations gathering together to further their collective interests on the world stage. A 'Common Market' approach, I see the sense in that.
The EU is not what I have in mind when I think of that however. It's also evolving away from a collective of nations and into a federal union, something I don't believe will work - European cultures are far too wide and varied for them to be governed effectively from the centre.
The only reason I can think of that there's no 'Fix the EU' political stance is the fact that individual countries can't change the EU on their own, so why run on a ticket that promotes reform of the EU when you'd need to have the agreement of a majority of your fellow member countries which you'd probably never get.
Mark Benson said:
The only reason I can think of that there's no 'Fix the EU' political stance is the fact that individual countries can't change the EU on their own, so why run on a ticket that promotes reform of the EU when you'd need to have the agreement of a majority of your fellow member countries which you'd probably never get.
Presumably you'd need similarly-minded parties to get elected in enough countries to act in partnership to make the changes they wanted. Maybe even the same party with national chapters?We can't be the only country to have people who feel this way.
Speaking as a non-UK resident (Dutch) I would actually support a European federal state if it were a) democratic and b) replaced local bodies instead of adding more cost, red tape and meddling for meddling's sake to an existing government infrastructure.
Unfortunately the EU in its current guise fails on both counts.
Unfortunately the EU in its current guise fails on both counts.

The problem for the pro EU group in the UK is that they cannot engage with the in/out debate honestly.
Look on the continent and you have the leaders of France, Germany et al, all openly talking about their shared Federal aspirations for Europe, all committing to closer monetary and fiscal union, building to political union in the form of a United States of Europe. OK, some there may be some minor detail differences, but that is what European political leaders seem to be happy to discuss. Granted, the "people" of Europe themselves might not be as enthusiastic about all this as their political elites, but even here the discourse is more about preserving cultures and regional identities than it is about issues of sovereignty in my experience.
When you look in the UK, you see politicians who flatly deny that the EU has Federal aspirations. Any questionning of this is typically met with accusations of Xenophobia or the questioner is derided as being a "little Englander/Scotlander/Welsher(?) Norner" (
) The upshot of this is that a debate on the EU is, like a debate on immigration/racism, always doomed to fail because one half won't debate the subject without smearing those who dare to challenge the liberal view and the other half gets too angry to remain coherent as a result!
The first point in all this is for everyone to get a common understanding of what it will mean to remain in the EU for the next 20+ years. Does it mean a loose trading group,operating as a single market and with some shared standards/modus operandi? Or does it mean ever closer integration and ultimatley the transfer of power to an "EU Government" under which the various national parliaments operate as little more than regional assemblies? We have to know what the big plan is before we can make a decision. That requires honesty, especially on the part of the pro EU group. And that honesty must extend to the consequences of any UK departure from the EU. The kind of apocalyptic bullcrap that the pro EU lobby spout whenever the subject arises is utterly deplorable. The fact is that the UK and Europe do need each other. They will NOT want to hurt each other. It's like the dentists chair in that regard. The only question is how the relationship is managed and I cannot see how sensible systems and solutions would not be put in place if the UK were to vote to leave.
Personally, I think the EU is a busted flush. It should have stayed as a trading bloc. I cannot see how it can be made to work in its current form, - it is simply too corrupt, unwieldy, undemocratic and slow witted. Governed by a political elite that frankly makes my skin crawl and who make the characters in our own Parliament look positively benign in comparison.
We shall have to leave. Soon please.
Look on the continent and you have the leaders of France, Germany et al, all openly talking about their shared Federal aspirations for Europe, all committing to closer monetary and fiscal union, building to political union in the form of a United States of Europe. OK, some there may be some minor detail differences, but that is what European political leaders seem to be happy to discuss. Granted, the "people" of Europe themselves might not be as enthusiastic about all this as their political elites, but even here the discourse is more about preserving cultures and regional identities than it is about issues of sovereignty in my experience.
When you look in the UK, you see politicians who flatly deny that the EU has Federal aspirations. Any questionning of this is typically met with accusations of Xenophobia or the questioner is derided as being a "little Englander/Scotlander/Welsher(?) Norner" (
) The upshot of this is that a debate on the EU is, like a debate on immigration/racism, always doomed to fail because one half won't debate the subject without smearing those who dare to challenge the liberal view and the other half gets too angry to remain coherent as a result! The first point in all this is for everyone to get a common understanding of what it will mean to remain in the EU for the next 20+ years. Does it mean a loose trading group,operating as a single market and with some shared standards/modus operandi? Or does it mean ever closer integration and ultimatley the transfer of power to an "EU Government" under which the various national parliaments operate as little more than regional assemblies? We have to know what the big plan is before we can make a decision. That requires honesty, especially on the part of the pro EU group. And that honesty must extend to the consequences of any UK departure from the EU. The kind of apocalyptic bullcrap that the pro EU lobby spout whenever the subject arises is utterly deplorable. The fact is that the UK and Europe do need each other. They will NOT want to hurt each other. It's like the dentists chair in that regard. The only question is how the relationship is managed and I cannot see how sensible systems and solutions would not be put in place if the UK were to vote to leave.
Personally, I think the EU is a busted flush. It should have stayed as a trading bloc. I cannot see how it can be made to work in its current form, - it is simply too corrupt, unwieldy, undemocratic and slow witted. Governed by a political elite that frankly makes my skin crawl and who make the characters in our own Parliament look positively benign in comparison.
We shall have to leave. Soon please.
Kermit power said:
There are lots of threads for people to rant about the EU itself, so hopefully people can keep the rants to those. 
What I was hoping to understand here was more why people want to leave. Personally, I look at the size of the US, China and possibly in the future India and I think I'd rather be part of a European bloc than a smallish individual nation. On the other hand, though, the EU as it currently exists is clearly a complete clusterf
k.
I wouldn't mind at all if we had a completely Federal Europe with a European government, military, tax system, currency, benefits system and so on, just so long as it was properly democratically elected and run.
However, when I look at the current political landscape, no party seems to be pushing for the "fix the EU" option. We have strongly pro-EU-as-is parties and strongly anti-EU-altogether parties.
So, the question in the poll really boils down to why the supporters of those anti-EU parties support them.
Is it out of Patriotism? Thinking "I just don't want my country to be governed in any way from elsewhere", in which case there would presumably be no support for an alternative European bloc, no matter how democratic and efficient, unless that system was governed from the UK?
Or is it out of pragmatism? Thinking "it's f
ked, so what's the point". Not minding it being changed into something that works, but just not believing it's ever going to happen. If it's this one, then why isn't there a political voice behind this line of thinking that I could vote for?
Or is it something completely different?
Would you rather be in the euro as well?
What I was hoping to understand here was more why people want to leave. Personally, I look at the size of the US, China and possibly in the future India and I think I'd rather be part of a European bloc than a smallish individual nation. On the other hand, though, the EU as it currently exists is clearly a complete clusterf
k.I wouldn't mind at all if we had a completely Federal Europe with a European government, military, tax system, currency, benefits system and so on, just so long as it was properly democratically elected and run.
However, when I look at the current political landscape, no party seems to be pushing for the "fix the EU" option. We have strongly pro-EU-as-is parties and strongly anti-EU-altogether parties.
So, the question in the poll really boils down to why the supporters of those anti-EU parties support them.
Is it out of Patriotism? Thinking "I just don't want my country to be governed in any way from elsewhere", in which case there would presumably be no support for an alternative European bloc, no matter how democratic and efficient, unless that system was governed from the UK?
Or is it out of pragmatism? Thinking "it's f
ked, so what's the point". Not minding it being changed into something that works, but just not believing it's ever going to happen. If it's this one, then why isn't there a political voice behind this line of thinking that I could vote for?Or is it something completely different?
For me it's a simple matter of sovereignty. If we were currently in a fully federalised EU, we would also be in the euro and unable to control our own currency and would be in the same boat as Spain having to pay huge interest rates because the markets have no confidence in their economy and have no levers to adjust it.
There are also the secondary matters of complete lack of democracy, waste and incompetence that actually make Westminster look quite good value for money. We would also have to have joined the Schengen agreement so our borders would be as secure as the weakest EU members.
900T-R said:
Speaking as a non-UK resident (Dutch) I would actually support a European federal state if it were a) democratic and b) replaced local bodies instead of adding more cost, red tape and meddling for meddling's sake to an existing government infrastructure.
Unfortunately the EU in its current guise fails on both counts.
Excellent points.Unfortunately the EU in its current guise fails on both counts.

The current, un-elected system of adding another layer of
t and bureacracyThe fiscal/monetary Euro is a dangerous hotcpotch for which, unless we get out of the EU soon, we may well end up footing more of the costs than we'd bargained for.
The EU is modeled along the old Communist style of 'government'. The political direction, policies and legislation are decided behind closed doors by unelected bureaucrats. The MEP's them simply discuss and vote on topics put before them by these unelected Bureaucrats.
The EU has a Presidents - i think it actually has 3 doesn't it? - and even a foreign minister. Now during this Eurozone crisis, are we always hearing on the news about how the EU president, and EU officials are urgently discussing how to resolve the crisis? No, all we get is the German and French presidents flying around to the crisis countries dictating to them how they should run their financial affairs.
It is a shambolic, undemocratic, expensive and corrupt organization.
The EU has a Presidents - i think it actually has 3 doesn't it? - and even a foreign minister. Now during this Eurozone crisis, are we always hearing on the news about how the EU president, and EU officials are urgently discussing how to resolve the crisis? No, all we get is the German and French presidents flying around to the crisis countries dictating to them how they should run their financial affairs.
It is a shambolic, undemocratic, expensive and corrupt organization.
Mark Benson said:
The only reason I can think of that there's no 'Fix the EU' political stance is the fact that individual countries can't change the EU on their own, so why run on a ticket that promotes reform of the EU when you'd need to have the agreement of a majority of your fellow member countries which you'd probably never get.
Or maybe because if as 900T-R suggests there were an efficient EU government of a federal state, that would remove / significantly reduce the local jobs for the boys. Thus, for example, no opportunity for Cameron et al lining the pockets of their chums and political sponsors with public money whist they have their own nose in the trough and sorting out their own pensions.Turkeys do not vote for Christmas.
Note:- insert any politician's name from any country I have just picked one at random, honest.
Digga said:
The current, un-elected system of adding another layer of bulls
t and bureacracy government is crazy and inefficient. Time and again, the EU parliament has proved itself not only able to support but also a means to create extremely well-remunerated non-jobs for non-entities.
Very true.
t and bureacracySubscribe to the newsletter from http://www.openeurope.org.uk/ to learn some very interesting things about what goes on.
I am opposed to the EU simply because Europe is just too diverse and self-determined for all countries to be governed uniformally.
It should be a collection of favourable trading conditions and nothing more.
What we've ended up with is a political body that follows on from a number of political traditions at odds with our history of democracy. From Eastern Europe, you've got entire systems used to dictatorships and Communist bureaucracy, for whom the governmental tradition revolves around decisions being made on your behalf 'for your own good' by people you didn't vote for. Those nations are unused to democracy, and if they want to cling to the vestiges of that method of decision-making, fine, but don't impose it on countries that outgrew it centuries ago.
And then you've got the 'war prevention' aspect. OK, so in the wake of WWII and the Cold War, perhaps it made sense to strengthen ties between nations who were at war with each other within living memory, but as the years have gone by that's looking more than unlikely, more like a total impossibility. The 'total control' aspect aimed at preventing war has just resulted in an all-pervading sense of inflexibility in the face of EU-wide laws.
And then you've got all the dodgy-dealing. European electronics company wants to safeguard its future income, so it lobbies the EU to make its safety systems compulsory on all new cars. As a result, you get cars being made more expensive and complicated by law rather than customer options, the whole notion of safety undermined by things like 'green' tyre ratings, so a car with a load of safety gubbins mandated by law will end up slithering off the road into a tree thanks to low-resistance fuel-saving ditchfinders also mandated by law. Customer choice narrows and life gets more difficult for the independent tradesman, but the EU company rakes it in and an unelected official gets a backhander.
The whole system is incompatible with so many systems - our Mother of Parliaments, the French 'Liberte, Egalite, Fraternite', and now the German Bundestag. These are systems that just don't need that level of governance.
No point trying to shrink your own state when the EU is so vast and unnecessarily bureaucratic and corrupt it makes the most extensive of welfare states look skimpy and cheap.
And I'm not the only one. If Labour or the Tories gave any of UKIP's policies a fair hearing, they'd rake in the votes.
It should be a collection of favourable trading conditions and nothing more.
What we've ended up with is a political body that follows on from a number of political traditions at odds with our history of democracy. From Eastern Europe, you've got entire systems used to dictatorships and Communist bureaucracy, for whom the governmental tradition revolves around decisions being made on your behalf 'for your own good' by people you didn't vote for. Those nations are unused to democracy, and if they want to cling to the vestiges of that method of decision-making, fine, but don't impose it on countries that outgrew it centuries ago.
And then you've got the 'war prevention' aspect. OK, so in the wake of WWII and the Cold War, perhaps it made sense to strengthen ties between nations who were at war with each other within living memory, but as the years have gone by that's looking more than unlikely, more like a total impossibility. The 'total control' aspect aimed at preventing war has just resulted in an all-pervading sense of inflexibility in the face of EU-wide laws.
And then you've got all the dodgy-dealing. European electronics company wants to safeguard its future income, so it lobbies the EU to make its safety systems compulsory on all new cars. As a result, you get cars being made more expensive and complicated by law rather than customer options, the whole notion of safety undermined by things like 'green' tyre ratings, so a car with a load of safety gubbins mandated by law will end up slithering off the road into a tree thanks to low-resistance fuel-saving ditchfinders also mandated by law. Customer choice narrows and life gets more difficult for the independent tradesman, but the EU company rakes it in and an unelected official gets a backhander.
The whole system is incompatible with so many systems - our Mother of Parliaments, the French 'Liberte, Egalite, Fraternite', and now the German Bundestag. These are systems that just don't need that level of governance.
No point trying to shrink your own state when the EU is so vast and unnecessarily bureaucratic and corrupt it makes the most extensive of welfare states look skimpy and cheap.
And I'm not the only one. If Labour or the Tories gave any of UKIP's policies a fair hearing, they'd rake in the votes.
Good question.
For me, I believe the idea of a democratic federal Europe falls at the first hurdle - there is no European demos with the kind of homogeneity to adequately exercise democratic control over such an entity. An entity that seeks to do so much.
We already have within the UK tensions between Scots who think they are ignored, English who think we're paying for everything, Welsh who think whatever they think, the north of England feeling left behind and so on. And that's within a 300 year old political union with a common language, where you can drive between any of the major cities in a day.
Throw into that countries as diverse as Sweden, Romania, Malta and Germany, and it just becomes impossible.
Patriotism is a loaded word in the EU discussion as it's usually dismissed as narrow minded jingoism and xenophobia. But to my mind a feeling of some sort of commonality, a shared narrative and common values between the citizens of a democracy is a necessary ingredient.
Without this ingredient politicians are all powerful, remote figures with no real restraint.
That's why small countries generally work better. And are generally happier, freer and more prosperous than big countries. The politicians are more directly accountable to the public.
If the EU was restricted to zero trade tariffs and freedom of movement I wouldn't have a problem with it. But it isn't, and never has been about simply that. It was always intended to be a country called Europe, forced together without the consent of it's people. And that is a recipe for total disaster.
For me, I believe the idea of a democratic federal Europe falls at the first hurdle - there is no European demos with the kind of homogeneity to adequately exercise democratic control over such an entity. An entity that seeks to do so much.
We already have within the UK tensions between Scots who think they are ignored, English who think we're paying for everything, Welsh who think whatever they think, the north of England feeling left behind and so on. And that's within a 300 year old political union with a common language, where you can drive between any of the major cities in a day.
Throw into that countries as diverse as Sweden, Romania, Malta and Germany, and it just becomes impossible.
Patriotism is a loaded word in the EU discussion as it's usually dismissed as narrow minded jingoism and xenophobia. But to my mind a feeling of some sort of commonality, a shared narrative and common values between the citizens of a democracy is a necessary ingredient.
Without this ingredient politicians are all powerful, remote figures with no real restraint.
That's why small countries generally work better. And are generally happier, freer and more prosperous than big countries. The politicians are more directly accountable to the public.
If the EU was restricted to zero trade tariffs and freedom of movement I wouldn't have a problem with it. But it isn't, and never has been about simply that. It was always intended to be a country called Europe, forced together without the consent of it's people. And that is a recipe for total disaster.
Hm Ive never met anyone who disagrees with free trade and friendship with our near neibours who hasen't been to a European county and had a positive view of most of it's inhabitants, but there is very little apeitite for a load of self seving unelected bureacrats making endless laws and overruling soverein goverments ,lets have free trade every country have its own goverment, simple rules for trade is all we need from the EU we have NATO and our own armys for security ...
andymadmak said:
The problem for the pro EU group in the UK is that they cannot engage with the in/out debate honestly.
spot on. how many time must we hear 'well i'd like to see how the uk economy is going to do when it looses it biggest export market' or 'you anti europeans are just xenophobic little englanders' I'd agree with many of the concerns of those above, but one example of why I think the EU will not work is that it still cannot decide which city or country it should have its headquarters in. Brussels or Strasberg.. how much time, money and energy is expended on this ridiculous waste.
Given the responses on here so far, I'm surprised there haven't been more votes for the patriotism option, as that's where I'd position the "nobody can manage our country better than us" sort of answer.
Maybe I'm just unusual in feeling that my country hasn't had it's own Parliament for the last 3 centuries, so beyond that it really doesn't bother me whether other countries are included in the federation we've already got.
Maybe I'm just unusual in feeling that my country hasn't had it's own Parliament for the last 3 centuries, so beyond that it really doesn't bother me whether other countries are included in the federation we've already got.
Kermit power said:
Given the responses on here so far, I'm surprised there haven't been more votes for the patriotism option, as that's where I'd position the "nobody can manage our country better than us" sort of answer.
then you need too read the responses again. You have missed the point completely Kermit me old froggy!Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


