Finally, decent sentencing from a judge
Finally, decent sentencing from a judge
Author
Discussion

hornetrider

Original Poster:

63,161 posts

236 months

Friday 19th October 2012
quotequote all

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Saturday 20th October 2012
quotequote all
39 previous convictions, and then he went out and violently robbed a 91 year old. I can think of a lot more "decent" sentences than 11 years, meaning he will be out in 6.

Are we really happy that this piece of st will be back out in 11 years at most?

A real case in point for my 3 strikes rule. At 39 strikes and 49 years old I can't see anything wrong with just throwing away the key.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 20th October 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
39 previous convictions, and then he went out and violently robbed a 91 year old. I can think of a lot more "decent" sentences than 11 years, meaning he will be out in 6.
more likely 4 with home curfew.

turbobloke

117,604 posts

291 months

Saturday 20th October 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
A real case in point for my 3 strikes rule. At 39 strikes and 49 years old I can't see anything wrong with just throwing away the key.
Definitely.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Saturday 20th October 2012
quotequote all
Sometimes I make these sort of posts, then I go away and think I'm being a bit over the top, or making assumptions with incomplete knowledge. This time I went away, thought about it and then I came back and had to recheck the article to make sure I had the numbers right - 49 years old with 39 convictions - this one I guess will make it 40/50 by his next birthday. That is simply staggering. He has been caught, tried and found guilty of a crime every year of his life since he was 10. Assuming this was only since he was 18, and that he has spent some time inside before then it's likely it's actually significantly more than that. He is a one man crime wave.

A few weeks ago I dug out the crime detection figures, and from memory I think around ~20% of total crime is detected. If the same applies to this guy then the total amount of crimes he has likely committed is just stupid. Clearly a habitual offender who simply can not help himself.

What on earth was he doing walking around freely? How many lives would have been improved if some judge at some point had twigged that he is not about to change his ways. Quite possibly including his own if it saved him from what sounds like an utterly wasted half century of drink, drugs, violence and crime.

nelly1

5,666 posts

262 months

Saturday 20th October 2012
quotequote all
Article said:
Banton, of Tottenham, north London, was jailed for 11 years yesterday, after pleading guilty to robbery last month. He cried in the dock as his solicitor said that he “expresses deep remorse and deep regret” for the attack, and Mrs Elmer-Laird accepted an apology from him.

Speaking after the hearing, Mrs Elmer-Laird said: “I’m pleased with the sentence: it keeps him off the street and buys the public some safety. He has got a wife and children, I can only hope he learns something from this".
I wouldn't bet on it love.


mickk

30,546 posts

273 months

Saturday 20th October 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
Sometimes I make these sort of posts, then I go away and think I'm being a bit over the top, or making assumptions with incomplete knowledge. This time I went away, thought about it and then I came back and had to recheck the article to make sure I had the numbers right - 49 years old with 39 convictions - this one I guess will make it 40/50 by his next birthday. That is simply staggering. He has been caught, tried and found guilty of a crime every year of his life since he was 10. Assuming this was only since he was 18, and that he has spent some time inside before then it's likely it's actually significantly more than that. He is a one man crime wave.

A few weeks ago I dug out the crime detection figures, and from memory I think around ~20% of total crime is detected. If the same applies to this guy then the total amount of crimes he has likely committed is just stupid. Clearly a habitual offender who simply can not help himself.

What on earth was he doing walking around freely? How many lives would have been improved if some judge at some point had twigged that he is not about to change his ways. Quite possibly including his own if it saved him from what sounds like an utterly wasted half century of drink, drugs, violence and crime.
Good post, now I've read that 11 years doesn't seem enough.

hornetrider

Original Poster:

63,161 posts

236 months

Saturday 20th October 2012
quotequote all
mickk said:
Good post, now I've read that 11 years doesn't seem enough.
On reflection, I would have to agree. I guess my OP reflects my usual jaded expectation that another slap on the wrist/community sentence would have been handed down.

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Saturday 20th October 2012
quotequote all
mickk said:
AJS- said:
Sometimes I make these sort of posts, then I go away and think I'm being a bit over the top, or making assumptions with incomplete knowledge. This time I went away, thought about it and then I came back and had to recheck the article to make sure I had the numbers right - 49 years old with 39 convictions - this one I guess will make it 40/50 by his next birthday. That is simply staggering. He has been caught, tried and found guilty of a crime every year of his life since he was 10. Assuming this was only since he was 18, and that he has spent some time inside before then it's likely it's actually significantly more than that. He is a one man crime wave.

A few weeks ago I dug out the crime detection figures, and from memory I think around ~20% of total crime is detected. If the same applies to this guy then the total amount of crimes he has likely committed is just stupid. Clearly a habitual offender who simply can not help himself.

What on earth was he doing walking around freely? How many lives would have been improved if some judge at some point had twigged that he is not about to change his ways. Quite possibly including his own if it saved him from what sounds like an utterly wasted half century of drink, drugs, violence and crime.
Good post, now I've read that 11 years doesn't seem enough.
Agree with all that.

Are you listening cameron?