Capping child related benefits to two children
Capping child related benefits to two children
Author
Discussion

BeefMaster9000

Original Poster:

82 posts

255 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-20077758

I'm perhaps slightly biased in that I don't have any children, and that if I was to pro-create with lady beefmaster, I couldn't see us spawning more than two. But I've often wondered why we don't already do something similar to the above proposal.

Some of the Labour politicians have been likening it the totalitarian approach of China and its one child policy, whilst others are complaining that children shouldn't be punished for being born into a workless / benefit dependent household.

But I think Duncan Smith is spot on with his observation that many hard working, would be parents, are having to (rightly) defer starting a family, until they have achieved a stable footing. Whether it be reaching a certain income threshold to pay for the various costs associated with having a child, or attaining a suitable family home in which to raise a family.

Meanwhile for the less diligent, less pro-active, less employable amongst us, the dilemma would appear to be reversed. Rather than considering how they are going to pay for, or house their new child, they are given the incentive of getting a bigger house, and more money to pay for their new arrival instead.

Surely this is a bad thing? and yet his comments have generally been regarded as controversial, with various Lib Dems distancing themselves from the idea..

McClure

2,173 posts

177 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
Completely agree. Getting pregnant to get a house was going on even when people in my school left at 16 in the mid-90's. Half the problem has been politicians being so out of touch that they didn't believe this was going on - I remember an interview with Tony Benn about 10 years ago now when he was flatly refusing to believe there were people out there who would do this, or - shock of shocks - didn't want to work and were happy collecting their benefits.

Ginetta G15 Girl

3,220 posts

215 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
Here's an idea:

If you want children then you pay for them and stop expecting the rest of society to finance your lifestyle choice.

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
There shouldn't really be any child benefit at all. If you can't afford to have children you don't. But like most benefits it is a sure fire vote loser from a large demographic to scrap it/ change it too much. As in most decisions Politicians make, they are led not by what's good for the country long term, but by what gets them as many votes as possible at the next election from the Plebs..Tinkering around the edges..

..it needs to at the very least be capped at 2 anyway. I heard some Muppet on tv yesterday saying how introducing such legislation would make the UK aligned with China blah blah..free choice is there, individuals just shouldnt expect other people to pay for their lifestyles

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
In principle I'm against all child benefits. Since we have them though this just seems to hit the wrong people, discouraging low-middle earners - the very people who need to reproduce more - from doing so. It will do nothing to deter 18 year old girls who want a council flat or career slobs who have 8 kids while never doing a day's work.

Just scrapping it altogether would be better.

crazy about cars

4,454 posts

200 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
I wonder how many who oppose child benefits actually have children wink

Capping at 2 definitely is a good idea though.

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
crazy about cars said:
I wonder how many who oppose child benefits actually have children wink

Capping at 2 definitely is a good idea though.
I doubt any, Turkeys don't vote for Xmas generally. That doesn't mean it's not wrong though. More personal responsibility needs to be encouraged in this country. I am sick of the entitlement culture that is just as rife in the middle classes as the lower classes.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
Won't happen not a single chance in hell


What i can see happening is anyone in work gets child benefit capped at 2 children

Edited by thinfourth2 on Sunday 28th October 18:45

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
What i can see happening is anyone in work gets child benefit at 2 children
?????????????????????????? scratchchin

stargazer30

1,722 posts

197 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
I have 3 kids and we struggle to get by sometimes with both of use working full time. Kids cost a small fortune. I support this idea, even if it means us loosing CB for our youngest. Why? For every family like us theres another 10 who are knocking out kids to get a house and have no intention of working. There kids grow up and do the same. Its not fair on the kids who get dragged up and get a **** start in life and its not fair on the ones who want to work and get taxed to death.

DAVEVO9

3,469 posts

298 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
Ginetta G15 Girl said:
Here's an idea:

If you want children then you pay for them and stop expecting the rest of society to finance your lifestyle choice.
Spot on

Too many have brats that can't afford them

miniman

30,239 posts

293 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
billzeebub said:
crazy about cars said:
I wonder how many who oppose child benefits actually have children wink

Capping at 2 definitely is a good idea though.
I doubt any, Turkeys don't vote for Xmas generally. That doesn't mean it's not wrong though. More personal responsibility needs to be encouraged in this country. I am sick of the entitlement culture that is just as rife in the middle classes as the lower classes.
Tricky one. I have three children - was only supposed to be two but the little buggers divided. Anyway, we had children when we could afford it, and all the child support money is sat in an account to go towards the first car or the first house or whatever. I certainly think that capping is a good concept, and I wouldn't be against scrapping it altogether.

But.

Friends of ours are in the same position as us - unexpected twins throwing a spanner in the works. They work their arses off to pay the mortgage and the child support is a lifeline. They would be better off on benefits with a bigger house. But won't do it on principal.

What about families for whom the absence of child support money wouldn't stop them getting themselves knocked up - should we really take away money from those children?

At the end of the day, it should be properly means tested, and perhaps take into account the efforts, or otherwise, of the parents to provide for the children. But it's by no means clear cut.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
swerni said:
thinfourth2 said:
Won't happen not a single chance in hell


What i can see happening is anyone in work gets child benefit capped at 2 children

Edited by thinfourth2 on Sunday 28th October 18:45
And out of work? ( long term)
Oh they can have as many as they want

Human rights

Jackleman

974 posts

197 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
A few points...

Having children is a lifestyle choice - the rest should not pay.

The UK is over populated.

People should be able to afford to have children before actually having them.


loafer123

16,769 posts

246 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
miniman said:
They would be better off on benefits with a bigger house. But won't do it on principal.
How does that work? You don't suddenly get allocated a big council house the moment you sign on, AFAIK.

crazy about cars

4,454 posts

200 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
loafer123 said:
How does that work? You don't suddenly get allocated a big council house the moment you sign on, AFAIK.
Depends on how many children you have wink

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
Ginetta G15 Girl said:
Here's an idea:

If you want children then you pay for them and stop expecting the rest of society to finance your lifestyle choice.
Here's the kicker though:

Try getting your state pension if the work force isn't filled up (the scheme is a massive pyramid scheme that only works if more money is being paid out than in)

If the benefits are capped then cap them at the babies of two pregnancies, or 2 children, that way if it is twins in the second pregnancy the parent's aren't penalised because the cells divided wrongly.

loafer123

16,769 posts

246 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
crazy about cars said:
loafer123 said:
How does that work? You don't suddenly get allocated a big council house the moment you sign on, AFAIK.
Depends on how many children you have wink
He did say they had 3, though.

miniman

30,239 posts

293 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
loafer123 said:
miniman said:
They would be better off on benefits with a bigger house. But won't do it on principal.
How does that work? You don't suddenly get allocated a big council house the moment you sign on, AFAIK.
Needs a little context I guess. Family of five, living in a tiny two bedroomed terrace. Bunk bed for the twins, with sister in the same room. Dad works two jobs, somewhere around 80 hours a week.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 28th October 2012
quotequote all
Jackleman said:
A few points...

Having children is a lifestyle choice - the rest should not pay.

The UK is over populated.

People should be able to afford to have children before actually having them.

The parents of said children could argue that their children are future taxpayers, lawyers, doctors, bankers and so on. Your no children lifestyle choice up to the age of 65 is perfectly acceptable then you become a burden to the state and the rest of society.

I am quite happy to have child allowance to support two children and no more.