Has political correctness become incorrect?......
Has political correctness become incorrect?......
Author
Discussion

RDMcG

Original Poster:

20,921 posts

238 months

Monday 29th October 2012
quotequote all

Magic919

14,595 posts

232 months

Monday 29th October 2012
quotequote all
Could have sworn this was discussed at the time.

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Monday 29th October 2012
quotequote all
He is right of course, (as is the campaign).

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
He is right of course, (as is the campaign).
+1

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
It hasn't become incorrect. It was always incorrect to try and legislate for how people talk and think.


Edited by AJS- on Tuesday 30th October 13:32

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
AJS-]It hasn't [I]become[/ said:
incorrect. It was always incorrect to try and legislate for how people talk and think.
I'm not sure if it was always incorrect. Does it have its roots in the civil rights movement, and women's suffrage, and the like? Those were noble causes. I think it has snowballed into an uncontrollable beast where the weakest link is the one who is most offended, about anything, affirmative action, daft names for things that once had normal names, and so on, and so forth. It is an industry, like any other.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
Yes but it's always driven by symptoms rather than causes. It tells you that you can't call a certain person a certain name, but it doesn't tell you why.

It aims to change behaviour by punishment, either the reproach of (most often) middle class white people, or by fines and condemnation.

Crucially it doesn't allow the "victim" to make their own case and assert themselves as an individual who is or is not offended by the use of certain language in certain ways at certain times.

This blanket approach has the unintended consequence of being extremely divisive, creating victims who are excluded from their natural peers by their victimhood, and the often innocent perpetrators who dare not speak freely for fear of causing offence, so stay in their white middle class comfort zone.

Spiritual_Beggar

4,833 posts

225 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
Completely agree with Mr Atkinson here.

PC is just another form of 'Oppression'.


OT.: but reading the comments in the OP's article led me to look up some of Winston Churchill's best quotes. He came out with some crackers!;

Bessie Braddock: “Sir, you are drunk.”
Churchill: “Madam, you are ugly. In the morning, I shall be sober.”

Nancy Astor: “Sir, if you were my husband, I would give you poison.”
Churchill: “If I were your husband I would take it.”

"Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy."

"We contend that for a nation to tax itself into prosperity is like a man standing in a bucket and trying to lift himself up by the handle."

A few favourites hehe

IainT

10,040 posts

269 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
http://reformsection5.org.uk/

The NSS is championing this campaign (http://www.secularism.org.uk/reform-section-5.html).

It's good to see so many diverse groups supporting this - groups that would, at first sight, be odd bedfellows.

eta 'odd'


Edited by IainT on Tuesday 30th October 16:28

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
Oh Christ.

Politeness costs nothing. Rowan Atkinson lives in a different wordl to you and I (well me anyway) where people are naturally lovie to each other and polite to the point of being sickening. Churchillian quips and Wildelian wit do not pass much for insults around my way where the people come right out with it, with no humour.

In the real world some people have to be told to be respectful and polite. Some people have to be persuaded to be good to each other - what this country certainly dosn't need is a culture of carte blanche to insult each other - we had that in the sixties and seventies and it was fairly ugly.

IainT

10,040 posts

269 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
mattnunn said:
Oh Christ.

Politeness costs nothing. Rowan Atkinson lives in a different wordl to you and I (well me anyway) where people are naturally lovie to each other and polite to the point of being sickening. Churchillian quips and Wildelian wit do not pass much for insults around my way where the people come right out with it, with no humour.

In the real world some people have to be told to be respectful and polite. Some people have to be persuaded to be good to each other - what this country certainly dosn't need is a culture of carte blanche to insult each other - we had that in the sixties and seventies and it was fairly ugly.
Deliberately obtuse or wilfully stupid?

The entire point is that being insulted is no measure of the rightness nor wrongness of something. The law as it currently stands is manifestly unfit to extend protection to anyone from harm or intimidation without leading to abuses as highlighted in numerous articles. Check out the NSS link and the repeal section 5 site.

Spiritual_Beggar

4,833 posts

225 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
mattnunn said:
Oh Christ.

Politeness costs nothing. Rowan Atkinson lives in a different wordl to you and I (well me anyway) where people are naturally lovie to each other and polite to the point of being sickening. Churchillian quips and Wildelian wit do not pass much for insults around my way where the people come right out with it, with no humour.

In the real world some people have to be told to be respectful and polite. Some people have to be persuaded to be good to each other - what this country certainly dosn't need is a culture of carte blanche to insult each other - we had that in the sixties and seventies and it was fairly ugly.
You sound like one of those people that gets 'offended' if someone looks at you funny hehe

Jesus....when did everyone become so damn sensitive to what other people think!


It's not about having 'carte blanche' to insult people.......it's about not having 'carte blanche' to cry foul of the law because someone says something you disagree with......which is sadly where we have ended up in this country.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
IainT said:
mattnunn said:
Oh Christ.

Politeness costs nothing. Rowan Atkinson lives in a different wordl to you and I (well me anyway) where people are naturally lovie to each other and polite to the point of being sickening. Churchillian quips and Wildelian wit do not pass much for insults around my way where the people come right out with it, with no humour.

In the real world some people have to be told to be respectful and polite. Some people have to be persuaded to be good to each other - what this country certainly dosn't need is a culture of carte blanche to insult each other - we had that in the sixties and seventies and it was fairly ugly.
Deliberately obtuse or wilfully stupid?

The entire point is that being insulted is no measure of the rightness nor wrongness of something. The law as it currently stands is manifestly unfit to extend protection to anyone from harm or intimidation without leading to abuses as highlighted in numerous articles. Check out the NSS link and the repeal section 5 site.
I would but my work web filter deems it unfit for work time consumption, it's political correctness gone mad - I know.

People have a right to be protected from the stupidity, ignorrance and abuse that undoubtly came before political correctness and will undoubtly come after it.

Obviously if people feel their freedom of expression is curtailed by the rights of others to be protected from filthy ignorrant opinion, then that is a line society has to walk.

This argument usually resolves to WASP middle age blokes with ego and self esteem issues being upset that they can longer call a spade a spade. As if that ever made you more of a man.

Edited by mattnunn on Tuesday 30th October 16:55

NWTony

3,011 posts

259 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
mattnunn said:
I would but my work web filter deems it unfit for work time consumption, it's political correctness gone mad - I know.

People have a right to be protected from the stupidity, ignorrance and abuse that undoubtly came before political correctness and undoubtly came after it.

Obviously if people feel their freedom of expression is curtailed by the rights of others to be protected from filthy ignorrant opinion, then that is a line society has to walk.

This argument usually resolves to WASP middle age blokes with ego and self esteem issues being upset that they can longer call a spade a spade. As if that ever made you more of a man.
Who decides what is "stupidity, ignorrance and abuse ", is it you or me? What exactly constitutes "filthy ignorrant opinion"?

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
NWTony said:
Who decides what is "stupidity, ignorrance and abuse ", is it you or me?
Elected democratic government, with the backing of intellectual and academic research. This is the way all societal paradigms should be made. if you know of a better way then please let us know, or more importantly let your MP know and involve yourself with your peers and form a democratic or intellectual voice of reason.


NWTony said:
What exactly constitutes "filthy ignorrant opinion"?
It's on the victim of an insult to judge how whether they are insulted or not, not the perpetrator. That said ignorrance is a simple lacking or misjudgment of knowledge, most of the "PC gone mad" brigade hold onto the ideal of the right to insult because they are simply ignorrant of the offense it causes, it's a simple lacking of empathy, not an unusual position for a WASP middle aged male to be in (although they continue to bleet about being a pesecuted majority expecting empathy in return).

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
Mattnunn makes me glad we have democracy, on the simple premise that it gives him a less than 1/60m chance of becoming a dictator.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
Mattnunn makes me glad we have democracy, on the simple premise that it gives him a less than 1/60m chance of becoming a dictator.
Less than that I'd have thought...

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
mattnunn said:
AJS- said:
Mattnunn makes me glad we have democracy, on the simple premise that it gives him a less than 1/60m chance of becoming a dictator.
Less than that I'd have thought...
But more than you deserve.

BullMoose

31 posts

173 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
mattnunn said:
This argument usually resolves to WASP middle age blokes with ego and self esteem issues being upset that they can longer call a spade a spade. As if that ever made you more of a man.

Edited by mattnunn on Tuesday 30th October 16:55
What absolute dross! It's the middle aged folk brought up in the 50's & 60's that kicked the racial barriers down! We're the generation that were thrown into the melting pot and worked things out. There of course were exceptions to the rule but that could be said of now too. People can have their soft, holier than thou PC outlook. We had it better and you knew where you stood. We don't do PC.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
BullMoose said:
mattnunn said:
This argument usually resolves to WASP middle age blokes with ego and self esteem issues being upset that they can longer call a spade a spade. As if that ever made you more of a man.

Edited by mattnunn on Tuesday 30th October 16:55
What absolute dross! It's the middle aged folk brought up in the 50's & 60's that kicked the racial barriers down! We're the generation that were thrown into the melting pot and worked things out. There of course were exceptions to the rule but that could be said of now too. People can have their soft, holier than thou PC outlook. We had it better and you knew where you stood. We don't do PC.
"You" invented it.