More tax dodging scum
Author
Discussion

thinfourth2

Original Poster:

32,414 posts

235 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-20157878

An offshore company employing thousands of BLANKs is avoiding the payment of millions of pounds in employer's National Insurance contributions.

ISS Ltd, based in the Channel Islands, employs more than 24,000 temporary agency workers across the UK

ISS says it is "meticulous in complying with HMRC codes on taxes and expenses".

ISS is a payroll company - sometimes known as an "umbrella" company - which pays the salaries and expenses of workers who find jobs through recruitment agencies in the UK.



I for one is disgusted and think this culture is disgusting and you would never see this kind of thing in an honourable public serving profession

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
I do believe if you are to receive money from the Government then you have to be paying tax in to the Government as well.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-20157878

An offshore company employing thousands of BLANKs is avoiding the payment of millions of pounds in employer's National Insurance contributions.

ISS Ltd, based in the Channel Islands, employs more than 24,000 temporary agency workers across the UK

ISS says it is "meticulous in complying with HMRC codes on taxes and expenses".

ISS is a payroll company - sometimes known as an "umbrella" company - which pays the salaries and expenses of workers who find jobs through recruitment agencies in the UK.



I for one is disgusted and think this culture is disgusting and you would never see this kind of thing in an honourable public serving profession
Seems they need to be taught how to behave.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
elster said:
I do believe if you are to receive money from the Government then you have to be paying tax in to the Government as well.
Not really. The government has no money. It pays some people with taxes it has taken and then simply takes some of that tax back again.

In this case not enough.

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
The fact that an employer is based outside the UK should not automatically mean that its employees - who are almost all UK tax resident individuals - should not pay the correct PAYE and NIC on their salaries. There has to be more to this scheme than just being merely based in the Channel Islands.

My hunch is that it is a "loan based" payment system i.e. the "employees" are paid a minimum amount as "wages" and the bulk of the payments are being made to them as "loans". A loan is not taxable income as - of course - it stands to be repaid at some point in time.

The trick with these systems is that the "loan" NEVER gets repaid. So, in reality, they aren't loans at all. HMRC seems to have extreme difficulty - or perhaps reluctance - to really tackle these types of highly artificial constructs.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
So instead of the government getting more tax. Consumers have more disposable income.
Hmm, I wonder if their money is better spent on stimulating the economy than government spending!?

Either the govt gets the money to spend or the consumer.

If the argument is that the govt is more deserving then everyone should try and pay as much tax as they can.
Cash in all their ISA's pensions and other tax avoidance scams.

The problem is not the company but incompetent government legislation.
Why does the govt not move to a simple flat tax with zero allowances or exceptions!?

Slaav

4,377 posts

241 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
The fact that an employer is based outside the UK should not automatically mean that its employees - who are almost all UK tax resident individuals - should not pay the correct PAYE and NIC on their salaries. There has to be more to this scheme than just being merely based in the Channel Islands.

My hunch is that it is a "loan based" payment system i.e. the "employees" are paid a minimum amount as "wages" and the bulk of the payments are being made to them as "loans". A loan is not taxable income as - of course - it stands to be repaid at some point in time.

The trick with these systems is that the "loan" NEVER gets repaid. So, in reality, they aren't loans at all. HMRC seems to have extreme difficulty - or perhaps reluctance - to really tackle these types of highly artificial constructs.
Eric, I didn't read it that way!

My understanding of this (forgetting the morality etc) is that it is just the Employer NIC that is saved; the agency workers themselves simply pay Tax and 'ee NIC as normal being UK Res etc.

I woul dbe more inclined to question the idiots at the Govt/Civil Service that signed up and agreed to the contract for services without insisting that the PAYE was run through a UK satellite? THus, impossible to avoid 'er NIC?

WOuld love to know what committee signed off the whole 'deal' and who will take 'lead responsibility' for signing the contract?? (A phrase used recently by a snr CS)

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
The fact that an employer is based outside the UK should not automatically mean that its employees - who are almost all UK tax resident individuals - should not pay the correct PAYE and NIC on their salaries. There has to be more to this scheme than just being merely based in the Channel Islands.

My hunch is that it is a "loan based" payment system i.e. the "employees" are paid a minimum amount as "wages" and the bulk of the payments are being made to them as "loans". A loan is not taxable income as - of course - it stands to be repaid at some point in time.

The trick with these systems is that the "loan" NEVER gets repaid. So, in reality, they aren't loans at all. HMRC seems to have extreme difficulty - or perhaps reluctance - to really tackle these types of highly artificial constructs.
Entirely correct and I think Eric's hunch is very probably well founded. The fact is that for whatever reason, neither the Treasury nor the Inland Revenue seem to be able to prevent this sort of fiscal abuse. Despite having absolutely clear written evidence of the abuse, in detail, more than a year ago. Direct to the relevant treasury minister. There has not even been an acknowledgement of the information. Which was definitely delivered.

Tax avoidance schemes in the UK are proliferating like topsy. They invariable incorporate a very doubtful device such as a loan which is never repaid as part of the scheme modus operandi. What is needed is effective action in every case to expose the device for the improper element it contains. IMO the R opinion that the loss could fall upon the teachers, the employment agencies or the local authorities is just so much hot air.

"He who comes to court must come with clean hands", is the old legal epithet relating to seeking losses from others. Clearly the Revenue have allowed this to continue without challenge. They have all the details of the extent of the scheme which is operating on the employment of 24000 teachers in the UK and have cheerfully ignored it. That is their choice. They cannot then pursue organisations who have acted properly within the law who were not responsible for the scheme.

Sadly, I think the Treasury and Revenue have reached the point where ineffective sabre rattling has replaced effective administration of fiscal collection. Hence the huge proliferation of such schemes.


hornet

6,333 posts

281 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
What are the odds that quite a few people within HMRC turn out to be employed in the same manner?

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
I would not be surprised. HMRC is no longer fit for purpose as an organisation. It has effectively washed its hands of proper administration of taxation in the UK and has merely passed the entire responsbility for doing things correctly on to those who have to pay staff etc.

It is because of this shift of emphasis that these types of schemes have blossomed and expanded over the last few years.

paulrockliffe

16,677 posts

258 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Interesting comments Eric. My understanding is that these scheme operators have to register with HMRC and that they have to tell HMRC who is on these schemes. I was under the impression that they are as aggressive as they can be in closing these schemes down, hence you finidng out about Jimmy Carr etc. Do you think that when the General Anti Avoidance Rule comes in that that will make a difference?

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
I have a client who has decided to switch to one of these aggressive scheme. Once he is up and running on the scheme, he will no longer be one of my clients.

I actually spoke to one of the "whizz kids" behind the scheme who explained to me how the scheme works and it was essentially a loan system as I outlined above. I asked him about obtaining HMRC approval for the scheme (which is a legal requirement for all tax avoidance schemes now). He explained to me that, in his opinion, his scheme did not fit within the definition of a notifiable tax avoidance scheme so therefore they hadn't bothered notifying HMRC.

They are sharks and charlatans - and the taxpayer will pick up the entire tab if and when HMRC finally comes calling. In the meantime they will have picked up massive fees which they are under no obligation to refund to their client if their scheme is eventually found to be a total scam.

JuniorD

9,013 posts

254 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
I have a client who has decided to switch to one of these aggressive scheme. Once he is up and running on the scheme, he will no longer be one of my clients.

I actually spoke to one of the "whizz kids" behind the scheme who explained to me how the scheme works and it was essentially a loan system as I outlined above. I asked him about obtaining HMRC approval for the scheme (which is a legal requirement for all tax avoidance schemes now). He explained to me that, in his opinion, his scheme did not fit within the definition of a notifiable tax avoidance scheme so therefore they hadn't bothered notifying HMRC.

They are sharks and charlatans - and the taxpayer will pick up the entire tab if and when HMRC finally comes calling. In the meantime they will have picked up massive fees which they are under no obligation to refund to their client if their scheme is eventually found to be a total scam.
I don't often get outraged, but thes type of scheme is outrageous. IMO as long as these loan-based tax avoidance schemes are allowed to continue, the government have the cheek to talk about clamping down on benefit cheats.

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
The do an awful lot of talking about clamping down on all sorts of behaviour - including sharp practice in the tax world.

But they don't.

fandango_c

1,993 posts

217 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
My hunch is that it is a "loan based" payment system i.e. the "employees" are paid a minimum amount as "wages" and the bulk of the payments are being made to them as "loans". A loan is not taxable income as - of course - it stands to be repaid at some point in time.
Any evidence that this is a loan based approach?

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
fandango_c said:
Eric Mc said:
My hunch is that it is a "loan based" payment system i.e. the "employees" are paid a minimum amount as "wages" and the bulk of the payments are being made to them as "loans". A loan is not taxable income as - of course - it stands to be repaid at some point in time.
Any evidence that this is a loan based approach?
No - I was surmising. The report I heard this morning didn't give any technical details as to how this particular scheme was supposed to work.

What particular taxes are they avoiding -

Income Tax (i.e. PAYE)?
Employee's NI?
Employer's NI?

All of the above?

I'd like to know.

And once it's clear what taxes they are avoiding, then I'd like to know what is their interpretation of the tax and NI rules that makes them believe they don't need to pay those particular taxes.

My understanding was that the taxes and NI due on payments to employees was based on the locatiomn and tax status of the employees - not the location of the employer. If the employer is situated abroad, they normally need to appoint an agent in the UK to manage and calculate the correct and appropriate taxes and NI arising on the salaries to the UK based employees.

Edited by Eric Mc on Sunday 4th November 13:32

fandango_c

1,993 posts

217 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
No - I was surmising. The report I heard this morning didn't give any technical details as to how this particular scheme was supposed to work.

What particular taxes are they avoiding -

Income Tax (i.e. PAYE)?
Employee's NI?
Employer's NI?

All of the above?

I'd like to know.

And once it's clear what taxes they are avoiding, then I'd like to know what is their interpretation of the tax and NI rules that makes them believe they don't need to pay those particular taxes.

My understanding was that the taxes and NI due on payments to employees was based on the locatiomn and tax status of the employees - not the location of the employer. If the employer is situated abroad, they normally need to appoint an agent in the UK to manage and calculate the correct and appropriate taxes and NI arising on the salaries to the UK based employees.

Edited by Eric Mc on Sunday 4th November 13:32
Surely all of that is a matter for HMRC, ISS Ltd & any individuals involved.

Meanwhile, it's probably best if you don't surmise. There's no suggestion that anything illegal/unlawful has been done.

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
It's all about interpretation. EVERY tax avoidance scheme is touted as being "legal" by those who make money by providing such schemes. They are definitely not going to advertise a scheme as an "illegal tax evasion" scheme, are they?

Often, however, they are classified as "legal" by themselves only. As I said earlier, they have a legal obligation to provide details of all such schemes to HMRC BEFORE the scheme is put in place, so HMRC get a chance for THEIR interpretation of the scheme's legality. It is obvious to me that many such scheme providers are not complying with their obligation to do this.

AND it is also obvious to me that, for whatever reason (lack of resources, pressue being applied from on high etc), HMRC are also not pursuing these schemes as thoroughly as they should.

I repeat what I said earlier, I would like to know which piece of tax or NI legislation this particular scheme THINKS they are exploiting. If they are confident that it is legal, they should have every confidence in explaining how it works.

1point7bar

1,305 posts

179 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
The benefit of offshore capital is something we want onshore.
We do not necessarily need the capital.

It is easy to assign (tax paid) any real benefit of capital that may occur, even over an extended period of time, when gilt yields are so low.

IMO a bit of a fiscal own-goal.

ellroy

7,858 posts

256 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
I read an article on this somewhere, telegraph I think, it was avoiding employer NI .