This 2 child benefit cap thing - does anyone have any stats?
This 2 child benefit cap thing - does anyone have any stats?
Author
Discussion

stuthemong

Original Poster:

2,536 posts

248 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
The whole 'poor people just have kids because they get benefit money' is very Daily Mail.

I was wondering if there are any proper hard and fast statistics about how many people would actually fall into this category. This is likely a very media driven 'issue' and very topical in that it's becoming more of a political one, but I was wondering if anyone has any real stats to show the extent of this 'problem'? I don't doubt that a few take advantage of the system, but is it really the widespread issue it's currently made out to be? I can't believe it really is, but it would be interest to see how so.

If anyone knows of any hard and fast numbers I'd love to see them.

Thanks,

Stu

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
stuthemong said:
The whole 'poor people just have kids because they get benefit money' is very Daily Mail.

I was wondering if there are any proper hard and fast statistics about how many people would actually fall into this category. This is likely a very media driven 'issue' and very topical in that it's becoming more of a political one, but I was wondering if anyone has any real stats to show the extent of this 'problem'? I don't doubt that a few take advantage of the system, but is it really the widespread issue it's currently made out to be? I can't believe it really is, but it would be interest to see how so.

If anyone knows of any hard and fast numbers I'd love to see them.

Thanks,

Stu
How on earth could you generate statistics for the intention of a pregnancy? How many people do you think would answer honestly that, yes, they did have their kids to up their benefit claim even if it was true?

phil-sti

2,983 posts

210 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Live in a town with ,assume unemployment, like me, and it's spot on, all 4 yeas apart..

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
How on earth could you generate statistics for the intention of a pregnancy? How many people do you think would answer honestly that, yes, they did have their kids to up their benefit claim even if it was true?

My interpretation of the OP's question is if anyone has any statistics that would confirm if there is indeed a disproportionate number of families who receive benefits and have more than two children or if this is media hype.

I think based on the limited amount of information available people are coming to one of two conclusions. Either there are too many families living on benefits (with no working parents) who have more than two children plus continue having them in order to get more money. That said child benefit only means £13.40pw per extra child - hardly the biggest money maker? At the other end of the spectrum some believe that there is also a large number of families with income of over £50k who are still eligible for benefits who perhaps should get nothing let alone payment for two children.


Just my 2pence.


rover 623gsi

5,230 posts

192 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
how about this for starters - from the ONS

the total number of families with dependent children
1996 / 2012
7,393,000 / 7,739,000

Percentage of dependent children per family 1996 / 2012
One child 42% / 47%
Two children 41% / 39%
Three or more children 17% / 14%

http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/family-demography/fa...


Edited by rover 623gsi on Sunday 4th November 19:15

Silver

4,373 posts

257 months

Efbe

9,251 posts

197 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
rover 623gsi said:
how about this for starters - from the ONS

the total number of families with dependent children
1996 / 2012
7,393,000 / 7,739,000

Percentage of dependent children per family 1996 / 2012
One child 42% / 47%
Two children 41% / 39%
Three or more children 17% / 14%

http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/family-demography/fa...


Edited by rover 623gsi on Sunday 4th November 19:15
so the answer to the OPs question is No then, it is just the media peddling a story with no substance

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
I dont get the outrage with this - someone has stood up and said "look, if you can't afford children, we'll help out with a couple.....but thats it, after that, you're on your own".

What's the issue? If you want more, you're going to have to pay for them.

London424

12,946 posts

206 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Pork said:
I dont get the outrage with this - someone has stood up and said "look, if you can't afford children, we'll help out with a couple.....but thats it, after that, you're on your own".

What's the issue? If you want more, you're going to have to pay for them.
It's very strange isn't it? They can even "grandfather" or "red circle" current families if they want. They have to make some changes or we aren't getting out of the almighty hole we are in.

Just from those figures above 14% of families are claiming for more than 2 children...surely that's a pretty sizeable chunk of change?

Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Pork said:
I dont get the outrage with this - someone has stood up and said "look, if you can't afford children, we'll help out with a couple.....but thats it, after that, you're on your own".

What's the issue? If you want more, you're going to have to pay for them.
This x 10000%... it is a bit of a case of bolting the gate after the horse has bolted though. Perhaps if it stops chavs sprogging uncontrollably and us having to pay for it that's a good thing. With the impending invasion of benefit seeking Bulgarians and Romanians it can't come soon enough.

Efbe

9,251 posts

197 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Pork said:
I dont get the outrage with this - someone has stood up and said "look, if you can't afford children, we'll help out with a couple.....but thats it, after that, you're on your own".

What's the issue? If you want more, you're going to have to pay for them.
why stop there, why not cap it at one child? that would save 39%+14%

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Efbe said:
why stop there, why not cap it at one child? that would save 39%+14%
Why provide any support at all?

There's a massive discussion to be had around it all, but I know plenty of poeple who would like more than 2 kids, but dont, mainly due to affordability. I think the main point of these proposed reforms is to make it that everyone has the same consideration. At the moment, from what I understand, if you're heavily dependant on social support, affordability isnt a consideration. in fact, there are cases where people cannot afford to work due to the number of children they have. How can that be right?

barker22

1,037 posts

198 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all

Whilst I agree that this is a good idea.(Don't have kids unless you can afford them) I don't think it is entirely the chavs thinking about purely getting more money. I have been around 'these people' most of my life and they just don't give anything a second thought. There is no way that these young mothers and fathers are looking a year in advance to what they are entitled to.
I have been around it. They have no concept of morals, they go out, get pissed and have sex without using contraception. Or they do it at home within their 'benefits house'
Do you honestly think they sit down and have a conversation about needing more money, and come to the conclusion that if they have a child, in 9 months time they will be better off..... no chance. They look no further that what's on Jeremy Kyle in the morning or when their dole gets paid.
All that will happen is they will continue having kids and the kids will just get less. More kids will go into care as a result.

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
No, they dont think about it at the moment as they have a state-funded safety net.

Perhaps, if suddenly having an extra child means that they'll have to cancel Sky instead of adding the Sports channels, or going without something they currently enjoy, then perhaps the prospect of having to go without will focus the mind a little.

My fear is that its the babies that suffer, not the parent. You're relying on a sense of decency that may not be able to be taken for granted.

BoRED S2upid

21,144 posts

271 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
The stats are in Primark and walking every high street of every town. How does an unemployed couple bring up 3 kids without state handouts? they would have stopped at 1 surley if it didn't pay them extra to have the second or third, I would struggle to afford to feed and clothe 3 kids which is why I don't yet have any.

hornet

6,333 posts

281 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Why have designated benefits at all? Give every adult in the UK an amount each year and be done with it. A sort of national stipend, if you will. Those without kids or housing needs can choose to spend it as they please, whilst those with kids use it for that but understand once it's gone, it's gone. Off the top of my head, you could perhaps vary it according to specific age ranges, ending up with something that morphs into the state pension come retirement age. No fiddling about with allowances or tax credits, just a known value of cash in your hand to do with as you see fit.

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Efbe said:
why stop there, why not cap it at one child? that would save 39%+14%
Cap it at zero children, after all they are only a hobby.

Why should the tax payers fund only some recreations.

People will still have children even if they are not state supported.

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
voyds9 said:
Cap it at zero children, after all they are only a hobby.

Why should the tax payers fund only some recreations.

People will still have children even if they are not state supported.
Social responsibility. If the govt are seen to do nothing for children, at all, those born to poorer families will suffer and no government want to be associated with that.

rover 623gsi

5,230 posts

192 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
voyds9 said:
Why should the tax payers fund only some recreations.
similar reason to why tax payers fund museums, libraries, parks, community centres, the Royal Ballet etc etc etc