Charities Commission - tax driven?
Charities Commission - tax driven?
Author
Discussion

Digga

Original Poster:

48,653 posts

314 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
Interesting news in media over the weekend regarding the Charities Commission's decision on the Plymouth Brethren: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/journalists/rowena-maso...

Telegraph said:
officials decided that religion is not always for “the public benefit” as it denied charitable status to the Plymouth Brethren
HOC Public Administration Committee: http://www.parliamentlive.tv/Main/Player.aspx?meet...

I'd seen similar moves in Australia, relting to them (unfairly) competing in business, but was surprised (given our Christain-controlled laws) any challenge has been made here.

I'm guessing that this is part of wider tax evasion/avoidance picture?

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
Plymouth Brethren have a very strict atitude to pensions, interest charges and other financial transactions - linked to criticism of "usurey" in The Bible. I think they have therefore organised their own alternatives which they consider as being compliant with biblical teaching - and then tried to claim the activity was tax exempt because it was part of their religious activity and therefore part of their overall charitable status for tax purposes.

Hmmm - I can see a bit of a disconnect here between biblical adherence and a moral duty to pay tax.

It will be interesting to see if HMRC are behind the scenes pulling the strings.

Digga

Original Poster:

48,653 posts

314 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
From what I gather, if I understand correctly, the 'church' owns homes and businesses. The flock pay a tithe (a good chunk of their income) over to the church (one more payment to redemtion etc. etc. hehe ) from which the cuerch can claim gift aid (i.e. contributaions are grossed-up) and rent their houses from i and also, if they run businesses, receive extremely, given the current climate, beneficial financial backing as well as various fringe benefits such as HR, and IT pacakges.

As I mentioned in the OP, I know there has been a lot of discussion in Aus about the same and of businesses complaining about very agressive, market dominating tactics, of the charity-backed businesses.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
USA - Scientology is a charity as it's considered a religion

UK - Scientology was refused charitable status as it's not considered a religion

The Plymouth Brethren haven't got a prayer....

Digga

Original Poster:

48,653 posts

314 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
The Plymouth Brethren haven't got a prayer....
rofl Great turn of phrase there.
AFAIK, this was bound to hit them sooner or later.

I think the crux is that they are not for public benefit, indeed are sometimes known as the "Exclusive Brethren" - they live very much apart and exclude non-members from their services.

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Monday 5th November 2012
quotequote all
Digga said:
Ozzie Osmond said:
The Plymouth Brethren haven't got a prayer....
rofl Great turn of phrase there.
AFAIK, this was bound to hit them sooner or later.

I think the crux is that they are not for public benefit, indeed are sometimes known as the "Exclusive Brethren" - they live very much apart and exclude non-members from their services.
Good job the Amish haven't set up here.