UK & Germany Unite Against Corporate Tax Dodging
UK & Germany Unite Against Corporate Tax Dodging
Author
Discussion

loafer123

Original Poster:

16,769 posts

246 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
About time too.

Telegraph said:
George Osborne threatens big business with global tax crackdown

Britain has joined forces with Germany to declare war on taxdodging multinationals and called for an end to loopholes that have allowed them to siphon off billions in profits to tax havens.

Such an investigation would look at how tax policy should be recalibrated by the Government to ensure profits are not being siphoned off aggressively to lower tax-paying jurisdictions and away from the exchequer

In a rare and hard–hitting joint statement, Chancellor George Osborne and his German counterpart, Wolfgang Schaeuble, called for the world's leading economies to combat tax avoidance and to force corporations to pay their fair share of tax or face the consequences.

The pair want to stamp out the practice of profit–shifting and so-called "transfer pricing", whereby big companies legally move income earned in one country to another jurisdiction to lower their total tax bill. The activity is depriving governments of huge tax revenues and giving multinational businesses an unfair advantage over domestic rivals, they said.

The issue has seen the likes of Amazon, Facebook and Google face increased scrutiny. Starbucks has come under fire for paying no corporation tax in Britain for the past three years, while Amazon, Facebook and Google have together paid less than £30m of tax despite sales of £3.1bn over the past four years.

Apple is paying less than 2pc tax on its overseas profits, despite earning $36.8bn of profits outside the US. At the weekend, it emerged that foreign companies could be responsible for as much as £11bn in unpaid British taxes.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfinance/9656882/George-Osborne-threatens-big-business-with-global-tax-crackdown.html

Digga

48,653 posts

314 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
loafer123 said:
About time too.
You'll find a few ready to fight the other corner on here I'm afraid, but personally I agree.

Whilst I'm by no means anti-cpaitalist, interventions and regulations are necessary at times, within the free market, to address inherent risks. The ability of these mega-corporations to syphon captial out of developed economies and hide it offshore is, IMHO, a big risk.

Hugo a Gogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
these companies want all the advantages of a well-governed country (OK, I'm not saying UK or Germany are the pinnacle of good government by any stretch) infrastructure, law and order, legal protection, property rights, patents, educated, healthy workforce - but they don't want to share any part of paying for it

loafer123

Original Poster:

16,769 posts

246 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Digga said:
loafer123 said:
About time too.
You'll find a few ready to fight the other corner on here I'm afraid, but personally I agree.

Whilst I'm by no means anti-cpaitalist, interventions and regulations are necessary at times, within the free market, to address inherent risks. The ability of these mega-corporations to syphon captial out of developed economies and hide it offshore is, IMHO, a big risk.
Indeed. For the avoidance of doubt, I'm no left wing/liberal idiot, but the way in which these corporations have been stripping out income is obscene.

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
loafer123 said:
Indeed. For the avoidance of doubt, I'm no left wing/liberal idiot, but the way in which these corporations have been stripping out income is obscene.
Ditto - I'm pretty right wing, but I can't agree that profits can be taken out of the country before tax.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Also agree. Good initiative - will everyone need to sign up though?

loafer123

Original Poster:

16,769 posts

246 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Also agree. Good initiative - will everyone need to sign up though?
Certainly there are implications on Tax Treaties, but nothing that can't be resolved on a regional basis.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Well I'll be the first of the bad guys then. It's just going to provide another incentive to locate in Luxembourg, Switzerland or some other lucky country whose politicians are just a little less greedy.

loafer123

Original Poster:

16,769 posts

246 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
Well I'll be the first of the bad guys then. It's just going to provide another incentive to locate in Luxembourg, Switzerland or some other lucky country whose politicians are just a little less greedy.
You're missing the point. These corporates already locate in Zug or Lux or the Caymans and move their income there before tax, thereby avoiding paying tax in the country where the income was generated.

What they can't do is say "sod it" and leave the UK in trading terms, because then they end up with no business.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
It depends how desperate the politicians get. Agree it's unlikely to result in major companies stopping doing business in the UK or Germany completely as that would be self defeating, but it's pretty well proven time and time again that people always find loopholes, and will continue to do so.

Spiritual_Beggar

4,833 posts

225 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Whilst i do find it wrong that these big companies get away with such little tax.......they are still operating within the law.

So, its alright for these politicians to come out and say the Big Bad Corps. need to pay their way, but it's the overly complicated tax systems that allow these loopholes to exist in the first place.

Osbourne et al., get off your arses.......do you job properly......and simplify the tax system!!!!

OllieC

3,816 posts

245 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Spiritual_Beggar said:
Whilst i do find it wrong that these big companies get away with such little tax.......they are still operating within the law.

So, its alright for these politicians to come out and say the Big Bad Corps. need to pay their way, but it's the overly complicated tax systems that allow these loopholes to exist in the first place.

Osbourne et al., get off your arses.......do you job properly......and simplify the tax system!!!!
Quite, lets make the UK more attractive to business.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Puggit said:
loafer123 said:
Indeed. For the avoidance of doubt, I'm no left wing/liberal idiot, but the way in which these corporations have been stripping out income is obscene.
Ditto - I'm pretty right wing, but I can't agree that profits can be taken out of the country before tax.
i'm really struggling to understand why 'right wingers' (not just you gents) are advocating higher taxes. we all want the likes of starbucks to stop exporting their profits to ireland and level the playing field with domestic companies. imo the answer is simple; lower uk corporation tax to such a level it becomes uneconomic for companies to structure themselves in dublin.

what is corporation tax anyway? once you've stopped the wholesale export of profits its a taxation on employees and consumers! people are looking at this like it's 'free money' because they don't see it coming directly out their own pockets, infact it's just coming out their pension funds in the form of lower dividends, employee benefits and higher prices.




Edited by fbrs on Tuesday 6th November 14:27

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
fbrs said:
Puggit said:
loafer123 said:
Indeed. For the avoidance of doubt, I'm no left wing/liberal idiot, but the way in which these corporations have been stripping out income is obscene.
Ditto - I'm pretty right wing, but I can't agree that profits can be taken out of the country before tax.
i'm really struggling to understand why 'right wingers' (not just you gents) are advocating higher taxes. we all want the likes of starbucks to stop exporting their profits to ireland and level the playing field with domestic companies. imo the answer is simple; lower uk corporation tax to such a level it becomes uneconomic for companies to structure themselves in dublin. their ct rate is 12.5%, add in the cost of offices, duplicate staff, legal and compliance etc i guess about 15% would do it. ct raises 50bn a year at 20-24%, most of which is paid at the small company rate so a drop to 15% would cost in the order of 15bn before the effects of widening the tax base to catch the likes of starbucks and google are taken in to account, not to mention the corporate jobs created from such companies moving back 'onshore' and the increase in FDI.

what is corporation tax anyway? once you've stopped the wholesale export of profits its a taxation on employees and consumers! people are looking at this like it's 'free money' because they don't see it coming directly out their own pockets, infact it's just coming out their pension funds in the form of lower dividends, employee benefits and higher prices.
Exactly!

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Hugo a Gogo said:
these companies want all the advantages of a well-governed country (OK, I'm not saying UK or Germany are the pinnacle of good government by any stretch) infrastructure, law and order, legal protection, property rights, patents, educated, healthy workforce - but they don't want to share any part of paying for it
I think you'll find that they want to be here to access the market. Little else.

But I do agree they should be made to pay taxes in that market and not elsewhere, though the only answer to that is for us to be competitive with these other places.

Hugo a Gogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
Hugo a Gogo said:
these companies want all the advantages of a well-governed country (OK, I'm not saying UK or Germany are the pinnacle of good government by any stretch) infrastructure, law and order, legal protection, property rights, patents, educated, healthy workforce - but they don't want to share any part of paying for it
I think you'll find that they want to be here to access the market. Little else.

But I do agree they should be made to pay taxes in that market and not elsewhere, though the only answer to that is for us to be competitive with these other places.
the profitable market only exists because of the infrastructure, law etc

how many Starbucks in Lagos? how much electricals does Amazon deliver to Lagos? how well protected are their patents in North Korea?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Guam said:
Not me, my feelings on Transfer pricing are well known on here, its a scam and has always been a scam.
agreed but i want to build a car factory in the uk. i'm going to employ 3000 people and export half the cars to europe. here's the catch, i'm going to export any profits to the netherlands and pay no uk ct. you still want me or not?

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Hugo a Gogo said:
the profitable market only exists because of the infrastructure, law etc

how many Starbucks in Lagos? how much electricals does Amazon deliver to Lagos? how well protected are their patents in North Korea?
And how many multinational companies serving the UK and Germany are headquartered there?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Hugo a Gogo said:
the profitable market only exists because of the infrastructure, law etc
i guess you can't buy mercedes, coca cola or computers in sub saharan africa then?
why can people not see that corporation tax is simply another tax on THEM?

loafer123

Original Poster:

16,769 posts

246 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
fbrs said:
Puggit said:
loafer123 said:
Indeed. For the avoidance of doubt, I'm no left wing/liberal idiot, but the way in which these corporations have been stripping out income is obscene.
Ditto - I'm pretty right wing, but I can't agree that profits can be taken out of the country before tax.
i'm really struggling to understand why 'right wingers' (not just you gents) are advocating higher taxes. we all want the likes of starbucks to stop exporting their profits to ireland and level the playing field with domestic companies. imo the answer is simple; lower uk corporation tax to such a level it becomes uneconomic for companies to structure themselves in dublin.

what is corporation tax anyway? once you've stopped the wholesale export of profits its a taxation on employees and consumers! people are looking at this like it's 'free money' because they don't see it coming directly out their own pockets, infact it's just coming out their pension funds in the form of lower dividends, employee benefits and higher prices.




Edited by fbrs on Tuesday 6th November 14:27
Who is advocating an increase in tax? Not me.

I certainly think that corporation tax shouldn't be optional through offshoring within the EU, and WHT deals with some of the worst tax haven issues already.

In terms of tax rates, if we set a tax rate of more than Ireland, but it has to be paid, then companies can choose whether they want to allocate capital into building their business here or not.

At that point we are competeing for investment on a sensible basis and then corporatation tax is a lever for us to use to attract more capital. At the moment, Ireland is no more nor less than an EU tax haven, so nothing we do will make a difference to that capital allocation and all the power is in the hands of the corporations.