Patriotism & the armed forces
Author
Discussion

MadMullah

Original Poster:

5,299 posts

224 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
playing devils advocate for a moment...

why is it that you have to support the armed forces for you to love your country?

especially when referring to the current campaigns of the forces, less so for ww2.

Odie

4,187 posts

213 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Why do you have to support the armed forces, be a patriot and support the current military action taking place?

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
You don't. Patriotism to me seems like a quote weak minded position anyway, all based on where you happen to have been born. An American is oddly patriotic when it comes to America, and a Canadian is patriotic towards Canada, a Frenchman France, and so on, and so forth. It is a simply freak accident that you happened to be born in a particular place.

Ideology should be what you 'love' not country.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Your original position is flawed, as there is not now, nor ever has been an edict for you to love the armed forces to be "allowed" to love your country and culture. Indeed, Arthur Wellesley once said "We have in the service the scum of the earth as common soldiers".

However, the current support for the armed services stems from a few places - the security requirements of NI, which meant no public displays of being military, and the breaking of the military covenant (you volunteer to die, we look after you), which meant a huge upsurge of public support.

If you are asking if PH, as individuals, support the mission in Afghanistan, we probably don't, over much. However, we started it, and owe it to the population of Afghanistan to try and make things as good as they can be before we hand it over to local security forces to do with as they will.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
You don't. Patriotism to me seems like a quote weak minded position anyway, all based on where you happen to have been born. An American is oddly patriotic when it comes to America, and a Canadian is patriotic towards Canada, a Frenchman France, and so on, and so forth. It is a simply freak accident that you happened to be born in a particular place.

Ideology should be what you 'love' not country.
WTF? We should 'love' ideology'? Like National Socialism? Communism? etc.
Patriotism is just enlightened self interest, if its where you live, where your family and friends live, then why wouldnt you want the best for it? Are you confusing patriotism with nationalism?

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
s2art said:
WTF? We should 'love' ideology'? Like National Socialism? Communism? etc.
Patriotism is just enlightened self interest, if its where you live, where your family and friends live, then why wouldnt you want the best for it? Are you confusing patriotism with nationalism?
Not sure why you go straight to communism, etc. My point is that patriotism for its own sake is pointless. The ideologies I am talking about is freedom of speech, equality, and so on, that you value in a society. I am not mistaking patriotism for nationalism. They both seem to be cut from the same cloth to me, just with varying degrees of action.

Edited by TheHeretic on Wednesday 7th November 18:17

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
MadMullah said:
playing devils advocate for a moment...

why is it that you have to support the armed forces for you to love your country?

especially when referring to the current campaigns of the forces, less so for ww2.
Soldiers don't get to choose their wars so you should support them even if you don't support the war they are fighting because one day they may be fighting for you.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
OP - it's just what we do, it's about identity and clan mentality, I'd have thought it's the same as what stops rabbits fking squirrels. You identify your own and stick to them.

Rest assured if we ever got attacked by aliens we'd all become patriots of planet earth and for that time our differences would be cast aside.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
s2art said:
WTF? We should 'love' ideology'? Like National Socialism? Communism? etc.
Patriotism is just enlightened self interest, if its where you live, where your family and friends live, then why wouldnt you want the best for it? Are you confusing patriotism with nationalism?
Not sure why you go straight to communism. My point is that patriotism for its own sake is pointless. The ideologies I am talking about is freedom of speech, equality, and so on, that you value in a society. I am not mistaking patriotism for nationalism. They both seem to be cut from the same cloth to me, just with varying degrees of action.
Patriotism is supporting the country that reflects your ideologies most closely. Freedom of speech and equality are merely abstract concepts without a nation willing to defend them.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
s2art said:
WTF? We should 'love' ideology'? Like National Socialism? Communism? etc.
Patriotism is just enlightened self interest, if its where you live, where your family and friends live, then why wouldnt you want the best for it? Are you confusing patriotism with nationalism?
Not sure why you go straight to communism. My point is that patriotism for its own sake is pointless. The ideologies I am talking about is freedom of speech, equality, and so on, that you value in a society. I am not mistaking patriotism for nationalism. They both seem to be cut from the same cloth to me, just with varying degrees of action.
Then you should have said we should love specific ideas. I gave you the reason why we should be patriotic; enlightened self interest. And no patriotism is not the same as nationalism, a patriot would want the best for his country, a nationalist thinks his country is superior to others and, historically, that has led to nationalists doing things that are to the detriment of their country.

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
Patriotism is supporting the country that reflects your ideologies most closely. Freedom of speech and equality are merely abstract concepts without a nation willing to defend them.
Is it really? Not convinced of that at all. Patriotism seems to me to be entirely about support for your country, not anyone else's country. Ideology does not equal 'country'.

The argument about 'defending them' is entirely different to whether patriotism is a weak stance.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
Soldiers don't get to choose their wars so you should support them even if you don't support the war they are fighting because one day they may be fighting for you.
They're not really ever fighting for me though are they? Everyone I know joined the forces for the opportunities it gives them not for some love of the UK or the Queen or me or whatever. When the conditions became too poor or the opportunities (whatever they were) dried up they left and did something they saw as being better somewhere else. Perhaps some people join the forces to serve their country but it can't be many.

I support the forces no more or less than I support the emergency services or teachers or anyone else who I think does anything worthwhile. They're people paid to do a job. If the job was too difficult or the conditions were too bad for the rewards, people simply wouldn't do it.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
Caulkhead said:
Patriotism is supporting the country that reflects your ideologies most closely. Freedom of speech and equality are merely abstract concepts without a nation willing to defend them.
Is it really? Not convinced of that at all. Patriotism seems to me to be entirely about support for your country, not anyone else's country. Ideology does not equal 'country'.

The argument about 'defending them' is entirely different to whether patriotism is a weak stance.
Indeed, my ideologies (political, moral and cultural) are probably more allingned to Scandinavia or even Ze Germans but if they ever come over here and try to straighten our bannanas I'd give them a holy dose of what for...

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
s2art said:
Then you should have said we should love specific ideas. I gave you the reason why we should be patriotic; enlightened self interest. And no patriotism is not the same as nationalism, a patriot would want the best for his country, a nationalist thinks his country is superior to others and, historically, that has led to nationalists doing things that are to the detriment of their country.
Definition of Ideology
n. pl. i·de·ol·o·gies
1. The body of ideas reflecting the social needs and aspirations of an individual, group, class, or culture.
2. A set of doctrines or beliefs that form the basis of a political, economic, or other system.

'Ideology' does not have to be a societal, or group thing, it is just as applicable to a persons own set of "needs and aspirations", so I will continue to use that term, thanks very much. I suggest when someone says ideology you don't just jump for a worst case scenario as you did in your reply. wink

I disagree with your definition of pateiot as well, as does the dictionary. Plenty of people who wanted what was best for the country have been accused of being unpatriotic.

Patriot
1.
a person who loves, supports, and defends his or her country and its interests with devotion.
2.
a person who regards himself or herself as a defender, especially of individual rights, against presumed interference by the federal government.

It is the "devoted support of ones country" I find to be of the same cloth as nationalism. Nationalism is just the extremity of patriotism.

So, as I said, ideology, (that can mean personal needs and aspirations, not being a Nazi or communist), should be what we support, and defend, not simply the country, (or flag, or figurehead).

PugwasHDJ80

7,684 posts

252 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
MadMullah said:
playing devils advocate for a moment...

why is it that you have to support the armed forces for you to love your country?

especially when referring to the current campaigns of the forces, less so for ww2.
what have hte armed forces got to do with the current campaigns?

the campaigns are started and decided by the politicians- trust me no general in the british armssuddenly decided that invading afghanistan was a good idea.

The recent support is probably because the politicians are happy to send them off to be killed and maimed but not happy to support them properly when they come home!

vonuber

17,868 posts

196 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all



s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
s2art said:
TheHeretic said:
'Ideology' does not have to be a societal, or group thing, it is just as applicable to a persons own set of "needs and aspirations", so I will continue to use that term, thanks very much. I suggest when someone says ideology you don't just jump for a worst case scenario as you did in your reply. wink

Ideology, unqualified, implies that it doesnt matter what the ideology is, but we should still love it. So I suggest you stop using that term unqualified.

Your definition of patriotism is overly simplistic and obviously came from an American dictionary (hence the ref to Federal)

A better description would look like;

1)Special affection for one's own country
2)A sense of personal identification with the country
3)Special concern for the well-being of the country
4)Willingness to sacrifice to promote the country's good

Note that all of these are related to enlightened self interest (even number 4). Its where you live, where you come from, where your family and friends are, where your cultural identity is formed etc. Who the hell wouldnt want the best for their country? Its the only sensible and pragmatic position.

The only thing that might overide that is if the state is doing things that are bad, such as Nazi Germany. In which case it would be your patriotic duty to oppose. Patriotism should not be confused with supporting any given Government or the state.

I agree that there are many positions taken on what patriotism is, but what I describe is close to the modern understanding.

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Wanting the best is based on ideals, not via simple patriotism.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
TheHeretic said:
Wanting the best is based on ideals, not via simple patriotism.
Who said patriotism was simple? And wanting the best is also based upon culture, history, judgement etc.

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
s2art said:
Who said patriotism was simple? And wanting the best is also based upon culture, history, judgement etc.
And those things would be part of your ideals. As I say, ideals make us, patriotism does not.

"Patriotism is your conviction that this country is superior to all other countries because you were born in it."- George Bernard Shaw