Levy on Diesel
Author
Discussion

SILICONEKID346HP

Original Poster:

14,997 posts

262 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Is it time for the levy to be abolished on Diesel ?

My girlfriend drives a diesel car with zero road tax (based on emissions) so is this telling us diesels are now on par with petrol cars, if so the Levy needs to go .


All the countries I have been to in Europe sell diesel cheaper than petrol so it must be cheaper to produce ..

There are a large number of Diesel cars in low road tax brackets so should it be the end of the Levy ?



Edited by SILICONEKID346HP on Sunday 5th January 17:36

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
What would you like the Government to tax instead? Obviously the lost revenue would need to be recovered somehow.

SILICONEKID346HP

Original Poster:

14,997 posts

262 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
slippery said:
What would you like the Government to tax instead? Obviously the lost revenue would need to be recovered somehow.
That should not have anything to do with it ,the levy was bought in because diesel thows more hydro carbons in to the air ,if Diesel engines have improved in line with petrol cars the levy should be abolished

They just can`t make up reason to tax you when it`s not true .


Edited by SILICONEKID346HP on Sunday 5th January 19:22

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
slippery said:
What would you like the Government to tax instead? Obviously the lost revenue would need to be recovered somehow.
Lefties. Windfarms. Solar Panels.

wemorgan

3,583 posts

209 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Lefties. Windfarms. Solar Panels.
rather than fighting wars, nuclear missiles, HS2........OK each to their own I suppose.

Back on topic. Why not make the levy on petrol and diesel equal such that the same revenue is generated. And whilst they are at it, increase the levy on aviation fuel - with £50 flights to Spain it's hardly needed these days anyway.

eldar

25,366 posts

227 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
slippery said:
What would you like the Government to tax instead? Obviously the lost revenue would need to be recovered somehow.
Or cut spending a little bit more?

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
SILICONEKID346HP said:
Is it time for the levy to be abolished on Diesel ?

My girlfriend drives a diesel car with zero road tax (based on emissions) so is this telling us diesels are now on par with petrol cars, if so the Levy needs to go .


All the countries I have been to in Europe sell diesel cheaper than petrol so it must be cheaper to produce ..

There are a large number of Diesel cars in low road tax brackets so should it be the end of the Levy ?



Edited by anonymous-user on Sunday 5th January 17:36
What levy? The only specific levy on diesel that I am aware of is the 3% on Company Car Tax, which is already scheduled to end.

The fuel duty on diesel is the same as for petrol, as is VAT.

The reason diesel is cheaper than petrol in some European countries is because they choose to tax it less than petrol. It has nothing to do with refining costs.

The reason it is more expensive than petrol in the UK is because of higher refining costs due to the lower capacity for refining diesel than petrol.

As far as I am aware.

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

198 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
There is no levy on derv, the duty is the same as petrol. The reason it costs more is because lots of people want to buy it and there is insufficient refining capacity to meet supply - basic economics.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
SILICONEKID346HP said:
Is it time for the levy to be abolished on Diesel ?

My girlfriend drives a diesel car with zero road tax (based on emissions) so is this telling us diesels are now on par with petrol cars, if so the Levy needs to go .


All the countries I have been to in Europe sell diesel cheaper than petrol so it must be cheaper to produce ..

There are a large number of Diesel cars in low road tax brackets so should it be the end of the Levy ?



Edited by SILICONEKID346HP on Sunday 5th January 17:36
What planet are you on? First the van drivel and now this.

Petrol is cheaper in a lot of other countries too. Let's abolish the duty on that.

Don't get me started on income tax and Capital Gains tax after just completing my tax return earlier. In fact let's abolish everything and start again.

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
eldar said:
slippery said:
What would you like the Government to tax instead? Obviously the lost revenue would need to be recovered somehow.
Or cut spending a little bit more?
This. Why is the default answer to question where we would like the government to get the money from. If I say I cant afford something people don't ask me which granny I'm going to mug tonight, they expect me to save somewhere else.

0a

24,160 posts

225 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
We should put a levy on then - noisy and smelly, with lots of other pollutants, diesel set car refinement improvements. Ack decades.

Imagine if all cars were diesel and someone invented a petrol straight 6!

Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
0a said:
We should put a levy on then - noisy and smelly, with lots of other pollutants, diesel set car refinement improvements. Ack decades.

Imagine if all cars were diesel and someone invented a petrol straight 6!
It's not about pollutants now it's all about CO2 and bl@@dy Global Warming.

Oil burners are king.

SILICONEKID346HP

Original Poster:

14,997 posts

262 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
What planet are you on? First the van drivel and now this.

Petrol is cheaper in a lot of other countries too. Let's abolish the duty on that.

Don't get me started on income tax and Capital Gains tax after just completing my tax return earlier. In fact let's abolish everything and start again.
Read the first line of the second paragraph,I`m on this planet thanks

Any GCSE chemistry student can tell you that diesel requires less refining than petrol and less crude oil to produce. Hence the heavy clouds of black smoke so characteristically emitted by older generations of diesel powered cars. But, if that is indeed the case, then the discerning reader will perhaps be wondering why exactly such cheaply produced diesel should be more expensive than petrol. Part of the problem is that diesel isn't actually as cheap to produce as some people think, at least not the modern "clean" variant anyway. Although diesel requires less crude oil per litre than petrol does to produce, newly established standards for lower sulphur diesel require a more complex refining process.

Despite these reductions in sulphur emissions, standard diesel fuel is still taxed more heavily than petrol. In 1994, duty on diesel and unleaded petrol (ULP) was the same, however from 1996 through to 1998 diesel was around a penny per litre more expensive. In 1999 it became three pence per litre. At this stage, ultra low sulphur diesel (ULSD) was introduced into the market and, by 2000 the majority of diesel being sold changed to ULSD. This carries a lower duty rate than standard diesel, and by 2001 the differential between standard diesel and ULSD was up to six pence per litre. However, since 2003 high oil prices have caused the duty on all fuels to rise drastically. In the last 2½ years alone a tripling in oil price has caused the price of fuels to rocket, and it seems to have been the case that diesel users have suffered more than the rest of us. If this were the whole picture though, then fuel would be as expensive everywhere as it is here in the UK. The fact of the matter is that, even with the hike in oil prices, almost three quarters of the petrol station price for any given fuel is government duty. Considering that Britain's motorists buy over 30 billion litres of fuel a year, that's a lot of tax.



Edited by SILICONEKID346HP on Sunday 5th January 21:32

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
eldar said:
slippery said:
What would you like the Government to tax instead? Obviously the lost revenue would need to be recovered somehow.
Or cut spending a little bit more?
Perhaps



Reducing the pay rise to less than 11%

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
SILICONEKID346HP said:
Read the first line of the second paragraph,I`m on this planet thanks

Any GCSE chemistry student can tell you that diesel requires less refining than petrol and less crude oil to produce. Hence the heavy clouds of black smoke so characteristically emitted by older generations of diesel powered cars. But, if that is indeed the case, then the discerning reader will perhaps be wondering why exactly such cheaply produced diesel should be more expensive than petrol. Part of the problem is that diesel isn't actually as cheap to produce as some people think, at least not the modern "clean" variant anyway. Although diesel requires less crude oil per litre than petrol does to produce, newly established standards for lower sulphur diesel require a more complex refining process.

Despite these reductions in sulphur emissions, standard diesel fuel is still taxed more heavily than petrol. In 1994, duty on diesel and unleaded petrol (ULP) was the same, however from 1996 through to 1998 diesel was around a penny per litre more expensive. In 1999 it became three pence per litre. At this stage, ultra low sulphur diesel (ULSD) was introduced into the market and, by 2000 the majority of diesel being sold changed to ULSD. This carries a lower duty rate than standard diesel, and by 2001 the differential between standard diesel and ULSD was up to six pence per litre. However, since 2003 high oil prices have caused the duty on all fuels to rise drastically. In the last 2½ years alone a tripling in oil price has caused the price of fuels to rocket, and it seems to have been the case that diesel users have suffered more than the rest of us. If this were the whole picture though, then fuel would be as expensive everywhere as it is here in the UK. The fact of the matter is that, even with the hike in oil prices, almost three quarters of the petrol station price for any given fuel is government duty. Considering that Britain's motorists buy over 30 billion litres of fuel a year, that's a lot of tax.
And any GCSE Economics student should understand the basics of supply and demand and the impact on prices as a result on the underlying product.

Tax is high, tax has always been high. Despite the calls to spend less, which we are doing, there is also a demand for a perfect NHS, well equipped armed forces, strong infrastructure, low headline income tax rates etc all o fwhich mean that tax revenue is needed.

They aren't all possible.

dingg

4,571 posts

250 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
SILICONEKID346HP said:
They just can`t make up reason to tax you when it`s not true .


Edited by SILICONEKID346HP on Sunday 5th January 19:22
you need to get out more

SILICONEKID346HP

Original Poster:

14,997 posts

262 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
And any GCSE Economics student should understand the basics of supply and demand and the impact on prices as a result on the underlying product.

Tax is high, tax has always been high. Despite the calls to spend less, which we are doing, there is also a demand for a perfect NHS, well equipped armed forces, strong infrastructure, low headline income tax rates etc all o fwhich mean that tax revenue is needed.

They aren't all possible.
Tax is higher on diesel than petrol ,diesel engines are a lot cleaner ,so clean they qualify for zero road tax or the lower tax bands and fuel is a lot cleaner ,a combination of the two has made diesels in line with petrol engines , Tax levy on diesel should be removed in line with petrol ..

Sounds fair to me and is justified .

When you say supply and demand, a lot more diesel can be made from a barrel of crude oil because it takes less processing so why would there be a shortage !




Edited by SILICONEKID346HP on Sunday 5th January 22:16

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
eldar said:
slippery said:
What would you like the Government to tax instead? Obviously the lost revenue would need to be recovered somehow.
Or cut spending a little bit more?
Running the country is a thankless task. I'm glad I don't have to do it.

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
SILICONEKID346HP said:
a lot more diesel can be made from a barrel of crude oil because it takes less processing


Edited by SILICONEKID346HP on Sunday 5th January 22:16
Just nono , you are so far off track with this I'm not going to attempt to correct you cry .

And (to answer a point not quoted above) why should there be a shortage of diesel? Essentially, petrol is essentially a waste product of the refining industry - it only has one use and that is being burnt in car engines. Its basic price (before duties and taxes) is generally much the same through the year as demand is fairly constant over time.

How many uses does diesel have? Basically, one is combustion in road vehicles (arguably fairly constant through the year) and the second is as heating oil (which demand DOES vary throughout the year, being used more in the winter when demand is higher than in the summer when few people use their heating [whether burning oil or anything else] at home or work).

This is basic 'supply and demand' - it's a lot more complicated than this as far as diesel prices go, but we'll start here...

hehe


LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Sunday 5th January 2014
quotequote all
Is the base product supplied to excess or controlled to an extent? Either way it's a moot point, the tax is the key driver of price and this isn't going to suddenly disappear as per the OPs fantasy.