More blood-boiling benefit claimants
More blood-boiling benefit claimants
Author
Discussion

AllTorque

Original Poster:

2,646 posts

300 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all

Look I know it's the Daily Mail, but I've just about had enough of stories like this.

linky

How on earth can it be possible to get away with siring >10 kids and have the taxpayer foot the bill? Can someone also explain to me the techniques for living permanently on the dole? When I was made redundant a while back, the Job Centre made it very clear that they'd stop paying my benefits if I didn't show activity pursuant to getting a job. So what are these guys doing to stay on benefits? Are they just living on the child support or claiming disability or something?

And to then read that the SNP want to remove the benefits cap and increase it just beggars belief. What planet are they on??

dudleybloke

20,553 posts

217 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
AllTorque said:
Look I know it's the Daily Mail, but I've just about had enough of stories like this.

linky

How on earth can it be possible to get away with siring >10 kids and have the taxpayer foot the bill? Can someone also explain to me the techniques for living permanently on the dole? When I was made redundant a while back, the Job Centre made it very clear that they'd stop paying my benefits if I didn't show activity pursuant to getting a job. So what are these guys doing to stay on benefits? Are they just living on the child support or claiming disability or something?

And to then read that the SNP want to remove the benefits cap and increase it just beggars belief. What planet are they on??
Its a piss boiler but the blame lies with the dumb slags that let him spunk up them.


Fluid

1,750 posts

216 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Why the fk is he still getting his housing payed for, with 500k in the bank?

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3025161/Bu...


98elise

32,896 posts

192 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Only JSA needs you to prove that you are looking for work. Once you embark on a career of doing nothing, you work out where all the other benefits come in.

Develop a bad back, get a few of your kids labled as special needs etc and the money comes in.

A member of my family claims everything going. They live 2 streets from me in a nice 3 bed home, with a 3-4 year old car, which they bought new (motability). They haven't worked in 30+ years. Their house has had a new kitchen, bathroom, boiler etc all without lifting a finger.

I've worked all my life and when I bought my current home it was 2 bed. When we started having kids I extended the house myself, while holding down a full time job (no automatic pay rise for workers when you have kids). I fitted the kitchen, and bathrooms myself.

Luckily for me I've done well in the past few years and may be able to retire earlier than expected, maybe late 50's. Its been hard though. I've spent the last 2 years working across the other side of the country, sometimes only getting 4 days at home in a month.

My relative "retired" 30 years ago.

BoRED S2upid

21,144 posts

271 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Stop reading the Daily mail.

AllTorque

Original Poster:

2,646 posts

300 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
BoRED S2upid said:
Stop reading the Daily mail.
Are you denying these things happen and are morally wrong?

BoRED S2upid

21,144 posts

271 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
AllTorque said:
Are you denying these things happen and are morally wrong?
Did I say that?

Your blood pressure will be lower if you stop reading the DM that's all.

Starfighter

5,352 posts

209 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
How hard would it be for there to be a small joint team of HMRC and DWP to look in to these reports and act accordingly?

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

187 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
They clearly employ people at Daily Mail who are close to brain hemmorage from unbridled rage. That was barely hate speech, let alone journalism.

The fact of the matter is we have a system. That system appears to work for the vast majority of people but like every imperfect system, there are ways to exploit it. These people have found a way...typically by having several litters of spawn.

But in reality, is that something we aspire to? All I see from these people is misery. They aren't 'better off' because of this, they are just society's failed examples.

I would predict that a good majority of folks on PH receive benefits in Child Tax Credits or similar...should we throw out the baby with the bath-water because of some bad apples?


Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
How about unemployed people receiving benefits for 6 months and then after that, if they're still unemployed, they get carted off to a power station and used for fuel? Anyone? No? Two birds and all that.

markcoznottz

7,155 posts

255 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Starfighter said:
How hard would it be for there to be a small joint team of HMRC and DWP to look in to these reports and act accordingly?
The dregs of the underclass, totally unemployable, no one knows what to do with them. Tapered CB would help though, they would definately think twice if the third kid had reduced ££££, and so forth on a sliding scale.

justanother5tar

1,314 posts

156 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Rawwr said:
How about unemployed people receiving benefits for 6 months and then after that, if they're still unemployed, they get carted off to a power station and used for fuel? Anyone? No? Two birds and all that.
I think you may be onto something there...



markcoznottz said:
The dregs of the underclass, totally unemployable, no one knows what to do with them. Tapered CB would help though, they would definately think twice if the third kid had reduced ££££, and so forth on a sliding scale.
Sliding scale? fk that. No more money after 2.

red_slr

20,994 posts

220 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Its disability that needs stopping.
The things people claim as disability are just shocking, things you can never prove.
And GPs are happy to go along with it. They are just as bad IMHO.

On top of that there is a whole industry around disability, providing goods and services to the NHS at silly money.
I know someone who had a stair lift put in their house. Never used and just gathers dust. Cost thousands.
The problem was, if they said "no we don't need it" then they get less money... so they go along with it to waste NHS money to ensure their disability payments don't fall.

paulwoof

1,783 posts

186 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
the problem with GP's is similar to whiplash insurance claims, They are not particularly interested in what benefits they may be claiming. Hence why "depression" is the most common affliction in which employment and support allowance ("the sick") is awarded.
If you go to your GP and tell them you feel depressed and describe anxiety, then you will receive your sick note and off to the DWP you go.

Now i am sure there are lots of cases of people with genuine mental health issues preventing them from working but it is the easiest way to get yourself off JSA and the GP's like whiplash claims don't want to say actually you're fine then in a couple months time be put under the microscope for not diagnosing things properly. So if you know what to say and what not to say its not particularly difficult.

My job entails dealing with benefit claimants everyday. When I ask if they have any serious physical or mental health issues, The most common answer i get is "Ive got depression", Not I suffer from depression but "I've got it" like it is caught of a bus seat.

Looking through their benefit history what I usually see is 10+ years of switching from JSA to ESA,
Currently when you claim ESA you are on an assessment phase for 13 weeks in which all you have to provide is the medical certificate from your doctor, With the huge amount of ESA claims currently you would be lucky if you had you're medical assessment within 6 months, So up until then you can carry on claiming ESA, Then inevitably the medical assessment comes around and what usually happens is the "regulars" don't even bother attending and their ESA gets stopped, They then cant claim ESA for another 3 months, So they claim JSA, Then when 3 months is up, They start the cycle again with self assessment then duck out before the medical assessment,
For those that do go to the medical assessment, Most will score 0 or a few points and get told they have no limited capability for work. They then appeal and appeal dragging it on for a few more months before eventually going back to JSA.

The one thing that annoys me is that the majority of people on JSA dont want to be there, They would rather have a job and are actually trying yet they are the ones the DWP hammers the most with sanctions etc. Didnt fill in our complex misleading form perfectly? Sanction, Didn't use our useless jobsearch site on Tuesday evening? Sanction, Yet they leave let the job shy feckless alone as they are to difficult to go after.

This is without starting on the massive expense that is when unemployed chantelle gets knocked up, Then we have another housing cost, Child benefit and tax credit, Maternity Grant etc. Receives Income support till her offspring turns 5, So 5 years in which she is entitled to be a "full time mummy" on facebook.

soad

34,769 posts

207 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Meet Frank...an unemployed, alcoholic womaniser.


wildcat45

8,160 posts

220 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Could the children not be sold to loving childless couples? 25k a kid. Say. Scummer gets maybe 50 quid in Iceland vouchers, the state gets the rest.

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

198 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Why not only get benefits for the first 2 kids and they need the same parents? It would stop all of that.

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
The good thing about all these "blood boiling benefit claimant" articles is that many people reading these articles or frothing at the mouth on internet forums will obviously suffer heart attacks, strokes and other fatal events due to raised blood pressure - thereby relieving financial strain on the health and benefit system.

So, not all bad.

PorkInsider

6,646 posts

172 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
paulwoof said:
This is without starting on the massive expense that is when unemployed chantelle gets knocked up, Then we have another housing cost, Child benefit and tax credit, Maternity Grant etc. Receives Income support till her offspring turns 5, So 5 years in which she is entitled to be a "full time mummy" on facebook.
Yes, but at least after that 5 years is up, the benefits will stop and she will then become a valued member of society, contributing to the prosperity of the country while raising her child to be an upstanding member of the community.

Well, unless she accidentally gets knocked up again just before the child turns 5, but I bet that hardly ever happens...

And of course if the child doesn't turn out to be a pillar of the community with a bright future, that will be society's fault for failing them, not the parents' fault, obviously.

BrabusMog

21,827 posts

217 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
paulwoof said:
the problem with GP's is similar to whiplash insurance claims, They are not particularly interested in what benefits they may be claiming. Hence why "depression" is the most common affliction in which employment and support allowance ("the sick") is awarded.
If you go to your GP and tell them you feel depressed and describe anxiety, then you will receive your sick note and off to the DWP you go.

Now i am sure there are lots of cases of people with genuine mental health issues preventing them from working but it is the easiest way to get yourself off JSA and the GP's like whiplash claims don't want to say actually you're fine then in a couple months time be put under the microscope for not diagnosing things properly. So if you know what to say and what not to say its not particularly difficult.

My job entails dealing with benefit claimants everyday. When I ask if they have any serious physical or mental health issues, The most common answer i get is "Ive got depression", Not I suffer from depression but "I've got it" like it is caught of a bus seat.

Looking through their benefit history what I usually see is 10+ years of switching from JSA to ESA,
Currently when you claim ESA you are on an assessment phase for 13 weeks in which all you have to provide is the medical certificate from your doctor, With the huge amount of ESA claims currently you would be lucky if you had you're medical assessment within 6 months, So up until then you can carry on claiming ESA, Then inevitably the medical assessment comes around and what usually happens is the "regulars" don't even bother attending and their ESA gets stopped, They then cant claim ESA for another 3 months, So they claim JSA, Then when 3 months is up, They start the cycle again with self assessment then duck out before the medical assessment,
For those that do go to the medical assessment, Most will score 0 or a few points and get told they have no limited capability for work. They then appeal and appeal dragging it on for a few more months before eventually going back to JSA.

The one thing that annoys me is that the majority of people on JSA dont want to be there, They would rather have a job and are actually trying yet they are the ones the DWP hammers the most with sanctions etc. Didnt fill in our complex misleading form perfectly? Sanction, Didn't use our useless jobsearch site on Tuesday evening? Sanction, Yet they leave let the job shy feckless alone as they are to difficult to go after.

This is without starting on the massive expense that is when unemployed chantelle gets knocked up, Then we have another housing cost, Child benefit and tax credit, Maternity Grant etc. Receives Income support till her offspring turns 5, So 5 years in which she is entitled to be a "full time mummy" on facebook.
This is possibly one of the most stark and depressing things I have read in my life. I don't have the answers but the system needs a proper shake up, these people are just taking the piss out of us hard working tax payers.