No wonder I am confused (warning, political content)
No wonder I am confused (warning, political content)
Author
Discussion

Jasandjules

Original Poster:

72,694 posts

260 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
Just for fun I did one of those generic "which party should you vote for" type of quizzes.

Now, 76% Tory, 75% UKIP and 73% Labour.

Given my diverse views it is no wonder I am struggling to choose between them, they must have very similar policies..... Odd that three supposedly completely different parties can be so similar is it not!?!?

RobinOakapple

2,802 posts

143 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
Just vote three times. Do you live in Tower Hamlets?

Shuvi McTupya

24,460 posts

278 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
I just did one for the hell of it and chose 'I strongly agree' for every answer and It says I should like conservative and labour equally...

I think we have a one party system..

don4l

10,058 posts

207 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
I don't see a huge difference between Tory and Labour policies, so I can understand those figures.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
I'm neither intelligent enough nor do I have the inclination to read each party's full manifesto and draw logical conclusions as to which is better.

All I can do is judge whether we're better off as we are than we were 5 years ago so with that in mind, I'll vote the same way I did last time as I feel both I and the country is in a better position now.

JustAnotherLogin

1,127 posts

152 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Just for fun I did one of those generic "which party should you vote for" type of quizzes.

Now, 76% Tory, 75% UKIP and 73% Labour.

Given my diverse views it is no wonder I am struggling to choose between them, they must have very similar policies..... Odd that three supposedly completely different parties can be so similar is it not!?!?
Or more likely: that quix, like all of its ilk, is just crap

brenflys777

2,680 posts

208 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
It's still less confusing than some of the politicians themselves.

Ed M lives in a house worth in excess of £2M. The tax he proposes to introduce on properties valued over £2M is called a 'mansion' tax by him, but he also says he doesn't live in a mansion.


Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
don4l said:
I don't see a huge difference between Tory and Labour policies, so I can understand those figures.
Oh you are mistaken - there is a gulf this time it's a stark economic choice
Previously yes it's been pretty similar not so now.


Which is great for choice - sadly it's clear you and potentially millions of others don't realise it.

Jasandjules

Original Poster:

72,694 posts

260 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
Oh you are mistaken - there is a gulf this time it's a stark economic choice
Well, they both seem keen to cut welfare and borrow plenty.......The main to**ers believe in AGW, well, believe it is a good way to raise taxes at least and control the plebs.. Both tend to be run by rich privately educated people (whose intelligence is in dispute)....

What is this vast gulf of which you speak? The colour of the tie?

gruffalo

8,184 posts

257 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
One of those parties squandered the biggest tax take on record and left a note saying sorry but all the money is gone.

The other is trying to clear that mess up, which would you vote for?

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Welshbeef said:
Oh you are mistaken - there is a gulf this time it's a stark economic choice
Well, they both seem keen to cut welfare and borrow plenty.......The main to**ers believe in AGW, well, believe it is a good way to raise taxes at least and control the plebs.. Both tend to be run by rich privately educated people (whose intelligence is in dispute)....

What is this vast gulf of which you speak? The colour of the tie?
The cuts the Tory's are aiming to do are VASTLY deeper than labour. Put it this way Tory's are aiming to be in surplus by year three Labour are aiming to be "current" budget clear by 2020.

Current excludes capital spend which is about £30billion a year.

So by 2020 the difference in cuts would amount to 90-120billiom different.

SNP want £150-180 billion MORE than current which would be near £400-500billion more than Tory's.

Suggest you actually read the manifestos.

don4l

10,058 posts

207 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
Jasandjules said:
Welshbeef said:
Oh you are mistaken - there is a gulf this time it's a stark economic choice
Well, they both seem keen to cut welfare and borrow plenty.......The main to**ers believe in AGW, well, believe it is a good way to raise taxes at least and control the plebs.. Both tend to be run by rich privately educated people (whose intelligence is in dispute)....

What is this vast gulf of which you speak? The colour of the tie?
The cuts the Tory's are aiming to do are VASTLY deeper than labour. Put it this way Tory's are aiming to be in surplus by year three Labour are aiming to be "current" budget clear by 2020.

Current excludes capital spend which is about £30billion a year.

So by 2020 the difference in cuts would amount to 90-120billiom different.

SNP want £150-180 billion MORE than current which would be near £400-500billion more than Tory's.

Suggest you actually read the manifestos.
Didn't the Tories, in 2010, tell us that they would completely eliminate the deficit by now?

Didn't many of us go into the last election with the impression that we were going to get a referendum on the Lisbon treaty?

Did we expect the foreign aid budget to go up by 50%?

Did we expect to see swingeing cuts to the Police and the Military?

The one thing that he was honest about was that we would all see our energy bills rise by about 6% above inflation, per annum, to fight climate change.

The man is an utterly contemptible moron.





ATG

23,877 posts

303 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
IFS budget projections were quite starkly different. Think the Beeb reported them this morning. All main parties were on a similar trajectory for the first year or two, but thereafter Tory budget discipline (did I spin that a bit? ) will be substantially greater. They are setting themselves much more ambitious targets. The way I see it, all the progressive stuff that makes society worth the name is predicated on a strong economy. If we want to be able to provide universal education, universe health care, a welfare safety net, and the expectation of employment and all the social good that brings ... you have got to have a robust and stable economy.

In my lifetime only one party has come close to delivering that consistently. In his first term Blair did a reasonable job too, but he'd just inherited a recovering economy from Ken Clark and New Labour stuck to the Tories' spending plans for a while ... and then true to form dug us yet another fiscal hole.

When an impartial, qualified observer like the IMF says that UK economic policy has clearly been working, why would we risk upsetting the apple cart by letting Labour get in again?

Jasandjules

Original Poster:

72,694 posts

260 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
ATG said:
When an impartial, qualified observer like the IMF says that UK economic policy has clearly been working, why would we risk upsetting the apple cart by letting Labour get in again?
Well, I see too many reports of poor people having their benefits taken away and killing themselves. I have no doubt that those who are not genuine are still able to milk the system whilst genuinely ill people can't fight it and give up and die/kill themselves etc.

So, cuts are all well and good but I don't see them on golden goodbyes for incompetent council managers, I don't see them on the MP bar bill (why do we subsidise their booze?) or expenses for second homes etc. The NHS waste billions as well yet all talk of simply putting more money in, NOT ensuring it is properly spent.

That is my concern.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
Does anyone seriously think that we're not going to end up with a Labour + SNP government?

I bloody hope not personally, but I'm not sure how it can go any other way?

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
don4l said:
Didn't the Tories, in 2010, tell us that they would completely eliminate the deficit by now?

Didn't many of us go into the last election with the impression that we were going to get a referendum on the Lisbon treaty?

Did we expect the foreign aid budget to go up by 50%?

Did we expect to see swingeing cuts to the Police and the Military?

The one thing that he was honest about was that we would all see our energy bills rise by about 6% above inflation, per annum, to fight climate change.

The man is an utterly contemptible moron.
They did - sadly no one knew (incl labour) about the structural deficit which had existed since 2002 and also the fact that the recession was much deeper than had been reported so it was restated.


Also you remember our trading block the EU? Yep Ireland Portugal Spain Hungary Cyprus and Greece all going pop massively impacting us and our growth. Hard to predict that.

CambsBill

2,481 posts

209 months

Friday 24th April 2015
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
don4l said:
Didn't the Tories, in 2010, tell us that they would completely eliminate the deficit by now?

Didn't many of us go into the last election with the impression that we were going to get a referendum on the Lisbon treaty?

Did we expect the foreign aid budget to go up by 50%?

Did we expect to see swingeing cuts to the Police and the Military?

The one thing that he was honest about was that we would all see our energy bills rise by about 6% above inflation, per annum, to fight climate change.

The man is an utterly contemptible moron.
They did - sadly no one knew (incl labour) about the structural deficit which had existed since 2002 and also the fact that the recession was much deeper than had been reported so it was restated.


Also you remember our trading block the EU? Yep Ireland Portugal Spain Hungary Cyprus and Greece all going pop massively impacting us and our growth. Hard to predict that.
Would that be the Lisbon Treaty that Labour lied about and fudged so that they could deny us the ability to vote on it, unlike many of our European neighbours? The treaty that Brown was so proud to be a part of that he didn't even appear for the grabs signing and instead sneaked in the back door when everyone else had gone? That one?

As for the deficit, my children and yours are still going to be lumbered with paying for Labours PFI splurge, where they gave 'big business' a licence to take vast amounts of our money for decades to come.

I'll say one thing, the current lot have had an extraordinary run of luck on interest rates, which couldn't have been predicted and has kept the interest part of the national spend well below what it might have been. None of the contenders this time round can expect this to continue, so whoever borrows more & cuts less will be costing every one of more in interest during the next parliament.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Saturday 25th April 2015
quotequote all
Labour bang on about the total debt going up by £500billion. Thing is the first year when Tory's took over deficit was £165billlion that was nearly 25% of our total budget at the time they had the emergency budget in Sept the following year the deficit was 145billion so £310billion of the deficit was there before they could really have any impact - then EU issues hit and the overwhelming view in the country by the ouic was don't cut too hard so he eased up the rate of reduction.


This is key just the same as when you look at 1997 &1999 the surplus all driven by the previous govt.

ellroy

7,858 posts

256 months

Saturday 25th April 2015
quotequote all
M
don4l said:
Didn't the Tories, in 2010, tell us that they would completely eliminate the deficit by now?

Didn't many of us go into the last election with the impression that we were going to get a referendum on the Lisbon treaty?

Did we expect the foreign aid budget to go up by 50%?

Did we expect to see swingeing cuts to the Police and the Military?

The one thing that he was honest about was that we would all see our energy bills rise by about 6% above inflation, per annum, to fight climate change.

The man is an utterly contemptible moron.
Did you miss the bit where we were ruled by coalition which included the Lib Dems?