Russia and Ukraine
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

78 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
[redacted]

161BMW

1,823 posts

189 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
It is no coincidenance Russia and China are both trying to test the waters about invading other countries. They cannot be trusted. USA is weak they couldn’t even sort out Afghanistan or the VC in Nam. There are just some countries out there with bad intentions so want to try to invade other countries.

DuncsGTi

1,172 posts

203 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
Sounds like a perfect time to be cutting back on the armoured component of our military

Gameface

16,565 posts

101 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
161BMW said:
USA is weak they couldn’t even sort out Afghanistan or the VC in Nam.
They certainly made themselves look weak with the Capitol Building riot.

Can you imagine if that was tried at The Kremlin etc?

Misanthrope

613 posts

69 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
Gameface said:
161BMW said:
USA is weak they couldn’t even sort out Afghanistan or the VC in Nam.
They certainly made themselves look weak with the Capitol Building riot.

Can you imagine if that was tried at The Kremlin?
Can you imagine the Western media reaction (and the reaction of many on here) if it was and the demonstrators/rioters/freedom fighters, whatever you want to call them, were vigorously repelled?

Gameface

16,565 posts

101 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
Can't imagine too many level headed people would listen to those criticising a government defending a government building from being stormed/overrun and police being killed.

GliderRider

2,855 posts

105 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
Gameface said:
They certainly made themselves look weak with the Capitol Building riot.

Can you imagine if that was tried at The Kremlin etc?
Something like this: 1993 Shelling of Russian Parliament building

Bathroom_Security

3,792 posts

141 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
161BMW said:
USA is weak they couldn’t even sort out Afghanistan or the VC in Nam.
I don't think that's entirely fair

Neither did the Soviet Union when they invaded Afghanistan

Same with the British Red Coats when they invaded

161BMW

1,823 posts

189 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
Soviet Union and China are well known for copying the West generally.

nikaiyo2

5,786 posts

219 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
161BMW said:
It is no coincidenance Russia and China are both trying to test the waters about invading other countries. They cannot be trusted. USA is weak they couldn’t even sort out Afghanistan or the VC in Nam. There are just some countries out there with bad intentions so want to try to invade other countries.
In all fairness the US never really tried to sort out the VC (and China and USSR) they set themselves up to loose from the inception of MACV. For instance they mined Haiphong harbour in 1972 not before. Deploying fighters designed to engage at long range then preventing them from engaging BVR so forcing them to engage in manner that exploited their weaknesses and played to the oppositions strength.

It’s also worth noting that the Chinese tried to “sort out” the Vietnamese after the Americans and failed. When they tried to prevent interference with that lovely socialist Pol Pot.

glazbagun

15,172 posts

221 months

Wednesday 21st April 2021
quotequote all
161BMW said:
It is no coincidenance Russia and China are both trying to test the waters about invading other countries. They cannot be trusted. USA is weak they couldn’t even sort out Afghanistan or the VC in Nam. There are just some countries out there with bad intentions so want to try to invade other countries.
yes Pre-Iraq when we still had some appetite for militarily sorting out other countries this might have been madness.

But we watched as the Arab Spring was crushed and did nothing, watched as the Kurds were crushed (again) and did nothing, accuse China of crimes against humanity whilst begging for market access and do nothing when they crush democracy in Hong Kong.

I fear the Ukrainians are going to find our support as strong as the Poles did in the forties.

garagewidow

1,502 posts

194 months

Thursday 22nd April 2021
quotequote all
Has Putin got an election on the horizon?

The east and the west know it can only be seen as sabre rattling,any inference of war would be disastrous,but who blinks first?

RichFN2

4,204 posts

203 months

Thursday 22nd April 2021
quotequote all
garagewidow said:
Has Putin got an election on the horizon?

The east and the west know it can only be seen as sabre rattling,any inference of war would be disastrous,but who blinks first?
yes September it looks like, last time Putins ratings were boosted when he sent troops in to help those in Ukraine who want to be part of Russia.

I had read that since 2014 the Russian language is far less popular in some parts of western Ukraine and Kyiv, and Ukrainian is the dominant language with Kyiv now the official spelling rather than Kiev. The anti Russia feeling has also grown since 2014 and you wonder if Putin might be nervous of another attempt for Ukraine to join NATO & EU which is what caused things to kick off back in 2014

Dagnir

2,116 posts

187 months

Thursday 22nd April 2021
quotequote all
RichFN2 said:
yes September it looks like, last time Putins ratings were boosted when he sent troops in to help those in Ukraine who want to be part of Russia.

I had read that since 2014 the Russian language is far less popular in some parts of western Ukraine and Kyiv, and Ukrainian is the dominant language with Kyiv now the official spelling rather than Kiev. The anti Russia feeling has also grown since 2014 and you wonder if Putin might be nervous of another attempt for Ukraine to join NATO & EU which is what caused things to kick off back in 2014
Literally the rhetoric that started WWII, so let's hope the Russian people aren’t so gullible this time.

Earthdweller

17,969 posts

150 months

Thursday 22nd April 2021
quotequote all
Dagnir said:
Literally the rhetoric that started WWII, so let's hope the Russian people aren’t so gullible this time.
Was it ?

WW2 was going Almost 2.5 years before Russia became involved

CarlosFandango11

1,986 posts

210 months

Thursday 22nd April 2021
quotequote all
Earthdweller said:
Dagnir said:
Literally the rhetoric that started WWII, so let's hope the Russian people aren’t so gullible this time.
Was it ?

WW2 was going Almost 2.5 years before Russia became involved
You’re forgetting about Russia invading Poland at the start.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

78 months

Thursday 22nd April 2021
quotequote all
CarlosFandango11 said:
You’re forgetting about Russia invading Poland at the start.
Quite. And sections of the Polish population feeling at home with Germany and others with Russia.

Byker28i

84,918 posts

241 months

Thursday 22nd April 2021
quotequote all
CarlosFandango11 said:
You’re forgetting about Russia invading Poland at the start.
The Soviet invasion of Poland was a military operation by the Soviet Union without a formal declaration of war. On 17 September 1939, the Soviet Union invaded Poland from the east, sixteen days after Germany invaded Poland from the west.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_invasion_of_P...

Earthdweller

17,969 posts

150 months

Thursday 22nd April 2021
quotequote all
CarlosFandango11 said:
Earthdweller said:
Dagnir said:
Literally the rhetoric that started WWII, so let's hope the Russian people aren’t so gullible this time.
Was it ?

WW2 was going Almost 2.5 years before Russia became involved
You’re forgetting about Russia invading Poland at the start.
Id still argue the annexation of eastern Poland in ‘39 wasn’t Russia joining WW2 as a combatant

The non aggression pact with Germany meant they stayed on the sidelines until Barbarossa in June 41


928 GTS

571 posts

119 months

Thursday 22nd April 2021
quotequote all
Earthdweller said:
Id still argue the annexation of eastern Poland in ‘39 wasn’t Russia joining WW2 as a combatant
You can argue it if you want to be a moron. If Poland is not good enough for you how about Winter war against Finland in 1939-40. They started it after secret agreement with Hitler how to split Europe.