Train Driver's Pay
Author
Discussion

Pitre

Original Poster:

5,539 posts

254 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Very simple question (and probably dim, so please forgive me in advance)....

Why does the government get involved in setting train driver's salary discussions?

The railways have been privatised, so why isn't the train driver's salary set at a commercial rate by the private company that they work for?

Countdown

46,258 posts

216 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
AIUI since COVID theyve effectively been nationalised.

bad company

21,166 posts

286 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Loved this.


dave123456

3,674 posts

167 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Don’t start this one… there’s a poster on the labour thread who’s ever so defensive about train drivers pay..

valiant

12,895 posts

180 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Nope, just happy to correct some of the bks spouted (some by you I believe).

smile

dave123456

3,674 posts

167 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
valiant said:
Nope, just happy to correct some of the bks spouted (some by you I believe).

smile
A different opinion does not make for bks.

Keep correcting everyone big boy

valiant

12,895 posts

180 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
dave123456 said:
valiant said:
Nope, just happy to correct some of the bks spouted (some by you I believe).

smile
A different opinion does not make for bks.

Keep correcting everyone big boy
Keep posting bks then Mr Executive.

scenario8

7,458 posts

199 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
You could retrain your thoughts to answering the OP’s query, perhaps?

alangla

6,013 posts

201 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Pitre said:
Very simple question (and probably dim, so please forgive me in advance)....

Why does the government get involved in setting train driver's salary discussions?

The railways have been privatised, so why isn't the train driver's salary set at a commercial rate by the private company that they work for?
That’s how they got as high as they are: it takes a year or more to train a new driver, so it’s a fairly restricted skill. Other companies don’t want to wait a year and have to pay a driving instructor for all that time, so poach other drivers by throwing cash at them, pay escalates right through from the late 90s to the 2010s. ASLEF also played a blinder playing the privatised rail companies against each other.

Pitre

Original Poster:

5,539 posts

254 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Yes, but.... Why do the government get involved in the negotiations now?

(sigh)

Edited by Pitre on Tuesday 10th September 17:33

Oliver Hardy

3,096 posts

94 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Countdown said:
AIUI since COVID theyve effectively been nationalised.
I have been wondering this too, will the government now increase the money it gives to the railways?

Haven't the bosses accepted a 4% increase, which is similar to the train drivers?



dave123456

3,674 posts

167 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
valiant said:
dave123456 said:
valiant said:
Nope, just happy to correct some of the bks spouted (some by you I believe).

smile
A different opinion does not make for bks.

Keep correcting everyone big boy
Keep posting bks then Mr Executive.
Oh dear…

Tommo87

5,316 posts

133 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
dave123456 said:
Don’t start this one… there’s a poster on the labour thread who’s ever so defensive about train drivers pay..
He sounds like a right knob head.

anonymous-user

74 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
The privatised train operators are now paid a set fee to operate services under contract to the DfT; the DfT keep the ticket revenue and the private operators are paid the same fees regardless. Every additional cost incurred has to be approved and effectively ultimately met by the DfT, including pay rises.

Stedman

7,352 posts

212 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Tommo87 said:
dave123456 said:
Don’t start this one… there’s a poster on the labour thread who’s ever so defensive about train drivers pay..
He sounds like a right knob head.
Or left.

Super Sonic

11,275 posts

74 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
To end the dispute and stop the strikes and disruption.

itcaptainslow

4,352 posts

156 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Pitre said:
Very simple question (and probably dim, so please forgive me in advance)....

Why does the government get involved in setting train driver's salary discussions?

The railways have been privatised, so why isn't the train driver's salary set at a commercial rate by the private company that they work for?
To answer the OP’s question smile

During COVID, the train operating company contracts were effectively transformed into management contracts, where the TOC was paid a fixed fee to run the service, and the government assumed the financial risk (but also took the revenue). This had happened previously with some under performing TOC’s, notably GNER.

Therefore, any expenditure had to be signed off by the DfT, hence the government being involved in the dispute and involved (well, not involved, as the case of the previous Tory government, who made an offer designed not to be accepted then stonewalled for a good 18 months) in pay negotiations.

Jasandjules

71,629 posts

249 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
valiant said:
Nope, just happy to correct some of the bks spouted (some by you I believe).

smile
What train do you drive?

The Leaper

5,437 posts

226 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
81 year old OAP here.

I am sure the train drivers will enjoy their newly negotiated wage increase of £5000pa while I have had no say in losing my WFA of £300. I'm am encouraged to use my travel pass to get on a train this winter for several hours a day so I can keep moderately warm. How ironic to see all their friendly Labour MPs voting on clearly a major social matter so that me and a few million other OAPs may well freeze this winter.


119

15,500 posts

56 months

Tuesday 10th September 2024
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
valiant said:
Nope, just happy to correct some of the bks spouted (some by you I believe).

smile
What train do you drive?
Noddys