British Summer Time. Again

Poll: British Summer Time. Again

Total Members Polled: 240

Add an hour and stay there permanently : 33%
Why the hell do we do this twice a year!: 29%
Add two hours and stay there permanently : 8%
I think it's fine as it is going forward/back: 30%
Author
Discussion

Pitre

Original Poster:

5,788 posts

257 months

Yesterday (13:05)
quotequote all
No justifications needed.

Personally I think we should add two hours, permanently. Anyone who doesn't like it can buy a torch!

Scotty2

1,428 posts

289 months

Yesterday (14:00)
quotequote all
Add 1/2 hr including Europe, then leave it. Best of both worlds?

No ideas for a name

2,991 posts

109 months

Yesterday (14:03)
quotequote all
Why no vote for leave it at GMT all year.
We are on the Meridian, its is GMT all year, why add an hour?


cliffords

3,650 posts

46 months

Yesterday (14:03)
quotequote all
I think we should add 1 hour and 21 mins and not move it again.

Panamax

8,311 posts

57 months

Yesterday (14:09)
quotequote all
QUESTION: Why do clocks change more or less ON the spring equinox but then stay on summer time until a month AFTER the autumn equinox - i.e. 5 months of winter time and 7 months of summer time?

It would IMO make massively more sense for clocks to change at the end of February, balancing up the daylight hours.

Panamax

8,311 posts

57 months

Yesterday (14:14)
quotequote all
Factoid. What's "Mean" about Greenwich Mean Time?

Earth’s orbit is not a perfect circle and its axis is tilted, so time measured by a sundial varies slightly throughout the year and days aren't all exactly 24 hours. "Mean" time is a calculated average of solar time, allowing clocks to keep the same time every day.

JoshSm

3,639 posts

60 months

Yesterday (14:18)
quotequote all
No ideas for a name said:
Why no vote for leave it at GMT all year.
We are on the Meridian, its is GMT all year, why add an hour?
Apparently stupid people either want to live in a different timezone or can't cope with sticking with GMT and just shifting when they do things.

The UK is physically located at GMT, and mostly located west of the meridian, yet some apparently want to join a more southern part of Europe in pretending they're in Paris as some sort of solidarity?

What kind of idiots are so beholden to what the clock says that they can't just shift their schedule if they need to instead of pretending by changing the clock?

Panamax

8,311 posts

57 months

Yesterday (14:19)
quotequote all
cliffords said:
I think we should add 1 hour and 21 mins and not move it again.
Go to India, they run with time 30 minutes offset from most other places. Bizarrely, local time is best converted to UK time by wearing a rotary dial watch upside down. Because India is exactly 5 hours and 30 minutes ahead of GMT, flipping the watch 180° reorients the hour and minute hands to roughly display the corresponding time in London.

Bill

57,360 posts

278 months

Yesterday (14:27)
quotequote all
No ideas for a name said:
Why no vote for leave it at GMT all year.
We are on the Meridian, its is GMT all year, why add an hour?
2nd option, no??

Panamax

8,311 posts

57 months

Yesterday (14:28)
quotequote all
JoshSm said:
The UK is physically located at GMT, and mostly located west of the meridian, yet some apparently want to join a more southern part of Europe in pretending they're in Paris as some sort of solidarity?
Check out Portugal - same time as UK.

The Irish, of course, call theirs Irish Standard Time and Irish Summer Time. Cross the border from Northern Ireland and the name changes but the time doesn't. Brilliant.

JoshSm

3,639 posts

60 months

Yesterday (14:42)
quotequote all
Panamax said:
JoshSm said:
The UK is physically located at GMT, and mostly located west of the meridian, yet some apparently want to join a more southern part of Europe in pretending they're in Paris as some sort of solidarity?
Check out Portugal - same time as UK.

The Irish, of course, call theirs Irish Standard Time and Irish Summer Time. Cross the border from Northern Ireland and the name changes but the time doesn't. Brilliant.
Spain, GMT+1 (aka Central European Standard Time) yet definitely not in that zone. Guess the Portuguese being even further west just couldn't (or wouldn't) pretend that much.

jmn

1,125 posts

303 months

Yesterday (16:07)
quotequote all
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&amp...

There have been attempts to do away with it in the past.

ExBoringVolvoDriver

11,336 posts

66 months

Yesterday (16:17)
quotequote all
Panamax said:
JoshSm said:
The UK is physically located at GMT, and mostly located west of the meridian, yet some apparently want to join a more southern part of Europe in pretending they're in Paris as some sort of solidarity?
Check out Portugal - same time as UK.

The Irish, of course, call theirs Irish Standard Time and Irish Summer Time. Cross the border from Northern Ireland and the name changes but the time doesn't. Brilliant.
Arguably Spain should be on GMT given where the Meridian line passes through and possibly Paris as well!

Smollet

15,372 posts

213 months

Yesterday (16:22)
quotequote all
jmn said:
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&amp...

There have been attempts to do away with it in the past.
And dropped fairly quickly. Leave it be.

Snow and Rocks

3,107 posts

50 months

Yesterday (18:12)
quotequote all
JoshSm said:
Apparently stupid people either want to live in a different timezone or can't cope with sticking with GMT and just shifting when they do things.

The UK is physically located at GMT, and mostly located west of the meridian, yet some apparently want to join a more southern part of Europe in pretending they're in Paris as some sort of solidarity?

What kind of idiots are so beholden to what the clock says that they can't just shift their schedule if they need to instead of pretending by changing the clock?
I think describing most people with a job as idiots is a bit much maybe?

Thankfully, I'm free to organise my day as I please but when I was office based and had to stick to office hours it was always great to suddenly have the ability to do things in daylight after work.

Not sure what being being able to go out on my bike or walk the dog without a head torch has to do with pretending I'm in Paris either.

gregs656

12,121 posts

204 months

Yesterday (18:46)
quotequote all
No ideas for a name said:
Why no vote for leave it at GMT all year.
We are on the Meridian, its is GMT all year, why add an hour?
Standardised time zones are a man made concept created to serve our needs.

Daylight savings time is the same deal.

What ever comes next (assuming it does change at some point) will be the same.

Downward

5,376 posts

126 months

Yesterday (18:51)
quotequote all
Scotland and the mornings not being light till after school opens are the issue

CoolHands

22,309 posts

218 months

Yesterday (19:18)
quotequote all
I like having it change.

Bill

57,360 posts

278 months

Yesterday (19:51)
quotequote all
gregs656 said:
Standardised time zones are a man made concept created to serve our needs.

Daylight savings time is the same deal.

What ever comes next (assuming it does change at some point) will be the same.
Originally the railway's need AIUI. Standardised time helps the world function. BST, not so much.

768

19,144 posts

119 months

Yesterday (19:52)
quotequote all
No ideas for a name said:
Why no vote for leave it at GMT all year.
We are on the Meridian, its is GMT all year, why add an hour?
We should move GMT by 27 minutes and tell everyone else to sort themselves out.