This is a modern world
Author
Discussion

Huntsman

Original Poster:

9,466 posts

281 months

Saturday
quotequote all
What kind of fool do you think I am?

It strikes me that we've become awfully reliant on some very fragile technology and ever more complex systems.

Do we need to unravel it a bit?


StevieBee

15,511 posts

286 months

Saturday
quotequote all
How often does something happen, though?

We are clearly reliant upon a very small number of critical systems but that has come about because those systems have proven themselves to be robust and reliable.

Nothing can ever be failsafe and yesterday was what, the second time in recent years where a global outage occurred? I'd say that is pretty remarkable given the scale and complexity involved.

redrabbit29

2,968 posts

164 months

Saturday
quotequote all
I'm getting a bit sick of the media narrative and meaningless comment about how reliant we are on fragile technology. It's not "very fragile". It's absolutely fking epic on the whole and extremely reliable

Even Amazon's own reliability for data storage is 99.999999999% (yes that's specific, and is called "the eleven 9s"). Microsoft have some services with a reliability of sixteen 9s. So written out that is: 99.99999999999999% reliability.

Think about how much technology we rely on every single day, and how much of it just works. Every second of every day, billions of transactions, communications, data transfers, cloud services, banking systems, infrastructure etc etc. All happening pretty much seamlessly

We jump on Teams, send emails, access systems hosted halfway around the world, move money, stream content, use GPS and expect all of it to work instantly.

But the minute there's an outage somewhere, suddenly it's a story about how we've become dangerously reliant on fragile technology

Have people actually stopped to think about the sheer scale and complexity of what we're talking about? The fact that this stuff works as reliably as it does is nothing short of incredible

Of course things fail. Hardware breaks, software has bugs, people make mistakes. That's the reality of operating technology at this scale

..

People conflate failures with single companies or infrastructure with others and start linking them together. There are increasing threats, primarily AI-assisted or ai-lead attacks, but that isn't about the reliability aspect necessary.

It's more about single companies like a retailer, or something.

Monkeylegend

29,590 posts

262 months

Saturday
quotequote all
Thankfully we don't get that many Friday the 13ths.

Disastrous

10,218 posts

248 months

Saturday
quotequote all
redrabbit29 said:
I'm getting a bit sick of the media narrative and meaningless comment about how reliant we are on fragile technology. It's not "very fragile". It's absolutely fking epic on the whole and extremely reliable

Even Amazon's own reliability for data storage is 99.999999999% (yes that's specific, and is called "the eleven 9s"). Microsoft have some services with a reliability of sixteen 9s. So written out that is: 99.99999999999999% reliability.

Think about how much technology we rely on every single day, and how much of it just works. Every second of every day, billions of transactions, communications, data transfers, cloud services, banking systems, infrastructure etc etc. All happening pretty much seamlessly

We jump on Teams, send emails, access systems hosted halfway around the world, move money, stream content, use GPS and expect all of it to work instantly.

But the minute there's an outage somewhere, suddenly it's a story about how we've become dangerously reliant on fragile technology

Have people actually stopped to think about the sheer scale and complexity of what we're talking about? The fact that this stuff works as reliably as it does is nothing short of incredible

Of course things fail. Hardware breaks, software has bugs, people make mistakes. That's the reality of operating technology at this scale

..

People conflate failures with single companies or infrastructure with others and start linking them together. There are increasing threats, primarily AI-assisted or ai-lead attacks, but that isn't about the reliability aspect necessary.

It's more about single companies like a retailer, or something.
Whilst you’re not wrong, I think you’re looking at it from a techno-centric position.

You don’t have to rewind the clock very far to get to a place where ‘we’ felt in control of technology. We could (more or less) mend things ourselves, revert to pen and paper (or cash) for transactions etc etc.

What people are feeling now is scared because we are so reliant on very complex technology that is so far beyond the realms of normal people to be able to manage if something goes wrong. Can’t even do routine maintenance on a car now without a laptop.

It’s really just a sense of alienation and I expect most people don’t know why they feel like that. It’s the same reason that people often feel uneasy about medical procedures. That’s been a sphere where for a long time we’ve been utterly dependent on technology and skilled operators. I don’t think humans are really meant to be passive passengers.

As I say, you’re correct, but I think the feeling is understandable.

snuffy

13,477 posts

315 months

Saturday
quotequote all
Huntsman said:
What kind of fool do you think I am?

It strikes me that we've become awfully reliant on some very fragile technology and ever more complex systems.

Do we need to unravel it a bit?
Very fragile?

Stuff like Outllok has been running for years, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, serving millions of accounts all at the same time, and it goes down for the first time that I can remember, and that makes it "fragile".

butchstewie

68,490 posts

241 months

Saturday
quotequote all
I do also think sometimes people need a bit of a reality check around what they pay for this stuff.

You pay someone tens of thousands a year then make their role very heavily - almost totally - dependent on something they're paying a quid a day for.

MCBrowncoat

1,792 posts

177 months

Saturday
quotequote all
snuffy said:
Huntsman said:
What kind of fool do you think I am?

It strikes me that we've become awfully reliant on some very fragile technology and ever more complex systems.

Do we need to unravel it a bit?
Very fragile?

Stuff like Outllok has been running for years, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, serving millions of accounts all at the same time, and it goes down for the first time that I can remember, and that makes it "fragile".
And what would the option be without it? Actual fking mail?

Yes, it's very robust

dontlookdown

2,566 posts

124 months

Saturday
quotequote all
The tech is incredibly robust and reliable. It is also completely ubiquitous.

Even the most reliable system will still suffer failures. And when they happen the consequences are severe and widespread because of the ubiquity, as has been demonstrated in the last two days.

It does seem to me that greater priority could be given by the tech cos and their customers into how to mitigate the impact of outages when they do happen.

General approach historically seems to have been 'try and make sure they never do' which is only ok up to a point.

vixen1700

29,369 posts

301 months

Saturday
quotequote all
I do get where the OP comes from and also have a 'fear' of cyber attacks on say the banking system together with the internet and email.

What if it was so severe it lasted a week? Or two weeks? A month?


snuffy

13,477 posts

315 months

Saturday
quotequote all
MCBrowncoat said:
snuffy said:
Huntsman said:
What kind of fool do you think I am?

It strikes me that we've become awfully reliant on some very fragile technology and ever more complex systems.

Do we need to unravel it a bit?
Very fragile?

Stuff like Outllok has been running for years, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, serving millions of accounts all at the same time, and it goes down for the first time that I can remember, and that makes it "fragile".
And what would the option be without it? Actual fking mail?

Yes, it's very robust
Yep, the NHS, for example, should go back to using 100% communication to patients using the Royal Mail. Becasue, indeed, that is 100% reliable.


swisstoni

24,239 posts

310 months

Saturday
quotequote all
I think AI has really rendered all those 99.9999 ..... percent availability stats a matter for history. From the pre AI world.

We will have to see how reliable things are going forward.

Randy Winkman

22,799 posts

220 months

Saturday
quotequote all
I think lots of people are wondering about how anyone can hack into supermarket freezers and turn the temperature up to silly levels.

Getragdogleg

10,311 posts

214 months

Saturday
quotequote all
There are ancient legacy systems in place in all sorts of obscure places with only a handful of people who know how they work. This is becoming more of a problem as time goes by.

Some large companies and government organisations around the world still use floppy disks, others rely on fax machines.

Some support techs are having to buy vintage parts from ebay to keep these legacy systems going.

The whole thing is a massive patchwork quilt and adding new things to the top of the pile can break old stuff.

This is the reality.

butchstewie

68,490 posts

241 months

Saturday
quotequote all
Randy Winkman said:
I think lots of people are wondering about how anyone can hack into supermarket freezers and turn the temperature up to silly levels.
I don't know if the full detail on what happened there has been made public but sometimes the issue isn't the technology it's the way it's been configured.

I'd be reasonably confident those freezers could have been configured in a way that what happened couldn't have happened.

I'm not trying to nitpick it's just sometimes a story is reported as "freezers hacked who on earth needs internet connected freezers" rather than "who the hell decided to make them accessible directly over the Internet" - if that was what happened.

Getragdogleg

10,311 posts

214 months

Saturday
quotequote all
butchstewie said:
Randy Winkman said:
I think lots of people are wondering about how anyone can hack into supermarket freezers and turn the temperature up to silly levels.
I don't know if the full detail on what happened there has been made public but sometimes the issue isn't the technology it's the way it's been configured.

I'd be reasonably confident those freezers could have been configured in a way that what happened couldn't have happened.

I'm not trying to nitpick it's just sometimes a story is reported as "freezers hacked who on earth needs internet connected freezers" rather than "who the hell decided to make them accessible directly over the Internet" - if that was what happened.
Much like exploding pagers nobody expected anyone to weaponise fridges.


OutInTheShed

14,936 posts

57 months

Saturday
quotequote all
butchstewie said:
I don't know if the full detail on what happened there has been made public but sometimes the issue isn't the technology it's the way it's been configured.

I'd be reasonably confident those freezers could have been configured in a way that what happened couldn't have happened.

I'm not trying to nitpick it's just sometimes a story is reported as "freezers hacked who on earth needs internet connected freezers" rather than "who the hell decided to make them accessible directly over the Internet" - if that was what happened.
I think your distinction between 'the technology' and 'the way it's been configured' may be false.

It's not naughty transistors doing the wrong thing, it's systems evolved from previous stuff that people work on without fully understanding, poor software, poor top level design and management, inadequate corner cutting. Software written by meatware. Tested by seeing how often it goes wrong.
A lot of this stuff is rotten from the first draft of the requirement list.
Hardware is the same, even simple mechanical things are often badly designed and thrown at the market to see if they break.

98elise

32,876 posts

192 months

Saturday
quotequote all
Randy Winkman said:
I think lots of people are wondering about how anyone can hack into supermarket freezers and turn the temperature up to silly levels.
Only people with no understand of technology. Do they not understand that sometimes things get hacked, or that industrial fridge plant is remotely monitored and controlled over the Internet?

Same with most modern buildings. Its unlikely a guy is walking around daily checking pumps, fans an temperatures. It will be run by a building management system which may be managed remotely. There will still be a maintenance team but smaller (or more mobile) than it used to be.


Edited by 98elise on Saturday 14th November 11:01

butchstewie

68,490 posts

241 months

Saturday
quotequote all
OutInTheShed said:
I think your distinction between 'the technology' and 'the way it's been configured' may be false.

It's not naughty transistors doing the wrong thing, it's systems evolved from previous stuff that people work on without fully understanding, poor software, poor top level design and management, inadequate corner cutting. Software written by meatware. Tested by seeing how often it goes wrong.
A lot of this stuff is rotten from the first draft of the requirement list.
Hardware is the same, even simple mechanical things are often badly designed and thrown at the market to see if they break.
I think in the case of the hacked freezers (the one I was referring to in that post) from a quick read it was down to what I said.

It doesn’t read like there was any complicated "hack".

It reads like it was down to the devices being directly accessible from the Internet - often with default passwords.

Throw in end-of-life firmware - and some of that setup apparently being the manufacturer’s own recommendation - and you’re asking for trouble.

But to me that isn’t the technology failing - it’s people deciding that recommending or doing that was a good idea when it’s actually absolutely bonkers.

swisstoni

24,239 posts

310 months

Saturday
quotequote all
Devices with the default password still set should refuse to operate without a change.