Obama's thoughts on Islam?
Author
Discussion

Tafia

Original Poster:

2,658 posts

265 months

KB_S1

5,967 posts

246 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
Some pretty heavy editing going on there!

davido140

9,614 posts

243 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
So, if he is, what does that mean?

I'm assuming a Muslim can still be president in the US (religion and state are supposed to be separate or something along those lines).






off_again

13,917 posts

251 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
Oh dear, some people clearly think that its wrong to be a Muslim or to have a president who might be a Muslim. How bizarre. To be honest, who cares if he is or not - does it matter? Surely what matters most is if he is a good president or not - if he's crap then get him out. If he's good then great. Since when did religion matter that much?

ivanj

203 posts

241 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
^^^^ I assume you've never been to Tennessee.

Tafia

Original Poster:

2,658 posts

265 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
off_again said:
Oh dear, some people clearly think that its wrong to be a Muslim or to have a president who might be a Muslim. How bizarre. To be honest, who cares if he is or not - does it matter? Surely what matters most is if he is a good president or not - if he's crap then get him out. If he's good then great. Since when did religion matter that much?
Read the Quoran?

Bill

56,078 posts

272 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
KB_S1 said:
Some pretty heavy editing going on there!
yesWith that amount of editing you could make anyone say pretty much anything.

Chris71

21,548 posts

259 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
ivanj said:
^^^^ I assume you've never been to Tennessee.
Sad but true. Christian fundamentalists are quite a scary lot and - if Louis Theroux is to be believed - the southern states are swarming with them.

Have to say virtually all the Americans I've actually met have been interesting, intelligent, cultured people, however George Bush can't have been alone. Someone must have voted him in, in between sitting on their porch playing the banjo and plotting the demise of the New World Order.

ewenm

28,506 posts

262 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
Tafia said:
off_again said:
Oh dear, some people clearly think that its wrong to be a Muslim or to have a president who might be a Muslim. How bizarre. To be honest, who cares if he is or not - does it matter? Surely what matters most is if he is a good president or not - if he's crap then get him out. If he's good then great. Since when did religion matter that much?
Read the Quoran?
Read the Bible?

Anyone who takes either of those as a set of instructions rather than a set of fables is a fool. The majority of Muslims and Christians interpret the message of their chosen holy book for modern times.

WorAl

10,877 posts

205 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
ewenm said:
Tafia said:
off_again said:
Oh dear, some people clearly think that its wrong to be a Muslim or to have a president who might be a Muslim. How bizarre. To be honest, who cares if he is or not - does it matter? Surely what matters most is if he is a good president or not - if he's crap then get him out. If he's good then great. Since when did religion matter that much?
Read the Quoran?
Read the Bible?

Anyone who takes either of those as a set of instructions rather than a set of fables is a fool. The majority of Muslims and Christians are fking idiots, in fact most "believers" fall into that category.
EFA

Frankeh

12,558 posts

202 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
I don't trust anyone who thinks you go to a better place when you die.
What reason do they have to live?

Poledriver

29,179 posts

211 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
Frankeh said:
I don't trust anyone who thinks you go to a better place when you die.
What reason do they have to live?
The "nail-head" interface is strong in this one!

AndrewW-G

11,968 posts

234 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
Give me a packet of Doritos, a few cans of diet coke, the raw film footage and a few hours and I could "prove" that Obama is a Martian far more believably than this clip proves his an islamist. George Bush(jnr) listed Star Wars as one of his favourite films, it doesn’t make him a Jedi or a Sith

As long as a the “teachings” of somebody’s imaginary friend, don’t interfere with their ability to do the job, I have no problem with any person of any faith holding a position of power, provided that they have been democratically elected.

G_T

16,163 posts

207 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
AndrewW-G said:
As long as a the “teachings” of somebody’s imaginary friend, don’t interfere with their ability to do the job, I have no problem with any person of any faith holding a position of power, provided that they have been democratically elected.
I think the bottom line is though that somebody who believes in a higher power will always (in theory) answer them before the people that democratically elected them.

Isn't that why you can't be catholic and prime minister? Because your allegiance would always lie with the vatican before Britaim?

nonegreen

7,803 posts

287 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
G_T said:
AndrewW-G said:
As long as a the “teachings” of somebody’s imaginary friend, don’t interfere with their ability to do the job, I have no problem with any person of any faith holding a position of power, provided that they have been democratically elected.
I think the bottom line is though that somebody who believes in a higher power will always (in theory) answer them before the people that democratically elected them.

Isn't that why you can't be catholic and prime minister? Because your allegiance would always lie with the vatican before Britaim?
The important issue is what is the cutting edge of critical thinking? Provided the US is managed by advisors who have large brains and at worst believe in a supreme being that created the universe and no more. The it really does not matter which poorly head is in the whitehouse. Obviously if regular prayers and other psychotic behaviour are regular occurences among the ruling team then we are deep pooh and we need to go nuclear to sort it.

G_T

16,163 posts

207 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
nonegreen said:
G_T said:
AndrewW-G said:
As long as a the “teachings” of somebody’s imaginary friend, don’t interfere with their ability to do the job, I have no problem with any person of any faith holding a position of power, provided that they have been democratically elected.
I think the bottom line is though that somebody who believes in a higher power will always (in theory) answer them before the people that democratically elected them.

Isn't that why you can't be catholic and prime minister? Because your allegiance would always lie with the vatican before Britaim?
The important issue is what is the cutting edge of critical thinking? Provided the US is managed by advisors who have large brains and at worst believe in a supreme being that created the universe and no more. The it really does not matter which poorly head is in the whitehouse. Obviously if regular prayers and other psychotic behaviour are regular occurences among the ruling team then we are deep pooh and we need to go nuclear to sort it.
I'd agree with that actually. A bright person would tend to compartmentalise their beliefs anyway so it would be unlikely to influence their decisions too much.

My biggest concern would be them buckling to similar minded religious group's agendas. Things like abortion laws and stem cell research were heavily influenced by those lobbyist groups despite them making up a minority of people.


WorAl

10,877 posts

205 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
G_T said:
nonegreen said:
G_T said:
AndrewW-G said:
As long as a the “teachings” of somebody’s imaginary friend, don’t interfere with their ability to do the job, I have no problem with any person of any faith holding a position of power, provided that they have been democratically elected.
I think the bottom line is though that somebody who believes in a higher power will always (in theory) answer them before the people that democratically elected them.

Isn't that why you can't be catholic and prime minister? Because your allegiance would always lie with the vatican before Britaim?
The important issue is what is the cutting edge of critical thinking? Provided the US is managed by advisors who have large brains and at worst believe in a supreme being that created the universe and no more. The it really does not matter which poorly head is in the whitehouse. Obviously if regular prayers and other psychotic behaviour are regular occurences among the ruling team then we are deep pooh and we need to go nuclear to sort it.
I'd agree with that actually. A bright person would tend to compartmentalise their beliefs anyway so it would be unlikely to influence their decisions too much.
But we're talking about Mercins here, so, we're fked.

ErnestM

11,621 posts

284 months

Friday 13th November 2009
quotequote all
Point 1: Obama is a socialist/marxist (never met a government beauraucracy he didn't liked) and so that probably dictates an agnostic spiritual disposition at the least. Obama's religious convictions, like all politicians, stop at the ballot box. I take Obama at face value that he doesn't share Jerimiah Wright's beliefs because, well, he's a politician. A church pew (any church pew), to a politician, contains voters who are used to being told or led in a specific direction.

Point 2: For any of you that have spent more than a year in the "deep South" in the States, you will recognise the role that organised religion (especially Christian based) plays in the scheme of things. It is a social gathering punctuated by gossip with, every now and then, an attempt at instilling a little moral fiber into the younger generation through tales of yore gleaned from "the book" (Bible, Talmud, Qur'an, whatever). Despite what some "journalists" would have one believe, the days of the puritan ethos have moved on. Some of the hottest times I had in my formative years were with the daughter of a Baptist preacher in Montgomery, Alabama (surely the very BUCKLE of the bible belt) Second hottest were with the daughter of a Rabbi, but I digress.

Point 3: For those that are, after reading this, tempted to run out to t'internet and grab the first story of fundamentalist Christian huxterism and assorted festivities, I say to you this: I can open the Daily Mail, Guardian, etc web site and find any number of stories concerning issues with the least common denominator of society in Blighty, but I certainly would't judge every person from the UK (or even a region in the UK) by the standards of Kev and Bianca (or indeed Posh and Becks).

Point 4: I also have the reverse speech for my American colleagues when they point out certain British stereotypes that leave facts at the door.

Cheers

drink
Guinness of course

Edited by ErnestM on Friday 13th November 17:35

Tafia

Original Poster:

2,658 posts

265 months

Saturday 14th November 2009
quotequote all
Bill said:
KB_S1 said:
Some pretty heavy editing going on there!
yesWith that amount of editing you could make anyone say pretty much anything.
Well I didn't see any editing within the phrases, just betwen the clips.

I know Oba corrected himself when he referred to: my Muslim faith" as I saw the full interview

jshell

11,571 posts

222 months

Saturday 14th November 2009
quotequote all
Tafia said:
off_again said:
Oh dear, some people clearly think that its wrong to be a Muslim or to have a president who might be a Muslim. How bizarre. To be honest, who cares if he is or not - does it matter? Surely what matters most is if he is a good president or not - if he's crap then get him out. If he's good then great. Since when did religion matter that much?
Read the Quoran?
Vegetarian?