Abu Hamza Wins Passport Appeal
Author
Discussion

Blib

Original Poster:

48,401 posts

228 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
Just breaking that the "preacher" Abu Hamza has won his High COurt Appeal against losing his British passport.

Yay! He can stay

ETA: The appeal was not heard in the High Court, instead, the decision was handed down from a Special Immigration Commission

Edited by Blib on Friday 5th November 10:02

andy400

11,859 posts

262 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
rolleyes

PintOfKittens

1,336 posts

221 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
Welcome to the UK government, where criminals get more rights than you can ever dream of.

Victor McDade

4,395 posts

213 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
PintOfKittens said:
Welcome to the UK government, where criminals get more rights than you can ever dream of.
It was the UK Government who Hamza was fighting his legal battle against. The special tribunal who made this decision is independent of the government.




bobbylondonuk

2,206 posts

221 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
Time to look at emigrating from here..... i dont think being a pussy is what i want to be known for when i get my british passport in the future.

I am very dissappointed in the British Administration! How can this immigration commission blatantly give an immigrant/asylum seeker the citizenship on condition that it can be revoked...then not revoke it for a wker like Abu Hamza?

What does that mean for a law abiding, tax paying, Zero benefit taking, Zero police record, non ghetto lifestyle, coconut immigrant like me? All the hard work that we put in to integrate into this society and make this our home for the next generation is wasted with this one decision! Just prooves that the bds who play the system are always better off than the hard working!

The smart people are the cheaters in society...atleast they get rewarded for the work they put in!

PintOfKittens

1,336 posts

221 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Welcome to the UK government, where criminals get more rights than you can ever dream of.
It was the UK Government who Hamza was fighting his legal battle against. The special tribunal who made this decision is independent of the government.
So they dont get paid by the gubberment?

Victor McDade

4,395 posts

213 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
PintOfKittens said:
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Welcome to the UK government, where criminals get more rights than you can ever dream of.
It was the UK Government who Hamza was fighting his legal battle against. The special tribunal who made this decision is independent of the government.
So they dont get paid by the gubberment?
What difference does this make?

Her Majesty's Courts Service is funded through central government too.

Your initial point was that somehow central government is responsible for cases like this. How so?

AshVX220

5,965 posts

221 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Welcome to the UK government, where criminals get more rights than you can ever dream of.
It was the UK Government who Hamza was fighting his legal battle against. The special tribunal who made this decision is independent of the government.
So they dont get paid by the gubberment?
What difference does this make?

Her Majesty's Courts Service is funded through central government too.

Your initial point was that somehow central government is responsible for cases like this. How so?
Surely central government have the power to reverse the decision, if they had the balls.

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Welcome to the UK government, where criminals get more rights than you can ever dream of.
It was the UK Government who Hamza was fighting his legal battle against. The special tribunal who made this decision is independent of the government.
So they dont get paid by the gubberment?
What difference does this make?

Her Majesty's Courts Service is funded through central government too.

Your initial point was that somehow central government is responsible for cases like this. How so?
The government introduce the laws, judges etc merely enforce them.

MX7

7,902 posts

205 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
"Radical Muslim cleric Abu Hamza has won his appeal against government attempts to strip him of his British passport, a special tribunal has ruled.

The preacher said it would render him "stateless" as he had already been stripped of his Egyptian citizenship.

The Special Immigration Appeals Commission allowed his appeal in a 12-page ruling."

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-11701262

So if your native country strips you of citizenship, we feel that we have an obligation to provide citizenship? I think that could put us in a very difficult situation.

PintOfKittens

1,336 posts

221 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Welcome to the UK government, where criminals get more rights than you can ever dream of.
It was the UK Government who Hamza was fighting his legal battle against. The special tribunal who made this decision is independent of the government.
So they dont get paid by the gubberment?
What difference does this make?

Her Majesty's Courts Service is funded through central government too.

Your initial point was that somehow central government is responsible for cases like this. How so?
The government introduce the laws, judges etc merely enforce them.
That was the point I was gunna make in a rather roundabout way (before I got a phone call at work!)

Four Litre

2,174 posts

223 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
I cant believe the ammount of reporting time and space this guy gets...simply amazing.

How much money has been spent on this fool, cant we just send chuck norris round his gaff and 'do the guy a favour!'


BeeRoad

684 posts

193 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
The greatest strength of this country is the complete independence of the courts from the government. Sometimes that returns results most of us don't like, but it's still infinitely superior to a politically controlled judiciary.

12gauge

1,274 posts

205 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
BeeRoad said:
The greatest strength of this country is the complete independence of the courts from the government. Sometimes that returns results most of us don't like, but it's still infinitely superior to a politically controlled judiciary.
Isnt that one of the reasons labour wanted to get rid of jurys, to politicise the legal system?

Although i'll bet the tories and 'liberals' have the same idea too.

bobbylondonuk

2,206 posts

221 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
MX7 said:
So if your native country strips you of citizenship, we feel that we have an obligation to provide citizenship? I think that could put us in a very difficult situation.
I think he attained dual citizenship by the marriage route in the 80's. The Egyptians then took the opportunity to get rid of his sorry arse by revoking his Egyptian passport. Now he is our fellow citizen and our problem and a BRITISH radical cleric that just incidentally happens to be of egyptian origin!

Yipeeee!!

Oh and we wont extradite his sorry arse to yankee town because they will put him on the chair and fry him apparently. £££££££££k for all his prison costs, legal defence and lifelong benefits paid for by yours truly till he dies! Wonderful news isn't it?

greygoose

9,674 posts

226 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Welcome to the UK government, where criminals get more rights than you can ever dream of.
It was the UK Government who Hamza was fighting his legal battle against. The special tribunal who made this decision is independent of the government.
So they dont get paid by the gubberment?
What difference does this make?

Her Majesty's Courts Service is funded through central government too.

Your initial point was that somehow central government is responsible for cases like this. How so?
The government introduce the laws, judges etc merely enforce them.
Interpret may be a better word than enforce.

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
greygoose said:
wolves_wanderer said:
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Victor McDade said:
PintOfKittens said:
Welcome to the UK government, where criminals get more rights than you can ever dream of.
It was the UK Government who Hamza was fighting his legal battle against. The special tribunal who made this decision is independent of the government.
So they dont get paid by the gubberment?
What difference does this make?

Her Majesty's Courts Service is funded through central government too.

Your initial point was that somehow central government is responsible for cases like this. How so?
The government introduce the laws, judges etc merely enforce them.
That's what I meant - brain fart.

Interpret may be a better word than enforce.

Scraggles

7,619 posts

255 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
why the need to quote all the other quotes ?

not surprised that he got the passport, should never have gotten it in the first place

if he hates the country so much, why not leave ? maybe it is all the benefits he gets for not wanting to work ?

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
Scraggles said:
why the need to quote all the other quotes ?

not surprised that he got the passport, should never have gotten it in the first place

if he hates the country so much, why not leave ? maybe it is all the benefits he gets for not wanting to work ?
Too lazy to strip them all out

BeeRoad

684 posts

193 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
12gauge said:
BeeRoad said:
The greatest strength of this country is the complete independence of the courts from the government. Sometimes that returns results most of us don't like, but it's still infinitely superior to a politically controlled judiciary.
Isnt that one of the reasons labour wanted to get rid of jurys, to politicise the legal system?

Although i'll bet the tories and 'liberals' have the same idea too.
I think the coalition would find that difficult given their loud promotion of their small government and libertarian ideals.