Maths and Voodoo
Author
Discussion

Groat

Original Poster:

5,637 posts

140 months

Friday 8th November 2019
quotequote all

If a landlord bought a flat in 1989 which cost £11k and now 30 years on sold it for £44k.........

.......and £1 today is worth 25p at 1989's value.....

......can that landlord be truly said to have made NOTHING on the property in real terms?

tumble dryer

2,383 posts

156 months

Friday 8th November 2019
quotequote all
Groat said:
If a landlord bought a flat in 1989 which cost £11k and now 30 years on sold it for £44k.........

.......and £1 today is worth 25p at 1989's value.....

......can that landlord be truly said to have made NOTHING on the property in real terms?
Not doubting your figures, but £1.00 - 25p seems ott?

Groat

Original Poster:

5,637 posts

140 months

Friday 8th November 2019
quotequote all
O in reality I think it's closer to 40p (maybe even 50p) but that wasn't really the point.

The point was, in terms of gain, should inflation be taken into account?

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

290 months

Friday 8th November 2019
quotequote all
Groat said:
O in reality I think it's closer to 40p (maybe even 50p) but that wasn't really the point.

The point was, in terms of gain, should inflation be taken into account?
If you're trying to work it out in real terms, then by definition yes.

Gary C

15,250 posts

208 months

Friday 8th November 2019
quotequote all
Groat said:
O in reality I think it's closer to 40p (maybe even 50p) but that wasn't really the point.

The point was, in terms of gain, should inflation be taken into account?
In terms of gain ?, to you mean capital gains ?

You can look at a gain in anyway you want, but if its for legal, or tax reasons, then there will be rules

tumble dryer

2,383 posts

156 months

Friday 8th November 2019
quotequote all
Groat said:
O in reality I think it's closer to 40p (maybe even 50p) but that wasn't really the point.

The point was, in terms of gain, should inflation be taken into account?
Ah, right. smile

I'm not really sure how you would look at that tbh.

I assume any rental income kept pace with inflation? (Although I don't know how that helps) spin

Simpo Two

92,736 posts

294 months

Friday 8th November 2019
quotequote all
Groat said:
If a landlord bought a flat in 1989 which cost £11k and now 30 years on sold it for £44k.........

.......and £1 today is worth 25p at 1989's value.....

......can that landlord be truly said to have made NOTHING on the property in real terms?
I think the issue is that one is cost, the other is buying power.

So the money has gone from 25p to £1.
The house has gone from £11K to £44K.

4x vs almost 4x.

Now if you could take the £44K back to 1989 in a time machine, that's when you really get ahead...

anonymous-user

83 months

Saturday 9th November 2019
quotequote all
Most significantly there will be a tax charge on the £33k gain, even though the owner has had no real profit/gain.

Tax on inflation.

Corbyn/McDonnell would love it!