Spend ISA savings while maxing pension contributions?
Spend ISA savings while maxing pension contributions?
Author
Discussion

Halitosis

Original Poster:

223 posts

86 months

Monday 10th January 2022
quotequote all
Currently in my mid 50s and hoping to retire at 60. With 50k in ISAs I'm wondering if it makes sense to ramp up contributions to my workplace pension pot (defined contribution) and use the ISA savings towards living expenses instead?
My thinking being that the pension contributions would be boosted by the 21% income tax rate (Scotland), and I don't expect to ever be a higher rate tax payer in retirement, though would enjoy the 25% tax free element from my pension.
Have I thought this through properly? Thanks for any thoughts

xeny

5,458 posts

107 months

Tuesday 11th January 2022
quotequote all
I hope you've thought it through properly as I've occasionally done something similar.

springfan62

923 posts

105 months

Tuesday 11th January 2022
quotequote all
Halitosis said:
Currently in my mid 50s and hoping to retire at 60. With 50k in ISAs I'm wondering if it makes sense to ramp up contributions to my workplace pension pot (defined contribution) and use the ISA savings towards living expenses instead?
My thinking being that the pension contributions would be boosted by the 21% income tax rate (Scotland), and I don't expect to ever be a higher rate tax payer in retirement, though would enjoy the 25% tax free element from my pension.
Have I thought this through properly? Thanks for any thoughts
Once it is in a pension pot it's harder to get it out, I would always have some funds that are more liquid so an Isa serves that purpose, with some in actual cash.



Carbon Sasquatch

5,222 posts

93 months

Tuesday 11th January 2022
quotequote all
Yes it makes sense.

As above, keep a little in reserve. but once over 55 you can withdraw the 25% tax free whenever you want & carry on paying in as long as you don't touch the rest - so there's your emergency fund.

Also if you're retiring at 60, you will have 7 years or so where you can use up your regular tax free entitlement as well before even starting paying tax.

devaneeiya

2 posts

57 months

Wednesday 12th January 2022
quotequote all
These manipulations definitely make sense. Be sure to remember the financial pillow. It is better to take at least a small loan if possible, but feel confident financially, no matter how old you are - 25, 50 or 80. Therefore, you can find out right here and immediately get 300 dollar loan with a guarantee that you will not be checked and you will receive your money instantly. I believe that this option of a loan without a credit check is the future, as well as a great opportunity for all people of any age, gender and profession to always have a few hundred dollars in reserve.

Edited by devaneeiya on Monday 31st January 16:57

alock

4,555 posts

240 months

Wednesday 12th January 2022
quotequote all
Carbon Sasquatch said:
As above, keep a little in reserve. but once over 55 you can withdraw the 25% tax free whenever you want & carry on paying in as long as you don't touch the rest - so there's your emergency fund.
I thought that once you crystallize any of your pension, your annual limit drops from £40k to £4k?

This is to stop the loophole of taking 25%, and putting it straight back in to get double tax relief.

Carbon Sasquatch

5,222 posts

93 months

Thursday 13th January 2022
quotequote all
alock said:
Carbon Sasquatch said:
As above, keep a little in reserve. but once over 55 you can withdraw the 25% tax free whenever you want & carry on paying in as long as you don't touch the rest - so there's your emergency fund.
I thought that once you crystallize any of your pension, your annual limit drops from £40k to £4k?

This is to stop the loophole of taking 25%, and putting it straight back in to get double tax relief.
Not if you only take the tax free cash and leave the rest.

One source - last sentence - https://www.youinvest.co.uk/pensions-and-retiremen...

You are correct that recycling is not allowed though, but those rules are somewhat vague.

nickfrog

25,286 posts

246 months

Thursday 13th January 2022
quotequote all
OP. Do it. A lot of people don't actually understand the value of pension tax relief, particularly past 55.


Carbon Sasquatch

5,222 posts

93 months

Thursday 13th January 2022
quotequote all
I was not suggesting recycling BTW - just that the 25% is there as an emergency fund if required.

bogie

17,062 posts

301 months

Thursday 13th January 2022
quotequote all
Carbon Sasquatch said:
alock said:
Carbon Sasquatch said:
As above, keep a little in reserve. but once over 55 you can withdraw the 25% tax free whenever you want & carry on paying in as long as you don't touch the rest - so there's your emergency fund.
I thought that once you crystallize any of your pension, your annual limit drops from £40k to £4k?

This is to stop the loophole of taking 25%, and putting it straight back in to get double tax relief.
Not if you only take the tax free cash and leave the rest.

One source - last sentence - https://www.youinvest.co.uk/pensions-and-retiremen...

You are correct that recycling is not allowed though, but those rules are somewhat vague.
I think you need to keep working part time and have another source of income, then you can live off the tax free cash and put all the income back into the pension, you cant directly recycle....which is obviously what you are doing if your only source of income is the money you just took from pension.


Whatsmyname

944 posts

106 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
bogie said:
I think you need to keep working part time and have another source of income, then you can live off the tax free cash and put all the income back into the pension, you cant directly recycle....which is obviously what you are doing if your only source of income is the money you just took from pension.
Serious question - could your Mrs start a company with ridiculous terms and conditions that allowed you as an employee of said company to pay it all back into a pension?

Carbon Sasquatch

5,222 posts

93 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
Whatsmyname said:
Serious question - could your Mrs start a company with ridiculous terms and conditions that allowed you as an employee of said company to pay it all back into a pension?
Said company would have to pay you - so somehow you have to get the money into it & any associated cost/tax in doing that.

It only really makes any sense if you are a genuine employee - live off your tax free sum & salary sacrifice 100% (or as much as possible). Ideally start the salary sacrifice pattern some time before taking the lump sum.

nickfrog

25,286 posts

246 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
Carbon Sasquatch said:
You are correct that recycling is not allowed though, but those rules are somewhat vague.
True. For starters you can legally recycle £2,880 per year per person even with £0 income. And HMRC will top up to £3,600.

Carbon Sasquatch

5,222 posts

93 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
True. For starters you can legally recycle £2,880 per year per person even with £0 income. And HMRC will top up to £3,600.
They will, but they will also tax it again on the way out. 25% is tax free, but the rest will depend on what other income you have and will be charged at your marginal rate.



nickfrog

25,286 posts

246 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
Carbon Sasquatch said:
nickfrog said:
True. For starters you can legally recycle £2,880 per year per person even with £0 income. And HMRC will top up to £3,600.
They will, but they will also tax it again on the way out. 25% is tax free, but the rest will depend on what other income you have and will be charged at your marginal rate.
Yes sure but I am planning on paying very little income tax in retirement, if any at all by managing the balance of ISA and Pension. I am therefore planning to return none of the tax that I saved out of pension provision. Admittedly that may mean that my kids will pay (some of) it though...or leave it to their kids laugh.