Loan to Daughter?
Author
Discussion

pauljdh

Original Poster:

215 posts

188 months

Sunday 5th January 2025
quotequote all
Could I loan approx 40K to my daughter for her to clear her Uni loans which she services at 7.9%?

.......the idea would be a loan with an agreed repayment schedule and an agreement (if thats a requirement to satisfy HMRC rules etc).

Want to do it properly and within the rules...

Many thanks

Paul

markiii

4,216 posts

218 months

Sunday 5th January 2025
quotequote all
what HMRC rules are you worried about?

Wilmslowboy

4,652 posts

230 months

Sunday 5th January 2025
quotequote all
I just paid my daughter's off (no loan), I don't see any difference to her not taking loans out and me paying as we went along.

I don't plan to die in the next 7 years.


Eric Mc

124,939 posts

289 months

Sunday 5th January 2025
quotequote all
pauljdh said:
Could I loan approx 40K to my daughter for her to clear her Uni loans which she services at 7.9%?

.......the idea would be a loan with an agreed repayment schedule and an agreement (if thats a requirement to satisfy HMRC rules etc).

Want to do it properly and within the rules...

Many thanks

Paul
No rules - unless you charge her interest. If you do, you should notify HMRC that you are receiving interest as interest is taxable.

C69

1,117 posts

36 months

Sunday 5th January 2025
quotequote all
Are you concerned about the seven-year rule for inheritance tax?

If so, what you're suggesting seems to be a reasonable way of establishing that it's a loan, not a gift. Obviously she'd have to actually pay the repayments when they become due...

Countdown

47,633 posts

220 months

Sunday 5th January 2025
quotequote all
C69 said:
Are you concerned about the seven-year rule for inheritance tax?

If so, what you're suggesting seems to be a reasonable way of establishing that it's a loan, not a gift. Obviously she'd have to actually pay the repayments when they become due...
By calling it a loan wouldn't the full outstanding amount be included in the Estate for IHT calculations, whereas if it's a gift the OP would get some amount of taper relief?

C69

1,117 posts

36 months

Sunday 5th January 2025
quotequote all
Countdown said:
By calling it a loan wouldn't the full outstanding amount be included in the Estate for IHT calculations, whereas if it's a gift the OP would get some amount of taper relief?
Agreed, making it a loan might not necessarily the best approach from an IHT perspective. I suppose it depends on the OP's circumstances and what they're trying to achieve.

Edited by C69 on Sunday 5th January 23:32

pauljdh

Original Poster:

215 posts

188 months

Sunday 5th January 2025
quotequote all
Thank you all some very useful information = Id assumed paying interest would show it wasn't a gift to avoid IHT - Ill think on, cheers.

Eric Mc

124,939 posts

289 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Interest has no bearing on whether the money was in the way of a loan or a gift. There is no obligation to charge interest on a loan, if you don't want to. And, as I said previouisly, if you start receiving interest, you must declare the interest for tax purpose - usually through self assessment.

What determines whether something is a gift or a loan are the terms and conditions associated with the transaction - and subsequent events.

For instance - if you say "here's £40,000 - yoiu don't need to pay it back" - that's a gift.
If you say, "here's £40,000 - you need to pay it back as soon as you can" - that's a loan.

Sometimes, an intended loan morphs into a gift as the lender changes their mind about being repaid.

With gifts the main concern is Inheritance Tax (IHT). You can give as much as you like with no IHT consequences - provided you don't die within 7 years of the date of the gift.

Bobley

730 posts

173 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Write a "promisory note". Both of you sign it. Lay out the terms of what you're proposing to do. We leat the kids money to buy a home but it's not money I can afford to be without. Our note said it was interest free for X years and then an interest rate of Y afterwards. They pay back into my bank and I keep an excel sheet with the numbers.

We've let them off with the interest payments so far as (mentioned above) it means declaring to HMRC.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Promissory_note

LooneyTunes

9,040 posts

182 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
With gifts the main concern is Inheritance Tax (IHT). You can give as much as you like with no IHT consequences - provided you don't die within 7 years of the date of the gift.
Isn’t the main IHT consideration the possibility of a gift being subject to IHT (if the giver dies within 7 years) vs the certainty of the money still being in the estate for IHT calculation purposes if it’s a loan?

Eric Mc

124,939 posts

289 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
Eric Mc said:
With gifts the main concern is Inheritance Tax (IHT). You can give as much as you like with no IHT consequences - provided you don't die within 7 years of the date of the gift.
Isn’t the main IHT consideration the possibility of a gift being subject to IHT (if the giver dies within 7 years) vs the certainty of the money still being in the estate for IHT calculation purposes if it’s a loan?
Pretty much

Mr Whippy

32,285 posts

265 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Can’t you get best of boast worlds there?

Loan it with repayment due at your death?

Assuming daughter is on your will it’s circular and can just come off the amount of residual of estate value?
Assuming estate is in balance to do that… could get messier if not.

981Boxess

11,894 posts

282 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
For instance - if you say "here's £40,000 - you don't need to pay it back" - that's a gift.
If you did that and that was the end of that, would she then be in the frame for CGT?

Eric Mc

124,939 posts

289 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Why?

Bobley

730 posts

173 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Shouldn't do as gifts from parents to children dont usually attract any tax as long as you live 7 years...

Eric Mc

124,939 posts

289 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Bobley said:
Shouldn't do as gifts from parents to children dont usually attract any tax as long as you live 7 years...
The 7 year rule is nothing to do with Capital Gains Tax. It relates to Inheritance Tax.

Anybody can give any amount they like to anybody they like.

wrencho

343 posts

89 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Surely the £40k would be better served on helping her in another way rather than on a loan with flexible terms that may never have to be repaid in full?

LooneyTunes

9,040 posts

182 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
Can’t you get best of boast worlds there?

Loan it with repayment due at your death?

Assuming daughter is on your will it’s circular and can just come off the amount of residual of estate value?
Assuming estate is in balance to do that… could get messier if not.
Surely that would be the worst of all worlds?

Why would he want to put it back in the estate at death in order to then pay IHT that, assuming he lived 7 years, would have been avoided?

981Boxess

11,894 posts

282 months

Monday 6th January 2025
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Anybody can give any amount they like to anybody they like.
So, I could give my mate £100k as a gift, nobody cares?

Two years later he gives me a gift of £100k, nobody cares again?

Two gifts, no loan, no interest, no profit - nobody cares?