Discussion
Hi,
Know a few of you have or have looked at air source heat pumps. We’re looking at this seriously for our house to get us away from oil. The property is about 5000 sq ft and now has underfloor heating downstairs (with pipes spaced at quite close centres) and oversized cast iron radiators upstairs. We carried out these works with the view to get an ASHP in a couple of years but now thinking we’ll bring that plan forward.
I have a detailed quote from an MCS accredited company for a 22KW pump (3 phase) which is nearly £15k for pump itself (excluding install and all other related parts). Does that seem reasonable? I can see 14KW Mitsubishi Ecodan units for sale online at around £6000 which makes me worry about mark up being added. The total quote makes the whole project less viable – especially with RHI looking uncertain. It’s also only a 1/3 cheaper than a price I got for ground source installation.
Will do some calling around but appreciate any thoughts from someone who has been down this route.
Thanks.
Know a few of you have or have looked at air source heat pumps. We’re looking at this seriously for our house to get us away from oil. The property is about 5000 sq ft and now has underfloor heating downstairs (with pipes spaced at quite close centres) and oversized cast iron radiators upstairs. We carried out these works with the view to get an ASHP in a couple of years but now thinking we’ll bring that plan forward.
I have a detailed quote from an MCS accredited company for a 22KW pump (3 phase) which is nearly £15k for pump itself (excluding install and all other related parts). Does that seem reasonable? I can see 14KW Mitsubishi Ecodan units for sale online at around £6000 which makes me worry about mark up being added. The total quote makes the whole project less viable – especially with RHI looking uncertain. It’s also only a 1/3 cheaper than a price I got for ground source installation.
Will do some calling around but appreciate any thoughts from someone who has been down this route.
Thanks.
Been done to death here before, but you've alighted on the important points - on larger scales, it's little different from GSHP in cost, and yet GSHP has the backing of the RHI, the future for ASHP under the RHI is far less than certain.
Running cast iron rads off either A or GSHP is a no-go unless you like monumental electricity bills. When we were looking in to GSHP we were around £25k for a 28kw system, so the price seems roughly in the right ball park - the smaller ASHP pumps are much cheaper than the biggers ones.
I assume you already have 3-phase? It was one of the big killers for us - EON wanted £25k + groundworks alone to put it in here, despite us being 20 yards from the transformer and being the only property connected to the line.... madness.
I'd seriously consider Biomass - it's where we've ended up, and thus far we're over the bloody moon with it. Plus the RHI is far higher on it, so we'll end up paying off the investment in a little over four years, instead of the 8 we were expecting with GSHP. Oh and the running costs are lower too - wood / pellets for us here are about £1200 per annum, as opposed to the projected £1600 per annum on leccy to run GSHP in "perfect" conditions.
As you say, anything's better than a £4kpa oil habit!
Running cast iron rads off either A or GSHP is a no-go unless you like monumental electricity bills. When we were looking in to GSHP we were around £25k for a 28kw system, so the price seems roughly in the right ball park - the smaller ASHP pumps are much cheaper than the biggers ones.
I assume you already have 3-phase? It was one of the big killers for us - EON wanted £25k + groundworks alone to put it in here, despite us being 20 yards from the transformer and being the only property connected to the line.... madness.
I'd seriously consider Biomass - it's where we've ended up, and thus far we're over the bloody moon with it. Plus the RHI is far higher on it, so we'll end up paying off the investment in a little over four years, instead of the 8 we were expecting with GSHP. Oh and the running costs are lower too - wood / pellets for us here are about £1200 per annum, as opposed to the projected £1600 per annum on leccy to run GSHP in "perfect" conditions.
As you say, anything's better than a £4kpa oil habit!
thanks, thats really helpful. So much information out there and really feel like I'm going in circles. We have 3 phase which was one reason the electrician suggested looking at ASHP (from some commercial jobs he'd worked on).
We originally looked at a wood burning system a friend of a friend has - in his words it was a "lifetyle choice" though as he has to load the boiler every day and also managed all the wood himself. If you don't mind would you share some info on the biomass sytem you went for in the end? Sounds like we at least have similar oil bills! I think if we could find something that didn't need too much attention I'd consider biomass. We live within a forest area so plenty of timber sources.
Really struggling to make the ASHP sums stack up without a very serious chunk coming from RHI.
We originally looked at a wood burning system a friend of a friend has - in his words it was a "lifetyle choice" though as he has to load the boiler every day and also managed all the wood himself. If you don't mind would you share some info on the biomass sytem you went for in the end? Sounds like we at least have similar oil bills! I think if we could find something that didn't need too much attention I'd consider biomass. We live within a forest area so plenty of timber sources.
Really struggling to make the ASHP sums stack up without a very serious chunk coming from RHI.
This link http://www.wharfplumbing.co.uk/products/air-source... is the same unit I sell in New Zealand. For around 1200 pounds it's an absolute bargain - when they perform to specification they are one of the best in the world.
However, there can be technical issues. These will be covered by a guarantee (and the Sale of Goods Act), so it depends if you want to take a risk and buy one (possibly two in your case, the units can be joined together).
I've sold 30 units in the last few months. Easy fixes have been a board failure, 5 fan capacitors, and a few short on refrigerant. Bigger problems have been three heat exchange failures.
I fitted one of these units in parallel with an existing oil boiler for a friend of mine to see how it works (large house). The heat pump keeps the whole place warm about 85% of the time, and he simply tops up with oil when the heat pump can't keep up.
Look at some figures.
1 litre of oil is 10kW, is that about 7p a kW? During cold weather these ASHPs will be say 4:1 efficient - if electricity is 12p a unit the actual cost is 3p a kW.
Note the heat pump efficiency varies with temperature, below 7c the unit defrosts every 40 minutes. Hence you could take advantage of night rate but the efficiency is lower.
These units work very well in NZ as we don't have that many hours below 7c when the heating has to running - the cost effectiveness is different in the UK.
I lived in the Midlands for forty years so I know what it's like in winter - one reason I moved to NZ. Warm and sunny here today, in very early spring.
ETA. Time clock is inaccurate, reasonably easy fix. Casings tend to rust, car polish needed.
However, there can be technical issues. These will be covered by a guarantee (and the Sale of Goods Act), so it depends if you want to take a risk and buy one (possibly two in your case, the units can be joined together).
I've sold 30 units in the last few months. Easy fixes have been a board failure, 5 fan capacitors, and a few short on refrigerant. Bigger problems have been three heat exchange failures.
I fitted one of these units in parallel with an existing oil boiler for a friend of mine to see how it works (large house). The heat pump keeps the whole place warm about 85% of the time, and he simply tops up with oil when the heat pump can't keep up.
Look at some figures.
1 litre of oil is 10kW, is that about 7p a kW? During cold weather these ASHPs will be say 4:1 efficient - if electricity is 12p a unit the actual cost is 3p a kW.
Note the heat pump efficiency varies with temperature, below 7c the unit defrosts every 40 minutes. Hence you could take advantage of night rate but the efficiency is lower.
These units work very well in NZ as we don't have that many hours below 7c when the heating has to running - the cost effectiveness is different in the UK.
I lived in the Midlands for forty years so I know what it's like in winter - one reason I moved to NZ. Warm and sunny here today, in very early spring.
ETA. Time clock is inaccurate, reasonably easy fix. Casings tend to rust, car polish needed.
Edited by caziques on Saturday 3rd September 23:09
Thanks, they're interesting - I'd hoped to find something "in between" in terms of reliability and price.
I had been expecting we might save about 25% by using ASHP - I'm in Scotland and the winters can be long and freezing. I had originally thought I might save around £1000 PA (over what I pay on oil) and spend around £12k on the solution. With something from a government incentive (erring on side of caution) it would maybe pay for itself in 10 years or so. With solution being quoted at over £20k I'd probably stick with oil for now and see what actual RHI figures end up at.
Moving country would probably have been the better plan!
I had been expecting we might save about 25% by using ASHP - I'm in Scotland and the winters can be long and freezing. I had originally thought I might save around £1000 PA (over what I pay on oil) and spend around £12k on the solution. With something from a government incentive (erring on side of caution) it would maybe pay for itself in 10 years or so. With solution being quoted at over £20k I'd probably stick with oil for now and see what actual RHI figures end up at.
Moving country would probably have been the better plan!
Simpo Two said:
I wonder why the Govt is paying people to fit solar panels but not heat pumps?
In Australia they do. You get a rebate on both solar hot water or a hot water heat pump. The rebate is based on how much energy you will avoid using over the next ten years. I doubt there is anyone in the UK with enough sense to work this out.OP have a look at this link:
http://www.sirac-cn.com/products/LSQ05RC-06RC-Air-...
I will probably be importing these next time I order - more reliable and operate down to -20c, the unit is designed for cold weather.
Contact them and see if they have any outlets in the UK, if not see if they'll sell you a sample! (about 2,000 pounds I think). Note they have a Copeland scroll compressor - reckoned the best in the world.
Can thoroughly recommend EcoDans.
We have the 14kw version although they can be paired if need be for higher outputs.
Running cost... our total electric bill for a c1906 house is £75pm. Readings taken weekly.
Low running costs are probably down to using fan convectors which run at even lower temps than ufh.
RHI - not really bothered as its peanuts to run compared to when we were on LPG...
Rated to -25
We have the 14kw version although they can be paired if need be for higher outputs.
Running cost... our total electric bill for a c1906 house is £75pm. Readings taken weekly.
Low running costs are probably down to using fan convectors which run at even lower temps than ufh.
RHI - not really bothered as its peanuts to run compared to when we were on LPG...
Rated to -25

Edited by Sleepers on Sunday 4th September 20:52
caziques said:
Note the heat pump efficiency varies with temperature, below 7c the unit defrosts every 40 minutes. Hence you could take advantage of night rate but the efficiency is lower.
These units work very well in NZ as we don't have that many hours below 7c when the heating has to running - the cost effectiveness is different in the UK.
Therein lies the problem - last winter here in the West Midlands we had four days of -19, and 20 which were below -10. Now granted that was a particularly harsh winter, but at that point you're sucking an awful lot of electricity to keep things going. Two locals I know with ASHP systems were getting less than 1:1 as they were having to put in so much leccy to keep the systems from freezing up. The OP is in Scotland where it was ten times worse than down here. Even during an average winter, one can bet on 30-60 days around freezing or below.These units work very well in NZ as we don't have that many hours below 7c when the heating has to running - the cost effectiveness is different in the UK.
Oh, and as per the other comment about an ASHP system being "rated" to -25, that means it'll work at -25, not that it'll be anything approaching efficient at that temp!
orbit123 said:
We originally looked at a wood burning system a friend of a friend has - in his words it was a "lifetyle choice" though as he has to load the boiler every day and also managed all the wood himself. If you don't mind would you share some info on the biomass sytem you went for in the end? Sounds like we at least have similar oil bills! I think if we could find something that didn't need too much attention I'd consider biomass. We live within a forest area so plenty of timber sources.
We looked at it briefly a couple of years ago before setting our minds to GSHP. I dismissed it because of the "hassle" factor - I didn't want to be loading logs, clearing ash, stoking fires, preparing kindling and what have you day by day. However, once we were beginning to discover that ASHP couldn't handle our house, and GSHP was becoming increasingly costly, our renovation architect urged us to take another look into Biomass. I eventually dropped in to one of the big UK importers purely to set my mind at rest that I was right and it was poo.... and came out an hour later to phone my wife and tell her we were getting one!On the small-scale end (IE non-commercial) it's principally about pellets or logs - with pellets it works just like any other fossil fuel boiler: feed on demand, lights and extinguishes itself, pellets turn up on a truck either in bulk or in bags. With logs it's a case of loading the things in, burning, and then putting more in when you need more. Wood is cheaper than pellets to buy and produces more heat (in the case of hard wood), but is more "hassle". However, we have about 6 acres of woodland, and I have binned my gym membership in lieu of a chainsaw... so suddenly wood becomes more "hassle", but "free".
As a rough guide, pertaining to our house here the running costs were projected as follows:
Oil (current and known) - £4k per annum
GSHP (running 4:1 perfect conditions) - £1600 leccy per annum
Biomass Pellets - £1200 per annum
Biomass Logs - £1000 per annum
So any of the options provide a decent saving, and if one can view the logs as being "free" (albeit with the cost of my time, energy and two-stroke) then the savings are enormous. I was a little dubious about the pellet cost as like heating oil it's unregulated, so the question remained: as more people adopted it, would the prices come down, or would the suppliers see a captive market and launch them into the stratosphere?
HOWEVER - I work away a lot, and I didn't want wifey to have to load logs, nor clear ash, and more to the point, what happens to the house when we're all away skiing in the depths of winter? An oil boiler would still work, GSHP would still work, a pellet boiler would still work, a log boiler would have no one to fill or light it... and I still didn't like the idea of having to light the logs anyway....
Then I discovered on going to the biomass place that the world has moved on, and the product which was perfect for us (totally understand it's not everyone's cup of warm tea) had arrived, replete with endless awards for innovation and so on - a combined log and pellet boiler - it can run purely on pellets, purely on logs, or on automatic: so if you fill it with logs, they burn down, and then you forget or can't be bothered to fill it up, it switches to pellets. If you fill it with logs and it doesn't have any heat demand it does nothing.... then the system calls for heat and it ignites the pellets automatically, and then uses the fire from that to light the logs. You don't have to touch a thing. So we now have the "perfect" system - we can use "free" logs, or paid-for pellets depending on our mood, situation, time of year or whatever.
The cost was roughly equal to the specced GSHP for this house, but the RHI is nearly double - so whilst the RHI would have "paid for" the electricity to run the GSHP and little more, with the biomass it'll be almost all into our back pockets. As a result, as I mentioned earlier, the payoff for GSHP was circa 8-9 years, the biomass will be cost neutral in 4.5 - and that time is calculated on assuming 100% pellet usage, and an uplift of only 10%pa on the cost of heating oil.... so the more oil goes up and the more "free" logs I use, the shorter that time will become. £3800pa of RHI and the saving of £4kpa on oil quickly adds up.
Oh and as for ash emptying, it's laughable. The manufacturers claim 98% efficiency, and I have no reason thus far to disbelieve them - in running the system now for nearly a month I have produced about 6 egg cups full of ash! So looking at it thus far in terms of the pellets / logs I have burned, I would anticipate emptying the ash about once every 6 weeks in winter, 18 weeks in summer.
orbit123 said:
Really struggling to make the ASHP sums stack up without a very serious chunk coming from RHI.
Therein lies the rub - IF the RHI is maintained, then depending on the system, the returns are enormous - better than investing the money in fact. Some fuels are better supported by the RHI than others, and some not at all (as you rightly say, ASHP is still under consultation as the EST don't trust it despite many years research in to it).We have tried to assume the RHI is dead in the water, or at least will only exist for a foreshortened period before another government rips it up - thus again the biomass payoff period being half that of GSHP had an enormous appeal - we only "need" the RHI to run for 4 years and we're then paid back - the crucial figure is the cost of oil, the RHI is a bonus.
Edited by RedLeicester on Monday 5th September 10:10
RedLeicester said:
Oh, and as per the other comment about an ASHP system being "rated" to -25, that means it'll work at -25, not that it'll be anything approaching efficient at that temp!
Agreed but have other souces of heat. Big smokeless coal delivery tomorrow and get loads of exercise cutting and managing our wood so prepared for winter this time. Still have dreaded lpg connected to flame effect fires too 
Solar PV will be going in at somepoint too...
Edited by Sleepers on Monday 5th September 11:28
Edited by Sleepers on Monday 5th September 11:45
Edited by Sleepers on Monday 5th September 12:20
RedLeicester said:
orbit123 said:
We originally looked at a wood burning system a friend of a friend has - in his words it was a "lifetyle choice" though as he has to load the boiler every day and also managed all the wood himself. If you don't mind would you share some info on the biomass sytem you went for in the end? Sounds like we at least have similar oil bills! I think if we could find something that didn't need too much attention I'd consider biomass. We live within a forest area so plenty of timber sources.
We looked at it briefly a couple of years ago before setting our minds to GSHP. I dismissed it because of the "hassle" factor - I didn't want to be loading logs, clearing ash, stoking fires, preparing kindling and what have you day by day. However, once we were beginning to discover that ASHP couldn't handle our house, and GSHP was becoming increasingly costly, our renovation architect urged us to take another look into Biomass. I eventually dropped in to one of the big UK importers purely to set my mind at rest that I was right and it was poo.... and came out an hour later to phone my wife and tell her we were getting one!On the small-scale end (IE non-commercial) it's principally about pellets or logs - with pellets it works just like any other fossil fuel boiler: feed on demand, lights and extinguishes itself, pellets turn up on a truck either in bulk or in bags. With logs it's a case of loading the things in, burning, and then putting more in when you need more. Wood is cheaper than pellets to buy and produces more heat (in the case of hard wood), but is more "hassle". However, we have about 6 acres of woodland, and I have binned my gym membership in lieu of a chainsaw... so suddenly wood becomes more "hassle", but "free".
As a rough guide, pertaining to our house here the running costs were projected as follows:
Oil (current and known) - £4k per annum
GSHP (running 4:1 perfect conditions) - £1600 leccy per annum
Biomass Pellets - £1200 per annum
Biomass Logs - £1000 per annum
So any of the options provide a decent saving, and if one can view the logs as being "free" (albeit with the cost of my time, energy and two-stroke) then the savings are enormous. I was a little dubious about the pellet cost as like heating oil it's unregulated, so the question remained: as more people adopted it, would the prices come down, or would the suppliers see a captive market and launch them into the stratosphere?
HOWEVER - I work away a lot, and I didn't want wifey to have to load logs, nor clear ash, and more to the point, what happens to the house when we're all away skiing in the depths of winter? An oil boiler would still work, GSHP would still work, a pellet boiler would still work, a log boiler would have no one to fill or light it... and I still didn't like the idea of having to light the logs anyway....
Then I discovered on going to the biomass place that the world has moved on, and the product which was perfect for us (totally understand it's not everyone's cup of warm tea) had arrived, replete with endless awards for innovation and so on - a combined log and pellet boiler - it can run purely on pellets, purely on logs, or on automatic: so if you fill it with logs, they burn down, and then you forget or can't be bothered to fill it up, it switches to pellets. If you fill it with logs and it doesn't have any heat demand it does nothing.... then the system calls for heat and it ignites the pellets automatically, and then uses the fire from that to light the logs. You don't have to touch a thing. So we now have the "perfect" system - we can use "free" logs, or paid-for pellets depending on our mood, situation, time of year or whatever.
The cost was roughly equal to the specced GSHP for this house, but the RHI is nearly double - so whilst the RHI would have "paid for" the electricity to run the GSHP and little more, with the biomass it'll be almost all into our back pockets. As a result, as I mentioned earlier, the payoff for GSHP was circa 8-9 years, the biomass will be cost neutral in 4.5 - and that time is calculated on assuming 100% pellet usage, and an uplift of only 10%pa on the cost of heating oil.... so the more oil goes up and the more "free" logs I use, the shorter that time will become. £3800pa of RHI and the saving of £4kpa on oil quickly adds up.
Oh and as for ash emptying, it's laughable. The manufacturers claim 98% efficiency, and I have no reason thus far to disbelieve them - in running the system now for nearly a month I have produced about 6 egg cups full of ash! So looking at it thus far in terms of the pellets / logs I have burned, I would anticipate emptying the ash about once every 6 weeks in winter, 18 weeks in summer.
orbit123 said:
Really struggling to make the ASHP sums stack up without a very serious chunk coming from RHI.
Therein lies the rub - IF the RHI is maintained, then depending on the system, the returns are enormous - better than investing the money in fact. Some fuels are better supported by the RHI than others, and some not at all (as you rightly say, ASHP is still under consultation as the EST don't trust it despite many years research in to it).We have tried to assume the RHI is dead in the water, or at least will only exist for a foreshortened period before another government rips it up - thus again the biomass payoff period being half that of GSHP had an enormous appeal - we only "need" the RHI to run for 4 years and we're then paid back - the crucial figure is the cost of oil, the RHI is a bonus.
Edited by RedLeicester on Monday 5th September 10:10
It's all down to lifestyle, type of property, availabity of fuels and budget etc...
Cheers
Sleepers said:
This is a brilliant post which clearly shows the steps people interested in renewables have to take.
It's all down to lifestyle, type of property, availabity of fuels and budget etc...
Cheers
Thankyou. It's all down to lifestyle, type of property, availabity of fuels and budget etc...
Cheers

It has infuriated me somewhat - it's taken 18 months to get to this point, and it doesn't seem to matter which technology you consider, there are an awful lot of charlatans about, or if they're not actually misinforming you, then they're either lazy or simply don't know themselves. The more I researched, asked around, crunched numbers, the cleverer I got, and later in the process I found myself asking questions of companies which they simply weren't prepared to answer or didn't know anything about. It's also notable how many of them try and sell you the "this'll save X tons of C02, nudge, nudge" versus others that look at it in realistic terms of "escape oil, here's your financial saving..."
It also amazed me the number of companies that contradicted each other - GSHP was a case in point, there's been piles of research into putting the pipes into bodies of water - the temperature is more even than in shallow trenches (ignoring boreholes for a minute) and the recharge time is quicker (thanks to water moving whereas earth can't) and better still, the temperature differential is far greater than in soil, so the efficiencies are much higher. On being told we had a lake, two companies jumped at it and insisted we must put the coils in the lake, oh wow, this is going to be brilliant etc, no less than four other commpanies said it couldn't be done or wouldn't work, and the remainder said it'd be less efficient... It's amazing how a "simple" thing like that coupled to a google or two for some scientific papers can put you in a far better position than the so-called salesman.
On talking to a couple of the more sensible companies, they were firmly of the opinion that there are two types of renewable company: those which do their own hard work, and then sell it on the back of its capability, and the rest who are simply there to take middle-class, eco-hand-wringing, Islington-ite money: IE the easy sell to people who want to splash cash on playing the game of "I'm more eco than you". They expect either to get an instant sale or won't waste their own time trying to make a sale.
The biomass was a case in point too - on deciding it was The Thing for us, I googled and googled to try and find the competition at our particular spec and price point. There were two broadly similar, though granted not as clever or advanced, but both slightly cheaper. One company took six weeks to reply to my emails, by which time I had great glee in telling them I'd already ordered, the other has yet to reply, four months on. Go figure.
For reference, the GSHP company who we would have gone with if we could have made it work (and on another building I'd have no hesitation in using) is Kensa - www.kensaengineering.co.uk - again, instead of oodles of shiny graphics or saless
te, look into their library of documents - this is a company of engineers, not salesdrones.The Biomass company was the Efficient Energy Centre - http://www.efficientenergycentre.co.uk/ - who sourced the SHT log/pellet boiler via Euroheat - www.euroheat.co.uk
No worries, we researched into renewables for a good year so feel your pain ;-)
I forgot to add... installers who promise to quote and never do... Wait weeks or even months for the quotes to come through and when they do it is not what was discussed and all this time is lost when doing other renovations at the same time before winter
I forgot to add... installers who promise to quote and never do... Wait weeks or even months for the quotes to come through and when they do it is not what was discussed and all this time is lost when doing other renovations at the same time before winter

Edited by Sleepers on Tuesday 6th September 15:18
Great information RedLeicester, very much appreciated. I think I’ll spend some time looking into the dual pellet/log systems you mentioned. We were very sold on the log burner at the start (we have a bit of woodland and a ton of old timber) but were put off by the management prospect. I don’t really mind the physical labour but don’t want it to be that I “have” to do it. The pellet option might fit the bill there.
A few of the companies we’ve spoken to definitely fall into the categories yourself and Sleepers mention. I’d agree that most of them seem to be missing the point that our primary concern is saving money on current oil costs.
I’ll give the company in Hereford a call and see if they would fancy a trip to sunny Scotland
Regarding the RHI, as I understand it, it would be October 2012 before this is available for domestic installations? Is the RHI for biomass a bit more guaranteed than for ASHP?
A few of the companies we’ve spoken to definitely fall into the categories yourself and Sleepers mention. I’d agree that most of them seem to be missing the point that our primary concern is saving money on current oil costs.
I’ll give the company in Hereford a call and see if they would fancy a trip to sunny Scotland

Regarding the RHI, as I understand it, it would be October 2012 before this is available for domestic installations? Is the RHI for biomass a bit more guaranteed than for ASHP?
I havent got the specific figures to hand, but yes Biomass is a higher figure than both GSHP and ASHP - and don't forget the latter has yet to be confirmed for being covered by the RHI at all due to the research in the UK basically reporting it's poo!
Domestic RHI does indeed kick in next Oct, but the RHI Premium Payment started in August - basically a one-off payment for early adopters signing up now - only applies to Biomass / GSHP / Solar Thermal IIRC.
Domestic RHI does indeed kick in next Oct, but the RHI Premium Payment started in August - basically a one-off payment for early adopters signing up now - only applies to Biomass / GSHP / Solar Thermal IIRC.
[quote=RedLeicester]I havent got the specific figures to hand, but yes Biomass is a higher figure than both GSHP and ASHP - and don't forget the latter has yet to be confirmed for being covered by the RHI at all due to the research in the UK basically reporting it's poo!
quote]
Ahhhhh.... Perhaps thats why I've been asked if my ASHP can be monitored by telemetry
quote]
Ahhhhh.... Perhaps thats why I've been asked if my ASHP can be monitored by telemetry

To quote the DECC:
Solar Thermal Hot Water - £300
Air Source Heat Pump - £850
Ground Source or Water Source Heat Pump - £1250
Biomass boiler - £950
Ironic that they have a payment for ASHP even though they have yet to confirm whether it'll be covered by the RHI at all.... but then they go on to say:
The projected RHI domestic tariffs are as follows (there's a simplespeak document here if you don't want to plough through the EST and DECC longer presentations):
Biomass (under 200kw) - 7.9p
GSHP (under 100kw) - 4.5p
Solar Thermal (under 200kw) - 8.5p
Biomethane (under 200) - 6.8
So again, no ASHP listed at all, but looking at the way those figures are going, I'd guess at it likely being around the same or more likely less than GSHP.
All "guaranteed" and inflation-linked for 20 years, like the FITs for solar panels. In essence, it's money for old rope - assuming it DOES continue for that period, then an early adopter could well pay off an installation within 10 years and have a further 10 years clear "profit" thereafter. That period could well halve or even quarter if you're removing oil as opposed to mains gas. In our case it's circa £3800 RHI, and the removal of £4k on oil... exceptionally quick payback time, and a 200% return on investment in the 20 year period, particularly given the minimal running costs.
DECC said:
Government is also aware of the concerns regarding the performance of heat pumps in situ and preliminary results from heat pump field trials carried out by the Energy Saving Trust showed variable performance, albeit at the domestic scale which will not be supported from the outset. Some of the reasons for the poorly performing heat pumps are understood and solutions are being tested as these trials continue. The industry is also working to improve the design, installation and consumer understanding of these systems and, at the small scale, the MCS can provide assurance about product and installation quality. We will continue to monitor and review the performance of heat pumps in situ.
The RHI premium payment - applicable to installations from the 29th of July this year:Solar Thermal Hot Water - £300
Air Source Heat Pump - £850
Ground Source or Water Source Heat Pump - £1250
Biomass boiler - £950
Ironic that they have a payment for ASHP even though they have yet to confirm whether it'll be covered by the RHI at all.... but then they go on to say:
DECC said:
Treatment of air source heat pumps under the RHI
Air source heat pumps can heat air directly (air to air heat pumps) or use water as the heating medium (air to water heat pumps).
In the medium to long term, we anticipate both of these technologies being deployed widely in the UK across all sectors and playing a significant role in meeting our renewables and carbon targets. We recognise an incentive may be required for that to happen.
The work undertaken by our consultants showed that currently the majority of heat pumps in the commercial and industrial sectors were air to air. In the domestic sector, air to water heat pumps are the predominant technology.
We do not have evidence for the costs of air to water heat pumps outside the domestic sector and are not in a position to provide support for that technology from the start of the RHI.
For air to air heat pumps we need to resolve several issues before we will be ready to include them in the RHI. This includes resolution of how to measure direct air heating, including separating out the heating and cooling output. There is also the wider question of how best to provide support for a technology which is often installed for the purpose of providing cooling to a building but which we also want to be used for heating.
We will be considering how we can include all air source heat pumps in the RHI from 2012.
In the meantime, air source heat pumps in the domestic sector will be eligible for the Renewable Heat Premium Payment, further details of which will be announced in May.
So they're thinking about it...Air source heat pumps can heat air directly (air to air heat pumps) or use water as the heating medium (air to water heat pumps).
In the medium to long term, we anticipate both of these technologies being deployed widely in the UK across all sectors and playing a significant role in meeting our renewables and carbon targets. We recognise an incentive may be required for that to happen.
The work undertaken by our consultants showed that currently the majority of heat pumps in the commercial and industrial sectors were air to air. In the domestic sector, air to water heat pumps are the predominant technology.
We do not have evidence for the costs of air to water heat pumps outside the domestic sector and are not in a position to provide support for that technology from the start of the RHI.
For air to air heat pumps we need to resolve several issues before we will be ready to include them in the RHI. This includes resolution of how to measure direct air heating, including separating out the heating and cooling output. There is also the wider question of how best to provide support for a technology which is often installed for the purpose of providing cooling to a building but which we also want to be used for heating.
We will be considering how we can include all air source heat pumps in the RHI from 2012.
In the meantime, air source heat pumps in the domestic sector will be eligible for the Renewable Heat Premium Payment, further details of which will be announced in May.
The projected RHI domestic tariffs are as follows (there's a simplespeak document here if you don't want to plough through the EST and DECC longer presentations):
Biomass (under 200kw) - 7.9p
GSHP (under 100kw) - 4.5p
Solar Thermal (under 200kw) - 8.5p
Biomethane (under 200) - 6.8
So again, no ASHP listed at all, but looking at the way those figures are going, I'd guess at it likely being around the same or more likely less than GSHP.
All "guaranteed" and inflation-linked for 20 years, like the FITs for solar panels. In essence, it's money for old rope - assuming it DOES continue for that period, then an early adopter could well pay off an installation within 10 years and have a further 10 years clear "profit" thereafter. That period could well halve or even quarter if you're removing oil as opposed to mains gas. In our case it's circa £3800 RHI, and the removal of £4k on oil... exceptionally quick payback time, and a 200% return on investment in the 20 year period, particularly given the minimal running costs.
Gassing Station | Homes, Gardens and DIY | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


