Light bulb quality
Author
Discussion

ChrisnChris

Original Poster:

1,424 posts

246 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
Do normal domestic light bulbs vary in quality?

We have lots in the kitchen (25) mainly a mix of SES & 12v halogen capsules.

I have kept a record (sad I know) of when I replace the individual lamps, sometimes they only last a few weeks. The SES all came from been & queued, the halogen are GE I think.

There is no pattern to the longevity, i.e it's not one single fitting that eats lamps, the time they last is completely random.

Is there a difference in quality or is everything we buy now crap?mad

anonymous-user

78 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
I try only to buy branded ones now, such as Philips with a 5 year guarantee. Keep the receipt. I have taken some back to be changed after a couple of years...

hairyben

8,516 posts

207 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
speaking as a professional spark with many years experience, basically they're all crap today. Dunno why. The "halogen energy saver" (the incandescent lamps that use around 70% power) seem to last better though, worth trying those.

as for the G4's (12v capsules) they should last a decent time, sure you're not overating the fittings? If you can't see a marking I'd stick with 10w.

Kudos

2,674 posts

198 months

Thursday 20th October 2011
quotequote all
crap. I used to buy GU10's from China for 1p each...

ChrisnChris

Original Poster:

1,424 posts

246 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
hairyben said:
as for the G4's (12v capsules) they should last a decent time, sure you're not overating the fittings? If you can't see a marking I'd stick with 10w.
To be fair, these aren't really a problem, other than the actual fitting which gives a border-line connection, but that's another issue (crap quality again, although the purchase price didn't reflect thatfurious)

It's these that cause me most grief
v
v
v
http://www.diy.com/diy/jsp/bq/nav.jsp?action=detai...

So any ideas where they are concerned would be appreciated.
Looked at the Philips and at £20 each they had better be good!!

chris1roll

1,899 posts

268 months

Friday 21st October 2011
quotequote all
When we did up the farm, we fitted 4 2-bulb wall light fittings in the living room. and fitted 8 GE "longlife" 40w Candle bulbs.
The first one didn't blow for two years, and the final one six months or so later.
I haven't been able to find the same bulbs since, and anything else lasted a few months tops.

Edit - in the kitchen we had 9 12w "downlighters" suspended from wires stretched above the work surfaces. These were from IKEA, and we never had to replace a bulb all the time we were there.

The 12v ceiling mounted ones in the bathroom blew a lot more regularly.


don't get me started on the fking 240v GU10's in our current rented kitchen. Within 3 months we had replaced every single one more than once, we've been here a year now and I've lost count. Plus we spend a lot of time cooking under a single 50w bulb. I'm on the verge of just sticking individual 12v transformers on them


Edited by chris1roll on Friday 21st October 23:17


Edited by chris1roll on Friday 21st October 23:19