Dimmer Switch Buzzing
Author
Discussion

nickd01

Original Poster:

636 posts

239 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
Why do all my dimmers buzz when they're on anything other than full? It drives me mad! Can I do anything about it?

Also - when I was in the attic I could feel heat from the spots in the bedrooms through the insulation and the loft boards. Is this normal? Seems like a huge fire risk to me?

Any pointers appreciated.

Thanks

Timbuk2

1,955 posts

179 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
I think the buzzing is down to the resistance that's being put on the circuit - I would like dimmer switches but having had ones that buzz before, and them annoying me, I don't! I will await a reply from someone more knowledgeable than me if non buzzing are available!

Spots get hot also, don't think it's that risky.

kinabalu

242 posts

223 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
Hiya,

Re spots/heat/loft/insulation.

You are right to be concerned, there should be no insulation near the spots, it is a fire risk.

A sensible option enabling your insualtion to be even in coverage is to put upturned terracota plant pots over the spots, ensure they have a drainage hole though to let said heat out. Then you can spread your insualtion up to the pots.

OzzyR1

6,300 posts

256 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
kinabalu said:
Hiya,

Re spots/heat/loft/insulation.

You are right to be concerned, there should be no insulation near the spots, it is a fire risk.

A sensible option enabling your insualtion to be even in coverage is to put upturned terracota plant pots over the spots, ensure they have a drainage hole though to let said heat out. Then you can spread your insualtion up to the pots.
This, the insulation being in contact with a light is a no-no.

Terracotta pots will do the trick or you can buy off the shelf solutions; google downlight fire hoods.

jeff m2

2,060 posts

175 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
I'm sure those "cans" are against code if they are hot.
Don't you have two types in uk, one for lower floors and a more expensive double skin one for top floors. (that are suiyable for contact with insulation)

Humming from the switch is the equivalent of transformer hum, buy a better made switch.

Wings

5,939 posts

239 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
kinabalu said:
Hiya,

Re spots/heat/loft/insulation.

You are right to be concerned, there should be no insulation near the spots, it is a fire risk.

A sensible option enabling your insualtion to be even in coverage is to put upturned terracota plant pots over the spots, ensure they have a drainage hole though to let said heat out. Then you can spread your insualtion up to the pots.
I recently nearly had a fire on one triple dimmer switch. Why I am not sure, but in the case of this dimmer switch, I both replaced the switch, and lowered the wattage of the spot light bulbs, the latter I was not aware had a maximum wattage for each switch circuit.

hairyben

8,516 posts

207 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
Lots of dimmer switches buzz today, it's something to do with todays nasty incandescent lamps too. sure fix is to use better dimmers, in particular trailing edge/intelligent/IQ

jeff m2

2,060 posts

175 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
hairyben said:
Lots of dimmer switches buzz today, it's something to do with todays nasty incandescent lamps too. sure fix is to use better dimmers, in particular trailing edge/intelligent/IQ
Or something to do with them being made by a guy that last week was pulling a rickshaw.

mk1fan

10,860 posts

249 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
If the downlighters are GU10 fitting try fitting LED bulbs. You can get 4W dimmable SMD ones for abot £9 each and the heat out put is very low (the SMD versions are brighter than a 35W bulb but not as bright as a 50W). This low heat out put means less danger when the insulation is piled on over them.

Oh and the dimmer switch maybe on it's way out if it has just started buzzing.

Thirdly, if you do change the bulbs and change the dimmer make sure you get a dimmer that can opperate at the low wattage you'll be showing it. 'Standard' dimmers usually need at least 40W of power through them to work properly.

Edited by mk1fan on Tuesday 1st November 21:02

AlexC1981

5,618 posts

241 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
I put a halogen bulb in mine. No more buzz.



ColinM50

2,689 posts

199 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
Cheaper dimmers will buzz as you say. I worked as a design draughtsman for MK Electric many years ago and was involved in the design of one that didn't buzz and it came out twice the prioe of competitors dimmers. But the main point was it DIDN'T buzz.

Can't see why they'd have changed the design over the years so my advice would be buy an MK one.

SaTTaN

284 posts

271 months

Tuesday 1st November 2011
quotequote all
Oh yeah and when energy saving bulbs say not suitable for use with a dimmer - they say that for a reason smile

Seemed to work ok (was being lazy in finding a replacement) for month but one day faint smell of burning and energy saving bulb in dimmer was starting to burn!

hairyben

8,516 posts

207 months

Saturday 5th November 2011
quotequote all
ColinM50 said:
Cheaper dimmers will buzz as you say. I worked as a design draughtsman for MK Electric many years ago and was involved in the design of one that didn't buzz and it came out twice the prioe of competitors dimmers. But the main point was it DIDN'T buzz.

Can't see why they'd have changed the design over the years so my advice would be buy an MK one.
Or buy varilight IQ range, unless you want to pay twice+ as much for MK to brand it their "intelligent" dimmer;)