My home allegedly is not my castle.
My home allegedly is not my castle.
Author
Discussion

Younez

Original Poster:

1,057 posts

197 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
I own my flat outright and have share of freehold.

The 30 flats have a management company who take care of thing such as gardening and cleaning the communal area etc...

I was contacted by the managing company asking when they could come inside my flat with a director(who in essence is a nosey neighbour) to check I was complying with terms of lease. I asked if this was for all the flats and they said no. I said I don't want you(a stranger) in my flat if there is no reason. They said under the terms of the lease they can enter my property even if I don't want them too.

I thought this was most bizarre and said I choose who comes inside my home not you! I can understand if renting or if I was on holiday and there had been a leak.

This sounds all a bit fishy to me, is this normal?

HRL

3,362 posts

250 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Do they have a set of keys? If so, change the locks.

Younez

Original Poster:

1,057 posts

197 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
HRL said:
Do they have a set of keys? If so, change the locks.
No this is a private residence.

We just hired them to maintain the external and communal parts of the property.


Mandat

4,657 posts

269 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
What does your lease say about this?

Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Does your copy of the lease state what youve said? If so i doubt you have a leg to stand on...

nw28840

1,009 posts

210 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Younez said:
HRL said:
Do they have a set of keys? If so, change the locks.
No this is a private residence.

We just hired them to maintain the external and communal parts of the property.
We have the same setup as you - they have no rights to enter your property, tell them to take a hike !

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Have you looked at your lease?

It's unusual, but certainly not unique. You could ask more for more specific details as to why they want access, but if your lease gives them a right then you have to ask yourself what would be more hassle, letting them into your flat for 10 minutes or messing about with dozens of letters and possibly some nasty fees.

Have you knowingly done anything that might be against the terms of the lease (depending on your lease, this might include keeping pets, using the property for business purposes or the old classic....changing the flooring type without permission).

andye30m3

3,501 posts

285 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
I don't think it's unusual to have something in the lease granting access to the freeholder.

The management company are acting for everyone, I guess they are reacting to a complaint from a neighbour?

Whilst it's annoying if you were affected by a neighbour who you suspected wasn't complying with the lease I expect you'd want them to investigate.

dundarach

6,236 posts

259 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Or alternatively buy some top shelf really good alt porn mags, dress in a nappie and get them round smile

So much fun is about to be wasted here because you're getting all uptight about things.

Use these situations wisely grasshopper!

Younez

Original Poster:

1,057 posts

197 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
andye30m3 said:
I don't think it's unusual to have something in the lease granting access to the freeholder.

The management company are acting for everyone, I guess they are reacting to a complaint from a neighbour?

Whilst it's annoying if you were affected by a neighbour who you suspected wasn't complying with the lease I expect you'd want them to investigate.
But i bought share of freehold, so I am freeholder too.

I have been there the longest out of all the residents 30 years and think all the neighbours like me.

I have heard one of the director of the residents committee is in cahoots with the management company but this is hear say.

Younez

Original Poster:

1,057 posts

197 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
dundarach said:
Or alternatively buy some top shelf really good alt porn mags, dress in a nappie and get them round smile

So much fun is about to be wasted here because you're getting all uptight about things.

Use these situations wisely grasshopper!
smile

Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
There will be freeholder access rights in the lease, there always are, but they won't be a general right of admission.

If you wish to get firm with the neighbour, ask the management co to set out in writing specifically why they want access (just "to check compliance" isn't sufficient), and then grant access for that purpose only on a supervised visit. The purpose has to be "in accordance with lease para 3.4 we wish to check that access to the roof is unhindered" or whatever.

Younez

Original Poster:

1,057 posts

197 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Newc said:
There will be freeholder access rights in the lease, there always are, but they won't be a general right of admission.

If you wish to get firm with the neighbour, ask the management co to set out in writing specifically why they want access (just "to check compliance" isn't sufficient), and then grant access for that purpose only on a supervised visit. The purpose has to be "in accordance with lease para 3.4 we wish to check that access to the roof is unhindered" or whatever.
That would make sense. If there was a leak they would send a builder, if there was a complaint surely someone would tell me.

So does it make no difference that I own share of freehold. I paid £20k for this a few years back thinking it would make my home, my homesmile

Also not sure why they want a director of the resident committee to come along with them. Don't really fancy my neighbour(director) to come in snooping, the ones I know are not home worthy type people either.;)




Edited by Younez on Monday 16th September 15:13

Odie

4,187 posts

213 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
How bizarre...

Could they even do anything if you refuse?

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Odie said:
How bizarre...

Could they even do anything if you refuse?
If a right of access is stated in the lease, then yes, they can get legal, and it's likely to cost the OP lots of money.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Younez said:
But i bought share of freehold, so I am freeholder too.
You are not a freeholder, but a shareholder in the company that owns the freehold.

That said, tell them to get stuffed.

paulrockliffe

16,677 posts

258 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Do you own a share of the freehold or the freehold for your flat?

If the former, you have as much say as any of the other residents, but can obviously be easily outvoted etc. If it's the later then you're on firm ground to refuse I'd think.

Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Zod said:
You are not a freeholder, but a shareholder in the company that owns the freehold.

That said, tell them to get stuffed.
Inkyfingers said:
If a right of access is stated in the lease, then yes, they can get legal, and it's likely to cost the OP lots of money.
Somehow I dont think these two pieces of advice are compatible hehe

NorthDave

2,542 posts

263 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
If you ask them why they want access they should tell you.

I guess they want the representative there to cover themselves. Just tell them they can have access but no need for the representative as you can be present. Then it is just like having workmen in.


Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Cupramax said:
Zod said:
You are not a freeholder, but a shareholder in the company that owns the freehold.

That said, tell them to get stuffed.
Inkyfingers said:
If a right of access is stated in the lease, then yes, they can get legal, and it's likely to cost the OP lots of money.
Somehow I dont think these two pieces of advice are compatible hehe
A small management company owned by the flat owners is unlikely to resort to litigation.