House purchase - seller made omission about subsidence
House purchase - seller made omission about subsidence
Author
Discussion

orangesrule

Original Poster:

1,976 posts

179 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Right, i had my offer accepted about two months ago, all going swimmingly, received the contract yesturday.

However (thankfully) mother was browsing the planning applications for the street, and noticed that an application for the property was withdrawn earlier this year. The site also included a letter of objection from the neighbour, fair enough.

However in this letter of objection, the neighbour clearly details a major subsidence issue and concern over further extension, which was seen to by the original builder, basically the house had to be underpinned and a whole ground floor wall rebuilt in 1992. Now if the seller didn't know this work has been carried out when he bought the property, he certainly does now!

Now obviously i am 99% i don't want to proceed with the purchase in light of this information (surveys didnt pick it up - although the council survey hasn't come through yet....)

Now in the contract, on the property information form - one of the questions is 'Have any notices or correspondence been received or sent (e.g from or to a neighbour, council or government department), or any negotiations or discussions taken place, which affect the property or property nearby? If yes, please give details:'

The seller marking NO for this question.

Now in my eyes that is pretty obvious to me the seller is holding back vital information, which he would certainly have known. This is going to leave me with a potential loss of £1500ish. In this contract it clearly states that the property information form isn't a mandatory requirement to fill out, however it also states 'It is very important that your answers are accurate. If you give incorrect or incomplete information to the buyer (on this form or otherwise in writing or conversation), weather through your estate agent or solicitor or directly to the buyer), the buyer may make a claim for compensation from you.'


What is the likely hood that i would be entitled for compensation for my losses from the vendor, seeing as they have not only withheld information which affects the property, but has lied on the information form.

Obviously i can see why they did it, but it has now cost me a substantial amount of money, and they still havn't sold their property.

Obviously on the bright side, i may lose £1500, but i havnt bought a house i would never be able to insure or sell on. :/




Edited by orangesrule on Saturday 7th December 13:58

greygoose

9,675 posts

226 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
If it was fixed 21 years ago and there is no sign of the subsidence now then does it really matter?

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
I'd limit your compo claim to costs incurred after/as a result of the lie on the questionnaire. Any costs incurred before you got the form returned would be irrecoverable.

elanfan

5,527 posts

258 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
I should get your solicitor to write to the seller outlining the deceit and the costs that you have incurred and ask for a cheque.Obviously they can imply that legal action will follow if not received.

orangesrule

Original Poster:

1,976 posts

179 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
greygoose said:
If it was fixed 21 years ago and there is no sign of the subsidence now then does it really matter?
1) Your buildings insurance asks if the property has EVER suffered subsidence

2) Would you buy a property at full market value knowing there has been a serious subsidence issue. In my eyes its the same as buying a cat C write off.

From the sounds of it the whole kitchen wall (about 16ft long) bowed and started to break up, as well as bowing to a retaining wall to the side of the property, the house had to be underpinned and the kitchen and retaining walls rebuild - it wasn't just a bit of movement.

Edited by orangesrule on Saturday 7th December 14:01

greygoose

9,675 posts

226 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
orangesrule said:
greygoose said:
If it was fixed 21 years ago and there is no sign of the subsidence now then does it really matter?
1) Your buildings insurance asks if the property has EVER suffered subsidence

2) Would you buy a property at full market value knowing there has been a serious subsidence issue. In my eyes its the same as buying a cat C write off.
I would make a reduced offer in light of the information coming to light, but if it has been fixed properly (which it sounds like it has if nothing has happened in the last 20 years) and you like the house then why not?

orangesrule

Original Poster:

1,976 posts

179 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Purchase price was 150k, i don't think an offer of 130k would be unreasonable (14% reduction). They will never accept that though.


Plus would i ever be able to sell the damn thing on, even at a reduced price.

Tribal Chestnut

3,001 posts

213 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
For someone partial to citrus fruits, what's wrong with buying a bit of a lemon?


(sorry!)

Neil - YVM

1,310 posts

230 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Arguably, a property that has been underpinned is now less of a risk than one that has not previously had an issue.

But clearly the seller is being deceitful.

V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Interesting responses... I'm looking at a house needing work due to subsidence and I wouldn't have thought that once fixed anyone would be concerned.

What are the insurance implications once it has been fixed ?

jkh112

23,948 posts

189 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Playing the devils's advocate, I can see an argument that the seller has not been deceitful.
The question you quote is:
'Have any notices or correspondence been received or sent (e.g from or to a neighbour, council or government department), or any negotiations or discussions taken place, which affect the property or property nearby? If yes, please give details:'

I would argue that a letter objecting planning permission and refering to a previous subsidence episode does not affect the property you are buying. It is the previous subsidence which affects the property, but the question you are quoting does not ask that.

I would be surprised if there is not another question which asks specifically about subsidence.

Chrisgr31

14,300 posts

286 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
V8RX7 said:
Interesting responses... I'm looking at a house needing work due to subsidence and I wouldn't have thought that once fixed anyone would be concerned.

What are the insurance implications once it has been fixed ?
Insurance will be available through the insurer that fixed it, other insurers might be cautious.

Personally I think you are wrong, and that most people will be extremely concerned at buying a house that has been subject to a subsidence claim,they might not be right to be but thats another story.


Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
orangesrule said:
Now obviously i am 99% i don't want to proceed with the purchase in light of this information (surveys didnt pick it up - although the council survey hasn't come through yet....)
Why did you proceed without having such a vital document in your hands? If the seller has made a material mis-statement (whether by accident or design) on the PIF then he has to accept the consequences. I don't believe for one moment that he was unaware of the neighbour's letter of objection.

Who can see my comments or objections?

Freedom of Information Act 2000 and Data Protection

Comments on planning applications form part of the statutory register of planning applications, including the name of the person making the comment and their address. The register must be made available for viewing at all reasonable times. All comments submitted on planning applications will be available for public viewing.

Many local authorities put this information online.



orangesrule

Original Poster:

1,976 posts

179 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
I havn't proceeded fully yet!

Just that i've set up my buildings insurance (based on the buyers survey), and set my mortgage up; whilst the solicitor was compiling the searchs, of which she requested the council search at the start of last month, and they havn't produced anything.

But i still have to now cover the cost of these surveys/searchs/mortgage setup/solicitor up to this point when if was made aware of the previous subsidence, i would have either put in a considerably lower offer, or not offered at all.

Busa mav

2,848 posts

185 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
I suggest you make a few enquiries for buildings insurance , telling them about the previous subsidence and see what they say.

Personally, Iwould walk away.

Subsidence on a house is a blight , despite what a few may say here.

If you aren't concerned about insuring the property with whoever you wish , or having problems selling the property then crack on wink

orangesrule

Original Poster:

1,976 posts

179 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Busa mav said:
I suggest you make a few enquiries for buildings insurance , telling them about the previous subsidence and see what they say.

Personally, Iwould walk away.

Subsidence on a house is a blight , despite what a few may say here.

If you aren't concerned about insuring the property with whoever you wish , or having problems selling the property then crack on wink
This is my exact feelings right now, even if it was majorly discounted, i could be a ballache to insure and sell (even at a price to reflect its history), the only advantage of getting it at a hypothetical reduced price, would be a good relative rental return, if i was to go down that route in the future.

Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
orangesrule said:
I havn't proceeded fully yet!

Just that i've set up my buildings insurance (based on the buyers survey), and set my mortgage up; whilst the solicitor was compiling the searchs, of which she requested the council search at the start of last month, and they havn't produced anything.

But i still have to now cover the cost of these surveys/searchs/mortgage setup/solicitor up to this point when if was made aware of the previous subsidence, i would have either put in a considerably lower offer, or not offered at all.
If you've already set up building insurance, why don't you phone the insurer and ask them what the implications of all this will be?

You're assuming the house is going to be uninsurable, but what's to say that the insurers won't say that the lack of further problems in the 20 years since it was repaired means that they consider the subsidence to be written off in the same way as old driving licence points?

blueg33

47,023 posts

255 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
All houses are under pinned, some are just done before they are built!

Seller should have declared it IMO. You need to tell the seller you have discovered this and you need to stop incurring costs because you have to limit the sellers liability to pay compensation

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Neil - YVM said:
Arguably, a property that has been underpinned is now less of a risk than one that has not previously had an issue.

But clearly the seller is being deceitful.
If a house has only been partially underpinned then one part of the house is stronger than the rest, a new extension or a long dry summer or tree growing in the wrong place could all be the catalyst for further subsidence.

There are good reasons the vast majority of Insurers decline properties with previous subsidence

skeeterm5

4,619 posts

219 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
If you have had a proper and full structural survey on the house (not the house buyers report) which doesn't say it is an issue then what's your problem?

S